Amey/Antara/Meenal -- Only talents in II2 - Page 2

Originally posted by: TruthWins

All the best , God bless!

Yup!...Thnx...I Hope u ALl the BEst Too For Ur Fav. Contestant...😊....WHo do u want to win the title?

Originally posted by: smartalec21

well..dude.. i was just callin yr explanation c**p...infact i actually happen to like meenal a lot...next to amey..but i still have to say tht talent wise... karu is far ahead of meenal...even meenal has given some weak performances...and u r askin me abt involvement then i have to honestly say tht i never feel involved in meenal's singin....it's good but not mesmerising...u seem to smitten by her and hence think tht whtever she does is flawless..but i beg to differ...

and P.S...i'm sorry if i've offended u i didn't mean to..i was just expressin wht i felt readin ur post..

Me too!...I've never felt involved in Meenal's Singing....I never felt like saying.."Wow" for her until now....but u never know wht happens......There is some kind of hesitation...something missing in her.....THat's one i agree with Smartlec.....But i agree

well like I said talent wise my favs are Amey, Meenal, Antara in that order.
I want Meenal to win as she is such a sweetgirl at heart.

Originally posted by: TruthWins

well like I said talent wise my favs are Amey, Meenal, Antara in that order.
I want Meenal to win as she is such a sweetgirl at heart.

But my point is......There r here to win something........Win Indian Ido crown.....n they can only do that BY THEIR SINGING......by not their Looks, or not their NATURE...Not to make friends...Not to show how good n humble they r....or not by like how nice he or she is............N performance wise.......deffinatly i think antara is better than meenal.....butagain it's my choice....i know u feel the same way for meenal..........But Really.......i think hard work is done by Antara n Amey !

Originally posted by: smartalec21

well..dude.. i was just callin yr explanation c**p...infact i actually happen to like meenal a lot...next to amey..but i still have to say tht talent wise... karu is far ahead of meenal...even meenal has given some weak performances...and u r askin me abt involvement then i have to honestly say tht i never feel involved in meenal's singin....it's good but not mesmerising...u seem to smitten by her and hence think tht whtever she does is flawless..but i beg to differ...

and P.S...i'm sorry if i've offended u i didn't mean to..i was just expressin wht i felt readin ur post..

Well as I said I respect your views anyways.

If you didn't find moved by Meenal, how about Karunya?

Well karish,
I didn't disagree on the talent of Amey and Antara. Meenal is equal to them.
Talent being equal, the differentiator in my openion is her genuine and good heart.
Thats why Abhi won last year, he is such a simple guy at heart.
If Sandeep was talented, I would also put him there because of his good nature, but he is not so I didn't put him
So its not about Nature, its talent plus good nature.

Originally posted by: TruthWins

Well as I said I respect your views anyways.

If you didn't find moved by Meenal, how about Karunya?

Karunya is Good, but NOT LIKE EXCELLENT....

AGain, his Kawa Kawa wa AWESOME N TOUCHING..!

But LAst week....the song he sung From Hum Tum......he didn't sing it well.......he really dissiopointed me.......like the way he started was not too good 😕...Karunya doesn't impress me n does not make me feel for him as Amey does n Panna use to😭

So i say.....Karunya should be in TOP 5,but should not be Indina Idol 2......

According to me, ANTARA, AMEY N PANNA r TOP 3........But POOR PANNA IS OUT........So in his place i would put either Karunya or Anuj sometimes....

As far as I know about singing, Amey, Meenal, Karunaya were never technically wrong. The best think in three is that they completely know about singing, sur, and can handle themselves easily in both high notes and low notes. So their singing is versatile.
Meenal's best thing is ,she is so perfect in taking "harkats" so easily, even if it is not in the original song. And it is not an easy job.
Amey's best thing is emotions in his songs. u get really involved in his songs.
Antara's last performance was best, otherwise in first few galas she didn't sing well. She is lucky if she got a good voice but sometimes she looks like she is singing in nose. And sometimes I don't get the lyrics because of her pernounciation.

Originally posted by: chitti123

As far as I know about singing, Amey, Meenal, Karunaya were never technically wrong. The best think in three is that they completely know about singing, sur, and can handle themselves easily in both high notes and low notes. So their singing is versatile.
Meenal's best thing is ,she is so perfect in taking "harkats" so easily, even if it is not in the original song. And it is not an easy job.
Amey's best thing is emotions in his songs. u get really involved in his songs.
Antara's last performance was best, otherwise in first few galas she didn't sing well. She is lucky if she got a good voice but sometimes she looks like she is singing in nose. And sometimes I don't get the lyrics because of her pernounciation.

But like if u look at it professionally....I think everyone makes little mistakes...meenal is deffinatly out of sur sometimes..there is not energy in her song......no uniqueness in her song......n i know antara pronounces some words wrong....but i guess i don't think she might know the perfect hindi as others......but she'll learn.....Karunya is good , but not good.........But Amey n Antar r best.....

Well said Karish.
Talents being equal, Meenal can be the idol because of her simplicity.