No Talent except Karunya and Amey - Page 4

Panna is a good performer and also is a good singer.
I won't put him in Karunya/Amey/Meenal league. But sitll he is a good singer and a humble guy. Though my top 4 are Karunya, Amey, Meenal and Antara and now I add Anuj, I still like this guy because he has a good attitude and works hard to make up for the singing gap he has with the others.
He deserves the place he has.
I don't know about Indian Idol, but overall he is a good guy, good singer and performer and will definitely pull crowds, which is one of the necessities for an Indian Idol.

I totally agree with you. I wud love to see Panna sing a tough song to chk his calibre.

Originally posted by: asha123

I have to agree with you kadwiphool. 👏
well noticed... he really is a great performer, but can he sing better than that? 😕

thanks for agreeing! but yea if this show was only about performance then it wouldnt be a singing competition in the first place. i agree panna is better than sandeep and ravi but that's where it ends.

For some reason I don't like Karunya..Amey is good, though!

^lets see....he's been quite a surprise since the alas started. I didn't think panna would be so good!

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

this was clearly shown by the gala of JAN 30TH! these were the only two who sonu nigam praised and didnt mention a single mistake for them... by teh way i've begun to ignore farah khan and anu malik's comments... only sonu is honest and open and RIGHT!

this show is mostly all karunya and amey that's it... and the songs sucked today except karunya's which was good and also hard

Agree ... Karunya, Amey and Meenal have a good potential for be II-Agla Kaun. But, somehow, my gut says Antara will take it this year.

Antara needs to improve her song selection if she plans on moving further in the competition. She needs to break away from the peppy numbers. Amey, Karyuna & Meenal are in a league of their own. 👍🏼 Monali is falling into a rut now as well. Her last two gala performances weren't too good. Now if only the public can learn to appreciate talent. 👍🏼

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Antara needs to improve her song selection if she plans on moving further in the competition. She needs to break away from the peppy numbers. Amey, Karyuna & Meenal are in a league of their own. 👍🏼 Monali is falling into a rut now as well. Her last two gala performances weren't too good. Now if only the public can learn to appreciate talent. 👍🏼

remember they dont pick the songs, sony assigns them to them. so there's nothing they could do about song selection

i am not judging on just one performance but all
amey and karunya are the best
among the girls antara is good and meenal too

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

yea he's the performance king but can he ever sing hard songs?? i highly doubt it

Yes, I totally agree with you, Kadwiphool.

Originally posted by: meghavi

For some reason I don't like Karunya..Amey is good, though!

I think you should watch his performance and listen his songs very carefully and you will start liking him. I think he will be competing in the last four or three or two for Indian Idol.