No Talent except Karunya and Amey - Page 3

Originally posted by: Iq_RkForeva

i think yesterdays gala completely belongs to karunya, he was amazing 👏 👏 👏

but i think amey, panna and meenal were the best out of all the other contestants, me being a panna fan, think he was amazing, and i disagree with peoiple who say that he is all about looks, cuz II2 is about performing u need everything to be II2 looks, persona;ity and above all singing, and i think panna has all that 😉

ID2 is all about singing, performance and looks. I think Karuniya has the highest quality of voice and best performer too. Speaking about versatality in singing, we should see in next few weeks. I think the next Indian Idol will be Karuniya. His performance is outstanig but he will get a tough cpmpetition from Amey, Meenal, Antara and Panna since they have equally high quality voice as him.

Can someone please explain why Panna is so good? Some enlightenment.. anyone? Is there something some of us are missing?

Panna is a good performer and also is a good singer.
I won't put him in Karunya/Amey/Meenal league. But sitll he is a good singer and a humble guy. Though my top 4 are Karunya, Amey, Meenal and Antara and now I add Anuj, I still like this guy because he has a good attitude and works hard to make up for the singing gap he has with the others.
He deserves the place he has.
I don't know about Indian Idol, but overall he is a good guy, good singer and performer and will definitely pull crowds, which is one of the necessities for an Indian Idol.

Thanks for your input harshmm. 😊
I agree with your top choices - only I prefer Antara more to Meenal. I differ in opinion about Panna... I find him lacking somewhere... but certainly give him another chance at it.He may grow on me... Wishing him luck 😃

1 AMEY
2 KARUNAYA
3 MEENAL 👏

i only like amey ... karunya soetimes sucked by amey .. he sings well plus he is a gud performer! 😊
In girls , i like monali and antra but i cant understand that inspite of having such a sweet voice y antra song selection is so stuupid! 😳

For singing, I like Karunya best followed by Amey and in girls Antara fist then Minal followed by Monali. As for Ravi and Panna, I think they are there by fluke...

Originally posted by: harshmm

Panna is a good performer and also is a good singer.
I won't put him in Karunya/Amey/Meenal league. But sitll he is a good singer and a humble guy. Though my top 4 are Karunya, Amey, Meenal and Antara and now I add Anuj, I still like this guy because he has a good attitude and works hard to make up for the singing gap he has with the others.
He deserves the place he has.
I don't know about Indian Idol, but overall he is a good guy, good singer and performer and will definitely pull crowds, which is one of the necessities for an Indian Idol.

Completely agree. I didn't like Panna initially but he does have a likable quality to him and he has done well in the galas.

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Completely agree. I didn't like Panna initially but he does have a likable quality to him and he has done well in the galas.

yea he's the performance king but can he ever sing hard songs?? i highly doubt it

I have to agree with you kadwiphool. 👏
well noticed... he really is a great performer, but can he sing better than that? 😕