Shocked!!! Ravi's entry in II finals - Page 2

I think they should make a rule where a person who has already sung in a music album or movie are not allowed to participate in II. If they have an album, it means that they are already established singers and II should be looking for some unknown talent in the general public. I wouldn't disqualify students of known singers though as far as they have not sung in an album or movie.
Maybe they should also disqualify immediate relatives of known singers or actors. They already have a foothold in the industry and do not need the II platform, they can leave that spot to some unknown upcoming talent. That would have disqualified Neha Kakkar!
Also, they should disqualify people who participated in other TV shows like SRGMP or FG. Now, that would disqualify Ameya and Ravi Tripathi. They already got a chance right?
Just my thoughts. Any comments?
Ameya, Ravi and Neha fans - don't beat me up - no offense intended.

Ravi Tripathi sang the song 'Tumse Milke" which I believe is originally sung by his mentor Suresh Wadkar. He must have come fully prepared but I still was very disappointed with his performace.

Originally posted by: jaysp

I think they should make a rule where a person who has already sung in a music album or movie are not allowed to participate in II. If they have an album, it means that they are already established singers and II should be looking for some unknown talent in the general public. I wouldn't disqualify students of known singers though as far as they have not sung in an album or movie.
Maybe they should also disqualify immediate relatives of known singers or actors. They already have a foothold in the industry and do not need the II platform, they can leave that spot to some unknown upcoming talent. That would have disqualified Neha Kakkar!
Also, they should disqualify people who participated in other TV shows like SRGMP or FG. Now, that would disqualify Ameya and Ravi Tripathi. They already got a chance right?
Just my thoughts. Any comments?
Ameya, Ravi and Neha fans - don't beat me up - no offense intended.

i dont see any chance of ravi or neha winning.. ameya .. we'll hv to wait and watch

i wissh there wasnt any conspiracy. hmm but Kshitij out.cant digest:( But public kiyu kisiko vote karta hey..ye to God ko vi malum nehi hey.

Remember ravinder ravi?

disaster strikes indian idol 2 in the first voting round itself!!! it's very VERY sad to know Kshitij was voted out! He was wayyy better than Ravi! So what if Ravi Tripathi is Suresh Wadkar's student? So what if he teaches singing? When the time comes to perform.... he is bad. Yup... BAD is the word. I really feel sorry for Kshitij. He has much more potential and is definitely more mature!

and yeah jaysp... I agree with your funda of not allowing already established singers to participate!

hope the future rounds are better!

Originally posted by: sid_12354

rubbish..

people dont vote of the basis of singing only.. we all know tht.. thts why some of the contestants tht we think shoudn't be in may get selected and one of them may even end up bcoming indian idol.

its got nothing 2 do with their "connections"

I dont contest the choice of singers by the public. All I am trying to say is that its a tad bit unfair that people with connections get to audition before the celebrity judges and of course if they are good, they get selected.....at the cost of (possibly) more talented people who were useful only when showing footage of long lines outside the audition venues.

Ravi was aweful to say the very least. Kshitij was miles ahead of him. I could have understood if he performed well but his performance, charisma & vocals were below average.

Originally posted by: maka

I dont contest the choice of singers by the public. All I am trying to say is that its a tad bit unfair that people with connections get to audition before the celebrity judges and of course if they are good, they get selected.....at the cost of (possibly) more talented people who were useful only when showing footage of long lines outside the audition venues.

i dont think tht people with "connections" get to audition b4 the judges and the others dont..

in fact i dont even think tht some of the guys u mentioned r tht well connected.

Originally posted by: FrenchieRox

Ravi was aweful to say the very least. Kshitij was miles ahead of him. I could have understood if he performed well but his performance, charisma & vocals were below average.

i think kshitij was the best singer out of the 7.. he definitely shud hv been selected.. kshitij and karunya shud hv been in the top 3 .. the third one i am not sure.. but i liked ravis performance also

Ravis entry to the finals is a bit disappointing. But being a fan of karunya i'm glad public voted him into finals.