Originally posted by: pakeezah
LOL! with shashis ouster a lot of emotions being stirred up and names being
thrown up; the level of support tia is getting on this board only i understand why
she is the frontrunner now for winning idol. well thats her good karma, she must have
earned this adulation in a previous life or something same way prashant did and
sandeep did. she is not to blame if junta is fida over her.
but slotting bhoomi and naushad in the same category as tia as singers.....I know
many will find that laughable, never mind how many people keep reposting their
opinions how so ever many times, it doesnt change the fact that they are much
superior with some scintillating performances to their credit from which no one
can take anything away because its all there on record and utube. u cannot
compare two singers who have given excellent performances in their own genres
to someone who has not had one completely decent performance in the entire
indian idol journey and who has been told more often than not, to please raise
their level.to that of others.
pakeezah jee you are seeing everything in black and white. just because we are standing up for Tia in way does not mean we want her to win. It is all about subjectivity.
OK Tia is an intelligent girl and let me give an example. When she was crowned DRAMA queen she felt bad and said she should have been crowned EMOTIONAL queen. We are using the same metaphor to say Tia should not be teated so harshly. There are other weak singers also.
yes Naushad is way better, but not consistent. Bhoomi IMO is weaker than Tia. So its all very subjective.
Current Affairs
