Isn't this suspicious ??

So almost all people here are happy and content over Remo's elimination.

But.. but.. think about this:
Remo has never been in the danger zone in any of the Gala Results till now.
And suddenly in yesterday's result he is out (that too after singing pretty well as compared to some others)
So, how come he is suddenly eliminated without ever being in danger zone earlier ???
I dont think the support for him must have decreased all of a sudden so much in just 1 Gala.

So I definitely smell something more than fishy here.
imo, the results were knowingly rigged by II officials just to keep the other more liked singers for the next galas. They did not want remo to go any further in the galas.

If u guys remember, even in Indian Idol-1, there was a contestant Ravinder Ravi who almost seemed like he is getting lots of votes, but suddenly got eliminated in the Top 4 gala. So, this kind of thing is not the first time it is happening.

I dont have anything towards or against any II contestant, but feel that this kind of thing is unfair and against the spirit of voting system in a competition.

Nope, if they had wanted to eliminate him, they would have done it much before because he was a weak singer... They wouldn't eliminate Bhavya last week but Remo if it was rigged...

Originally posted by: rahman2005

Nope, if they had wanted to eliminate him, they would have done it much before because he was a weak singer... They wouldn't eliminate Bhavya last week but Remo if it was rigged...

Originally posted by: rahman2005

Nope, if they had wanted to eliminate him, they would have done it much before because he was a weak singer... They wouldn't eliminate Bhavya last week but Remo if it was rigged...

I think they realized the real need to do something like this now only, like an after-reaction as so much has happened and judges were also feeling pissed off.

Originally posted by: SHABARI

there is a point here too..who knows the ones voting for sauabhee and remo were divided in their opinion ,so the votes split....that's why Remo was eliminated😊

In that case, votes should have split from the beginning only.

u guys r not trying 2 understand voting pattern in II till now. Remo had never been in any kind of danger till now. And he gets eliminated like a whiff JLT..
maybe this can help in better understanding and reinforcing my point:

Stage:	Finals
Week:	12/06	12/13	12/20	12/27	01/03	01/10	01/17	01/24	01/31	02/07	02/14	02/21	02/28
Place	Contestants	Results
	Kapil Thapa
	Rajdeep Chaterjee			Btm 4		Btm 2		Btm 3	Btm 2	Btm 3	Btm 4
	Sourabhee						Btm 5				Btm 3
	Torsha Sarkar		Btm 6			Btm 3				Btm 2	Btm 2
5	Remo Ghosh										Elim
6	Bhavya Pandit	Btm 6		Btm 2	Btm 2		Btm 2		Btm 3	Elim
7	Prasenjit Kosambi		Btm 2	Btm 4			Btm 5	Btm 2	Elim
8	Bhanu Pratap		Btm 6				Btm 3	Elim
9	Mohit Lalwani	Btm 2			Btm 3		Elim
10	Kuldeep Singh	Btm 6	Btm 6			Elim
11	Priyanka Negi				Elim
12	Shini Kalvint	Btm 3	Btm 3	Elim
13	Tulika Ganguly	Btm 6	Elim
14	Ananya Mishra	Elim

One among Torsha or Rajdeep was sure to get eliminated yesterday. But Sony wanted them both to stay.
So Remo gets kicked out

Originally posted by: cool.aquarian

I think they realized the real need to do something like this now only, like an after-reaction as so much has happened and judges were also feeling pissed off.



In that case, votes should have split from the beginning only.

u guys r not trying 2 understand voting pattern in II till now. Remo had never been in any kind of danger till now. And he gets eliminated like a whiff JLT..
maybe this can help in better understanding and reinforcing my point:

Stage:	Finals
Week:	12/06	12/13	12/20	12/27	01/03	01/10	01/17	01/24	01/31	02/07	02/14	02/21	02/28
Place	Contestants	Results
	Kapil Thapa
	Rajdeep Chaterjee			Btm 4		Btm 2		Btm 3	Btm 2	Btm 3	Btm 4
	Sourabhee						Btm 5				Btm 3
	Torsha Sarkar		Btm 6			Btm 3				Btm 2	Btm 2
5	Remo Ghosh										Elim
6	Bhavya Pandit	Btm 6		Btm 2	Btm 2		Btm 2		Btm 3	Elim
7	Prasenjit Kosambi		Btm 2	Btm 4			Btm 5	Btm 2	Elim
8	Bhanu Pratap		Btm 6				Btm 3	Elim
9	Mohit Lalwani	Btm 2			Btm 3		Elim
10	Kuldeep Singh	Btm 6	Btm 6			Elim
11	Priyanka Negi				Elim
12	Shini Kalvint	Btm 3	Btm 3	Elim
13	Tulika Ganguly	Btm 6	Elim
14	Ananya Mishra	Elim

One among Torsha or Rajdeep was sure to get eliminated yesterday. But Sony wanted them both to stay.
So Remo gets kicked out

Originally posted by: cool.aquarian

So almost all people here are happy and content over Remo's elimination.

But.. but.. think about this:
Remo has never been in the danger zone in any of the Gala Results till now.
And suddenly in yesterday's result he is out (that too after singing pretty well as compared to some others)
So, how come he is suddenly eliminated without ever being in danger zone earlier ???
I dont think the support for him must have decreased all of a sudden so much in just 1 Gala.

So I definitely smell something more than fishy here.
imo, the results were knowingly rigged by II officials just to keep the other more liked singers for the next galas. They did not want remo to go any further in the galas.

If u guys remember, even in Indian Idol-1, there was a contestant Ravinder Ravi who almost seemed like he is getting lots of votes, but suddenly got eliminated in the Top 4 gala. So, this kind of thing is not the first time it is happening.

I dont have anything towards or against any II contestant, but feel that this kind of thing is unfair and against the spirit of voting system in a competition.

Very good decision...Rajdeep and Torsha are liked by majority of junta(not regional) and should be in top 2

hmmmmmm....let me get this.straight...II has a universal format ...that's why even if the sponsors and producers wanted a desired contestant to win ..they couldn't save the far better singer Karunya ....and a better singer Amit Paul....because of the voting machines of the other 2 ....

I agree that voting patterns can change but voting results are not transparent so the producers can do whatever they feel like.

I think that the hole thing was a bit fishy from fridays episode, coz if u look at last weeks episode wen remo singing Faran Aktar is there
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQ0WDxTlRps
And then listen to his performance on Friday
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jrrf3IzXdMY
it doesnt quiet sound like him