SPOILER 17'th jan

Page

Next Last

laughthorn

@laughthorn

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

BHANU PRATAP is out....the best result of indian idol galas after kuldeep

THREE CHEERS👏

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ruhi gandhi

@Ruhihutijufan

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

oh ...i dont know but am happy bhanu is out but sad for him....

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

malvika

@malvikamodi

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

thnk god!....janta saved d girls.........i m so relieved!

Quote

mewwzik

@mewwzik

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

I personally thought he really sang well last night. Probably the best! I wonder howcome you guys are happy, a good singer exited!

Edited by mewwzik - 16 years ago

Quote

yipee

@yipee

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

he was gud but others were better

Quote

laughthorn

@laughthorn

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

probaly remo deserved more to be out,

BUT REMO WILL NEVER BE OUT

and we all know the reason why;)

same for kapil/sourabhee

so evenif bhanu was a better singer tha them, his exit is justified

AT LEAST RAJDEEP/TORSHA are safe....

this bhanu/remo shud have been out before Anaya and Tullika the 2 pretty ladies...

Quote

str8tok

@str8tok

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: laughthorn
BHANU PRATAP is out....the best result of indian idol galas after kuldeep

THREE CHEERS👏

Originally posted by: seemahujufan

oh ...i dont know but am happy bhanu is out but sad for him....

Now, it is clear that Bhanu is a major talent - one of the best of those left on this show. So let me try to understand this- you guys are ok with Bhanu being voted out while complete incompetents like Remo continue to remain in the show?

Wow. (After this, I for one am now truly, really curious to understand how your head works).

Care to explain the logic (or lack of it) behind the reasoning that spurred you on to publicly voice apparently rabid-sounding conclusions like "BHANU PRATAP is out....the best result " and "...am happy bhanu is out ..." ?

Thanks!

Quote

laughthorn

@laughthorn

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

i already aid remo and kapil should have been out long ago

But all said and sone, it is better that Bhanu and not some majorly talented one like Torsha/prasenjit/rajdeep/sourabhee are not out.......................

Quote

0mega Galaxy

@0mega Galaxy

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

I m happy that bhanu is out because he was very over confident abt his singing. trying to show that he is the only one who could sing.

This is not to say that I would not have been happy if Remo got out. perhaps i would have been more happy.. But i think he has a huge votebank out there in the public voting for him. so it looks like he will hang out couple of more episodes even though he is the worsts singers in all the 4 seasons of Indian Idol.

Quote

str8tok

@str8tok

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: laughthorn
i already aid remo and kapil should have been out long ago

But all said and sone, it is better that Bhanu and not some majorly talented one like Torsha/prasenjit/rajdeep/sourabhee are not out.......................

Thanks for your response.

In my opinion- Bhanu, Sourabhee, Torsha and Prasenjeet are the only ones that are not only technically accurate most of the time (I am a trained keyboardist that has performed with gigs and consider myself qualified to judge this attribute) but most importantly-also have a unique or interesting voice.

By contrast, I found Rajdeep's voice quality insipid and boring though he always sings in key. I preferred Mohit's voice by far because of its punchy, lively tenor (recall his rendition of "Bijuria").

In II4, stage performance, charisma and flair are as important components of the title as voice quality. From that angle, I would rate Bhanu's loss a bigger setback than compared to losing Rajdeep, Prasenjeet or Torsha.

Worst would have been losing Sourabhee since after keeping all the "Idol-worthy" qualities in mind I consider her the most deserving contender for the II4 title now especially after her Jan 16 performance.

Best elimination scenario today would have been Remo- but since he seems to have the undeserved protection of angels - I would have accepted Kapil or even Bhavya or any of the others except Sourabhee, Bhanu, Torsha or Prasenjeet.

Bummer.

Edited by str8tok - 16 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

SPOILER 17'th jan

Related Topics

Explore Topics