Indian Idol 14 - Performance Discussion (18&19 Nov'23) - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.1k

Users

8

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago
#11

Piyush was phenomenal and the mother relating the story about her son before he sang just tore my heart. It was beautiful!smiley19


Overall it was a great episode and I agree with altgr I love this season mainly because of the judges panel but I do agree that I do not want the usual gimmicks and all, I’m just shocked and sad that such a great season isn’t getting the ratings and I hope they don’t associate that with Sanu da and Shreya. The contestants are doing great and I don’t have a clear fave yet but I’m loving their performances and hope that the ratings improve after the World Cup ends

IbuHatela thumbnail
Navigator Thumbnail 2nd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#12

I really enjoyed Saturday's episode for the most part.

I really like Surendar. He was a bit erratic down the stretch today, but he still did pretty good. I love his voice and the energy it exudes.

Vaibhav was also very energetic. He always is, but it was another level today. Not my favorite performance of his, but he is a lot of fun every time.

Piyush had a phenomenal return to form. He's amazing when singing soulful songs like today.

Utkarsh is always terrific.

Mahima did the best she could with what she had to work with. They gave her a song that was out of her comfort and she did a quality job.

Muskan is so consistent. I could listen to her all day.

Performance of the day goes to Kumar Sanu. Him singing a Kishore classic? Sensational.

I'm excited for tomorrow's episode. Sadhana Sargam and Anuradha episodes are always fantastic on any singing show. Full of great vibes and performances. I can't wait to see who will sing Saat Samundar, and to find out of they do proper justice to the greatest disco song in Bollywood history.

A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 1 years ago
#13

Piyush, Vaibhav & Muskan were the highlights for me this episode.

minakrish thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#14

This weekend’s star performers in my opinion were:


18th Nov: Piyush and Vaibhav

19th Nov: Dipan, Subhadeep and Menuka

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#15

We had a Diwali ball in my city and I missed yesterdays episode. I won’t be able to watch the whole whisper, any performances I shouldn’t miss?

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#16

Lovely episode. Songs from the 90’s are lovely, they’re a certain magic to them. I’ve grown up listening to these songs, so it was certainly nostalgic.


Obom - pehla nasha - such a beautiful song. Like Shreya said it’s a song almost everyone has associated with their first love. He sang it beautifully. These are the kind of songs that suit him. His singing was effortless like always. But I still maintain, as much as I enjoyed the song, he’s not worthy of being in this competition amongst others who are clearly better singers.


I didn’t catch the name of the guy that sang next but he sang - Teri umeed tera intezaar and mujhe neend na aaye. Brilliant!! Im amazed at the talent this year. Two very different songs the first with very low notes, the second with almost no low notes. Im happy he got two different songs - perfect to show his versatility.


Ananya - tu Mera hero/dhak dhak karne laga - she’s my winner. I’ve only heard her twice and each time she’s been outstanding. She gets the finer nuances of the songs so correct each time. Even the judges pointed it out. I haven’t watched the show regularly, so I don’t know if she has, but I’d like a dance song or something similar from her, just to see if she’s as versatile as I think she is.


Shubhodip- adayein bhi hain/ jabse tumko dekha hai sanam. I didn’t enjoy his first performance as much as his second, but he was flawless in both. I am trying to rack my brain to come up with a reason for not enjoying the first one much, but I can’t fault him for anything. I remember when I watched the show last, I liked him even then. He’ll go far but I want a girl to win this time.


Adya - mainu ishq da lageya rog - I don’t know if she had a cold or something but she sounded quite husky. I remember even last time she had a heavy and husky voice but today it was more pronounced. Nothing wrong with a voice that’s not typically sweet - I love Jaspinder Narula - but her voice quality also has smoothness to it which is missing in Adya. Sorry to say, but this was the worst performance today by miles.


Menuka - chupke se and jeeyein to jeeyein Kaise- last week I was probably the only one that didn’t enjoy her performance and reading others reviews, I was questioning my judgement. Today when I started listening to her I was surprised, I LOVED her first performance. It was beyond what I expected, but the second performance was so so for me. I won’t say it was bad, because it was decent. Just that when you sing the first song so well, expectations are higher. Also I think her second song needed someone with a stronger voice projection. Menuka’s voice is too sweet and lacks a strong throw- which means that not all soft Melodie’s will sound good in her voice. I believe she’s classically trained - I would love to hear something semi classical from her. Don’t think she’d do justice to peppier numbers, but I’m happy to be proved wrong.


Maithili - goonji si hai - what an improvement from the last I heard her. It was a decent performance, but compared to the other singers she’s clearly weak. In my opinion, in the high notes she was half a scale (at least) lower than the original. Her scale range is pretty limited (she’s not the only one). She should be more careful with her song selection if she wants to stay.

reborn-re thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Raina101

Lovely episode. Songs from the 90’s are lovely, they’re a certain magic to them. I’ve grown up listening to these songs, so it was certainly nostalgic.


Obom - pehla nasha - such a beautiful song. Like Shreya said it’s a song almost everyone has associated with their first love. He sang it beautifully. These are the kind of songs that suit him. His singing was effortless like always. But I still maintain, as much as I enjoyed the song, he’s not worthy of being in this competition amongst others who are clearly better singers.


I didn’t catch the name of the guy that sang next but he sang - Teri umeed tera intezaar and mujhe neend na aaye. Brilliant!! Im amazed at the talent this year. Two very different songs the first with very low notes, the second with almost no low notes. Im happy he got two different songs - perfect to show his versatility.


Ananya - tu Mera hero/dhak dhak karne laga - she’s my winner. I’ve only heard her twice and each time she’s been outstanding. She gets the finer nuances of the songs so correct each time. Even the judges pointed it out. I haven’t watched the show regularly, so I don’t know if she has, but I’d like a dance song or something similar from her, just to see if she’s as versatile as I think she is.


Shubhodip- adayein bhi hain/ jabse tumko dekha hai sanam. I didn’t enjoy his first performance as much as his second, but he was flawless in both. I am trying to rack my brain to come up with a reason for not enjoying the first one much, but I can’t fault him for anything. I remember when I watched the show last, I liked him even then. He’ll go far but I want a girl to win this time.


Adya - mainu ishq da lageya rog - I don’t know if she had a cold or something but she sounded quite husky. I remember even last time she had a heavy and husky voice but today it was more pronounced. Nothing wrong with a voice that’s not typically sweet - I love Jaspinder Narula - but her voice quality also has smoothness to it which is missing in Adya. Sorry to say, but this was the worst performance today by miles.


Menuka - chupke se and jeeyein to jeeyein Kaise- last week I was probably the only one that didn’t enjoy her performance and reading others reviews, I was questioning my judgement. Today when I started listening to her I was surprised, I LOVED her first performance. It was beyond what I expected, but the second performance was so so for me. I won’t say it was bad, because it was decent. Just that when you sing the first song so well, expectations are higher. Also I think her second song needed someone with a stronger voice projection. Menuka’s voice is too sweet and lacks a strong throw- which means that not all soft Melodie’s will sound good in her voice. I believe she’s classically trained - I would love to hear something semi classical from her. Don’t think she’d do justice to peppier numbers, but I’m happy to be proved wrong.


Maithili - goonji si hai - what an improvement from the last I heard her. It was a decent performance, but compared to the other singers she’s clearly weak. In my opinion, in the high notes she was half a scale (at least) lower than the original. Her scale range is pretty limited (she’s not the only one). She should be more careful with her song selection if she wants to stay.

Menuka is really good with what she does and even I would love to see her trying fast songs and
see how she does. If you get time do watch Saturday episode too everyone sang beautifully and do give your review what ever you feel because everyone has different opinion and perspective.

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: reborn-re

Menuka is really good with what she does and even I would love to see her trying fast songs and
see how she does. If you get time do watch Saturday episode too everyone sang beautifully and do give your review what ever you feel because everyone has different opinion and perspective.

I will try to watch it, if I do I will review it here.

IbuHatela thumbnail
Navigator Thumbnail 2nd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#19

Sunday's episode, for me, was the best episode since the live shows began.

Obom was very good per usual. It was nice to hear Sadhana maam sing with him.

Dipan was also very good as usual, but you could feel an extra amount of soul in his performance today. I'm glad Kumar Sanu gave him all the credit he did because he deserved it.

Kumar Sanu's live singing is always wonderful. So are all of his songs, but every time we get to hear him is a gift.

I loved Ananya's performances. Soulful in her first and sensual in her second. She showed her verssatility and while she isn't perfect, she is consistent and delivers great performances on a weekly basis.

Subhodeep was also as good as usual.

Vishal nailed it with regards to Adhya. She had been struggling lately and needed to rebound badly. This was her best performance since the auditions/theater rounds. I don't know how long she can stay afloat, if it's too late or all that but I was very happy to see her do well again.

Shreya singing Menu Ishq Da just, uff. Sensory overload.

I was going to save this for the end, but it brings me so much joy to see how much love and respect the panel has for each other. We all know that Vishal and Shreya revere Sanu ji, how much respect he has for them, etc. We know Sadhana ji, Anuradha ji and Sanu ji are forever connected. But hearing Shreya get so much praise from Anuradha, who she reveres? She deserves all of that. You can tell how much it meant to her.

The reason why I but the above point so early is because of how impossible it is to elevate the show after such a thing happens. You need a transcendent performer to follow that. Often times, the best singer of most seasons on any show can't do it justice. And they gave Menuka that spot. And she not only lived up to it, she took it to another level. Seeing legends like Anuradha and Sadhana ji crying and showing her so much love and respect is all you need to know about the level of singer that Menuka is. It's beyond winning the trophy at this point. She's transcended this show. Her performances are events of their own accord.

I almost feel bad for Maithili. The 20 minutes that preceded her performance were on par with the best 20 minutes you'll see on any show, whether it's a singing show or anything else. The sounds, the vibes, the feels, all were perfect. Unlike with Menuka, who is consistently great and was trusted with following several great performances and unforgettable moments, Maithili was asked to follow those things AND Menuka's performance, And Shreya and Sadhana ji singing together. She had no chance today. She did a good job singing a song that is not in her element. It was one of her few performances I didn't forward. But she got completely dwarfed, including while Sadhana and Shreya sang with her.

Perforance of the day is undeniable: Hussain and Sanu ji rocked Dhak Dhak so hard that it might be the greatest performance of anyone for the entire season. Finale wala performance.

So to summarize, everyone did at least very good. Some of the performances were great. What took this show to the next level, along with Menuka's performance,was the intangibles. The stories between the guests and Sanu da, their performances along with Shreya and Sanu da, and with the contestants. The vibes were so good. And closing with that iconic gem? How do you top that? It's a good thing there's six days until the next episode, because it was such a perfect episode rich with so much great content that it will fulfill your appetite for the whole week. It's a good thing they gave no preview of next week either, because it's not needed and probably won't live up to this episode anyways.

altgr thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#20

Missed Sunday's episode as WC finale was going on. Will watch later.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".