Please...... can we have less of her?

Dear Sony Tv,

It is with great forbearance that we put up with the likes of Neha Kakkar & HR as judges - in fact they are permanent fixtures in most reality shows. If we still keep watching the show, it is for the contestants & our love for music.

Is it essential to show Kakkar’s face every 2 seconds?? Even when the guest speaks, we are bombarded by ma’m kakkar’s close-ups. In the Republic Day episode we had to suffer the onslaught of kakkar ma’m’s myriad expressions. Seems like apart from crying & laughing, she has perfected another expression of incredulity for this season, which is mostly reserved for SMP’s performance. All together, it is taking a toll on our nerves.
since we want to continue watching the show, can we have less of her please???

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

Dear Sony Tv,

It is with great forbearance that we put up with the likes of Neha Kakkar & HR as judges - in fact they are permanent fixtures in most reality shows. If we still keep watching the show, it is for the contestants & our love for music.

Is it essential to show Kakkar’s face every 2 seconds?? Even when the guest speaks, we are bombarded by ma’m kakkar’s close-ups. In the Republic Day episode we had to suffer the onslaught of kakkar ma’m’s myriad expressions. Seems like apart from crying & laughing, she has perfected another expression of incredulity for this season, which is mostly reserved for SMP’s performance. All together, it is taking a toll on our nerves.
since we want to continue watching the show, can we have less of her please???

Totally agree with you. Day by day Neha is getting worst. HR gaga over Nihal's performance. Also when a contestant is performing, camera mostly on SMP to show her expressions where as a quick roll by on other contestants.

Can we have no more of her.

There are so many more talented people in the music industry who deserve that seat. Neither her comments are helpful nor does her being there make any sense.

Esp when there were guests like Pyareji, Javed Akhtar, Jatin-Lalit, Sonu Nigam have graced the stage...then there's Neha.

Idk what's wrong with the creative team. Get newer and better judges. This is getting monotonous af.

Originally posted by: Ashley.Tisdale

Can we have no more of her.

There are so many more talented people in the music industry who deserve that seat. Neither her comments are helpful nor does her being there make any sense.

Esp when there were guests like Pyareji, Javed Akhtar, Jatin-Lalit, Sonu Nigam have graced the stage...then there's Neha.

Idk what's wrong with the creative team. Get newer and better judges. This is getting monotonous af.

I have wondered whether she is paying the channel or the makers! What is her claim to fame? Honestly, I barely knew about her before she started judging these shows! She is so besur & in no position to comment & judge any of the contestants. All are way above her.
And on top of everything else her drama. Now, before the season ends the Kakkar siblings & their parents will make an appearance & all will have a cry fest 😳
HR also had me in stitches when he cried remembering his bro! Overacting ki Dukaan. 😡. No wonder he is a flop actor!
Vishal ; though a good composer cannot appreciate classical genres. Wish they had Shaan , kavita K; Salim, Atul -Ajay, or Javed Ali.

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

I have wondered whether she is paying the channel or the makers! What is her claim to fame? Honestly, I barely knew about her before she started judging these shows! She is so besur & in no position to comment & judge any of the contestants. All are way above her.
And on top of everything else her drama. Now, before the season ends the Kakkar siblings & their parents will make an appearance & all will have a cry fest 😳
HR also had me in stitches when he cried remembering his bro! Overacting ki Dukaan. 😡. No wonder he is a flop actor!
Vishal ; though a good composer cannot appreciate classical genres. Wish they had Shaan , kavita K; Salim, Atul -Ajay, or Javed Ali.

I think she might be slashing her fee for more footage time.

Her claim to fame is buttering up T Series lol. Nothing special or grand about her. Average at the best.

Thats the irony na. When my dad watched Indian Idol for the first time, he saw Neha commenting on Nilanjana's performance (we were watching season 10) and said kya zamaana hai, jinko kuch nahi aata voh judge hai aur talented logon ko struggle karna padhta hai.

Lol everytime they bring the entire family its such a crap fest. Does Sony's marketing team have no access to Twitter ?? The amount of bashing there is 🤣

And the creative team thinks the TRP are due to Neha...lol no, people watch it for the participants.

They need versatile music directors from the 90s as judges; coz from 2000s only HR and Sajid (Wajid) understand all types of music. Even Salim Sulaiman are more westernised. Ajay Atul, as much as I love them, they make better guests than full time judges.

For special guests they should get Pyarelal-ji, Anandji sir, Usha Khanna (first female music director)...like a golden era special.

I had said previously, singers only judge singing. MDs would judge the overall performance and if a singer's job gets affected by for ex the orchestra, they would ask for a redo and not blame the singer for something being off.

I’d love to see new judges for next season

Neha and HR are too busy competing with the camera and with who can cry the most . I’m pretty sure HR is outdoing Neha in the makeup department as well

True, as much as I like Vishal (because he doesn’t get into hysterics), he doesn’t seem to understand classical music. He prefers more modern music.

I have absolutely no words for Neha. She’s just famous for being famous. She butchers every song she sings. How can she judge another?

While I’d like to believe HR understands different genres of music better than the other two, he is too dramatic at times.

There are so many better suited people to call, some of whom I’ll list.

Udit Narayan

Kumar Sanu

Alka Yagnik

Shaan

Shreya Ghoshal

Sunidhi Chauhan

Kavitha Krishnamoorthy

Rajesh Roshan

Sonu Nigam

Shankar Mahadevan

Ismail Darbar

Sajid Khan

Vishal Bhardwaj

Jaspinder Narula

Sadhna Sargam

Arijit Singh

Lol she was a contestant in Indian Idol season 2! She was only 16-17 when she participated in that season that’s why she’s a judge because of her recent amount of “hits” with remakes and she and Monali Thakur being the two contestants out of that season that made it far in their careers.

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

True, as much as I like Vishal (because he doesn’t get into hysterics), he doesn’t seem to understand classical music. He prefers more modern music.

I have absolutely no words for Neha. She’s just famous for being famous. She butchers every song she sings. How can she judge another?

While I’d like to believe HR understands different genres of music better than the other two, he is too dramatic at times.

There are so many better suited people to call, some of whom I’ll list.

Udit Narayan

Kumar Sanu

Alka Yagnik

Shaan

Shreya Ghoshal

Sunidhi Chauhan

Kavitha Krishnamoorthy

Rajesh Roshan

Sonu Nigam

Shankar Mahadevan

Ismail Darbar

Sajid Khan

Vishal Bhardwaj

Jaspinder Narula

Sadhna Sargam

Arijit Singh

You missed and forgot to add, Javed Ali :)

I remember Javed Ali used to judge Sa Re Ga Ma Pa (if I’m correct), but I never watched it much and this forgot. But yes him too