Salman Ali - Page 4

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Salman has sung lower notes as well not sure why everyone thinks he sings in high notes.

His Chalo Bulava Aaya Hai was almost fully in lower range except for intro and ending. Chunar was also lower and this week he's singing Aayat ki tarah so I think hes quite versatile.

Even if he isnt versatile, who cares lol...him in his form is still better than everyone else lol

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Salman has sung lower notes as well not sure why everyone thinks he sings in high notes.

His Chalo Bulava Aaya Hai was almost fully in lower range except for intro and ending. Chunar was also lower and this week he's singing Aayat ki tarah so I think hes quite versatile.

Even if he isnt versatile, who cares lol...him in his form is still better than everyone else lol

Versatility is overrated. All singers don't need to be versatile. If you are versatile then that is great for you, it is a plus. But it is not necessary. Did we care about Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan being versatile?

Salman is an awesome singer and a master in the field at this young age. He has the potential to be a legend in this field.all singers are trained on this show but no one can match his caliber the way he can sing low notes as well as very high notes. In the name of versatility we lose out on such good singers. Where in the Indian idol format Is it written that you have to sing rock songs along with classical ...if that is the case then not even 1 singer will qualify for this competition.

Low notes or high notes ... what does it matter? What matters is the emotions he puts into each rendition. Salman sings with such emotions that there has rarely been a guest who left with dry eyes.

All great comments about versatility not being the necessity in a competition.

If a singer is versatile that's great but if not let them be masters of their genres. I remember one SaReGaMaPa season I think it was where the contestants were a mix of ghazal singers, classical singers, and others too. If only singers who can sing all kinds of songs are chosen on the shows how do the others with great caliber get an exposure..

Originally posted by: MasoomaBukhari

i hate to say how talented ones like shomyo avanti biswajit have got out and not salman n nitin..

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Biswajit and talented? HAHAHH Please.

Yes I agree...Soumyo - when in form is right up there with Salman when Salman is in form too.

Somo shouldve stayed longer than the likes of Vibhor, Kunal and Ankhush - who are all AVERAGE singers.

I am glad some of you agree that Salman sings less and screams more and Nitin is sort of following him as well. But we know the judges will make sure Salman wins