CVS....Direction lost somewhere??

prettypri thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
We really laud the social message conveyed in the episode aired on New Year's Eve...there were a lot of helpful takeaways from that..
Remain alert.
Make use of phone apps and at the first sign of trouble make sure you alert a trusted one of your location.
Don't get scared and cower down...fight back and keep fighting till help arrives.

Most importantly it was conveyed that when such incidents happen it is not the fault of the girl but the thinking of such men who consider women as objects of pleasure. There is a need to therefore educate boys and men on how to respect women and keeping girls locked up or restricting their attire is no solution...

👏👏 To this.

However after this the portrayal of the state of the victim and the reaction of the family went a bit awry and lacked the same sensitivity. No offense meant but some of what we saw was not relatable given the situation!

When such an incident occurs the girl is totally traumatised and tends to be terrified of the male touch atleast immediately. And the family members close ranks around her..to keep her safe..to,protect her..to ensure that nightmares don't shake her awake.

Yet yesterday we saw Arzoo being left alone by Nausheen and then Zara too. Zara was asked to go and sleep by Zaki but why wasn't Nausheen around? How could she leave her traumatised daughter alone ...why wasn't she by her bedside? That was hard to understand.

After this Zaki clambers onto the bed...he may be a friend to Arzoo but in that situation that was so unwarranted..he could have sat nearby..in fact there was no need for him to stay at all..Zara could have slept beside Arzoo on that bed holding her hands which is what she was doing anyway.

Zaki holding Arzoos hands in her sleep..woke her up...she wanted to shake off his touch and she screamed for help..and no one heard..no one came running...that was unbelievable..and Arzoo getting comforted by Zaki and going back to sleep was too...it would be more believable for her to have called for her family members in that scared state...not accept Zakis comfort so easily...after what she went through.

After this Sahir made his entry into the room and leaned so close and said what he wanted to...and no one realised that either..Zaki was sleeping soundly..again no one cared that another man was so close to a girl who should have been dead scared in this situation..

These instances of Zaki and Sahir entering Arzoos room and later Nausheen happily saying Zaki sitting on Arzoos bedside the whole night was why she could soundly sleep are going against the grain of normal reactions in this situation...they dilute the message that is sought to be conveyed by this track..

In order for it to be truly effective this discrepancy should have been taken care of as well...so that the portrayal could be more realistic and sensitive.

And last but not the least we all know that this is the story of SaAz..Zaki Arzoo is not happening.
So it's inexplicable that such a scene was shown with Zaki and Arzoo at such a sensitive point in the story...was there a need for it at all? What purpose did it really serve other than show insensitivity to the victims plight?


Edited by prettypri - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.5k

Users

12

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Yesterday epi was totally direction less ... in fact if i see it in continuity of thursday's it didn't fit even then ... and the whole zaki sleeping in room fiasco ... nausheen not there ... just took the cake ... who directed it? Who wrote it? Who executed it? Like seriously?
Also in sahir's monologue direction and editing was bad ... only saving grace were hc, his expression and that voice in yesterday's epi
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
CVs are over-doing the ladka-ladki dosti angle, come on CVs, we are in 21st century, and i have a dozen of male friends, but late at night, will i allow, or will my mother allow any of them to lie beside me on the same bed ? Friendship is a beautiful bond, and CVs have made it into something so cheap and creepy now.. Moreover, zaki was snoring as if he was drunk and slept and lost it and he didnt even realize that 2 other people in the form of sahir and samaira entered the room.. then what was the use of him being a bodyguard come mahaan lover come cheap and leech friend ?

And the SaAz moment was beautiful, and it was a tear jerker indeed, and the moment was so poignant and calm, you can feel the love and pain between them, whereas whenever zaki is near arzoo, all i sense is a in ur face lovey dovey friendship, which neither goes well down with the fact that Zaki still wants arzoo, and god knows for why ?


CVs, i am appalled, because you know that you are catering to the women audience more, catering them the islamic culture, and then you sow this ?
sam123_0 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Over dose of anything is not good... Be it friendship... Be it pain...


They have built this friendship to such an extent that we feel like puking... Then there is build up of sahir's pain... Hope they justify it properly... Too much of kurti/anam/nausheen crying-fainting... Is just plain annoying



Direction of this show needs to improve a great deal...




664269 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
and one more thing, is it just me or many of u have felt the same.. CVs have gone wrong here big time, because i assume they wanted us to pity over zaki and arzoo, and then most of us are not even touched by their rona dhona, leave feeling pity or sympathy for them... is it the poor writing, direction or just plain bad acting of Shehbaz and Shivya ? Shivya has improved being a newbie, but i feel she needs to tone down, and Shehban, the more i expect a good performance, he fails, especially his dialogue delivery is monotonous and has the same expression in every damn scene.. No wonder its hard to connect
premeeristry thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Also yesterday there was an editing blooper in this scene 😕...when Sahir came Zaki was already sleeping with a blanket 🤔






then they showed Sahir covering him with blanket... 😕




they have this editing scene problem from start

true2heart thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
It was one of the most disappointing episodes to date, In the garb of showing Uber rape and sensitizing people about it, they actually made a huge mess of it. They butchered every character just to show how concerned Zaki was about Arzoo. You are right, a molestation victim will abhor any touch because the fear sets in so bad. and it takes a long time for the person to get over it.
Here it was treated as a joke literally. The girl is brought home instead of being taken to a hospital for treatment of injuries and trauma, and then her immediate family abandons her for the night to be left in the arms of another man. Wah wah! One holds her hand and sleeps right next to her, totally in bad taste and the other one walks in to say sorry to her, and bends so close to her that despite him being the lead it looks very inappropriate.

And someone explain to me why Zaki had to wake up the already sleeping Zara to tell her that he will sit next to Arzoo and that she should go to sleep ? Wasn't she already sleeping next to her sister comfortably? Arzoo had been given an injection to help her rest so what was he planning to do next to her anyways ? N nausheen had absolutely no objection to that? Infact she glorified it to everyone concerned ?

Sahir is suddenly begun to look weak and incompetent. His continuous fight with himself, his masochism, his confusion about Arzoo and his inability to accept her love coz of Zeenat has begun to grate on my nerves. Another thing that bothers me is that he hurts himself badly each time, draws blood but in the next episode all the injuries vanish as if he were a superman. No scars, no bandaid, nothing ? The repetition of the same old ghisa pita dialouges now have no effect at all, Yesterday neither did Rehman's threat made me sit up and take notice nor did Sahir's tears move me, for the first time there was a total disconnect from the characters.

If the cvs do not step up to tie loose ends and make some palatable semblance of the story, even Harshad's superb acting will not be able to save the serial from its doom.








crazzykuri thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
OMG! I don't know how to count the number of people not agreeing with this scene... Count me too...😆

Nobody including me is accepting this. Really it is not giving any sense that How Zaki could sleep next to Arzoo comfoting her? Though we are now going to be modernized but in such a situation where girl is really in terrified stage... It would be possible if Nausheen and Zara would not be there... But don't know how CVs dare to think of such things?
Edited by crazzykuri - 10 years ago
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Zaki sleeping with her has nothing to do with modernism or old age morality ... it was plain wrong which ever way one looks at it! Its' like in order to make space for zaki's char they are hell bent on compromising everything else ... i mean what impression that scene gave of nausheen and zara? How much they care for arzoo to leave her alone? ... how was that scene even important or needed ... imp for this story? Sumaira could get the same impression from something else too ... why make zaki sleep with her for that?
And I agree there is just too much of the deal going round and round and repetition of the scenes when it comes to Sahir ... how much can the actor pull it off? In fact if it was not for HC the disconnect would have happened long time ago ... Kudos to him for still pulling it and keeping the interest, despite poor script at times and now bad direction as well!
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: premeeristry

Also yesterday there was an editing blooper in this scene 😕...when Sahir came Zaki was already sleeping with a blanket 🤔






then they showed Sahir covering him with blanket... 😕




they have this editing scene problem from start


Editing tou is always an issue with the show ... even sahir's monologue had bad editing to top the not so good direction

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".