Please stop bashing Shivya! - Page 3

Originally posted by: SabrinaMalik

Gayu & Rozana.

I wasn't rude. It is MY opinion and MY choice too.

I was just expressing what I feel.

We're free to do that, I guess. 😉

I did not pin point anyone.

And do not think I'm supposed to go all gaga over people who criticize someone I like. I can't. Sorry.

And thank you for making a character sketch for me already. I'm honored.

You could've easily ignored me you know. But alas! you're so much affected by me.

Anyways, I wasn't here to pick up a fight. 😛

Wow, so much passive aggression in one thread! Y'all, chill. Drink some tea or something 😆
That being said, here's my opinion. I think what this show needs is some revision of the script, storyline and better editing.
The script is a bit... flat at times. Some lines are great, while others are just filler. The fact that Sahir's character is so intense provides a good delivery, hence no criticism of Harshad is heard. It's a testament to HC's acting skills that Sahir's character portrayal is so great. With Arzoo's character, she is passionate but not as intense as Sahir, so her delivery, to me anyway, can come out as flat at times. I think Shivya's doing a great job with what lines she is given. I agree that the jail scene was amazing! Right now she is a newcomer, so she probably won't do any improvisation until a few months have passed.
The storyline makes no sense to me because of the choppy editing, over the top negative characters, and cryptic conversations that lead to nothing.
This criticism aside, the chemistry is believable and developing at a normal pace. Unlike IPKKND, there is no manhandling, which is a relief! To be perfectly honest I hated Arnav's excessive grabbing of Khushi. I like that Sahir told Arzoo to stand on her own feet and save herself. Much more empowering and symbolic.
Anyways, I think I'm going to stick with this serial for a little longer. It has more pros than cons. I'll just be forwarding through the Kurti Aapa portions lol!

Originally posted by: Zah.Of.RoZaNa.

Laugh at someone just because they don't hold the same opinion as you? That talks a lot about you.

One free piece of advice to you too. Stop giving advice.

Because, my eyes, my tv, and my account and time on IF. My choice how I want to spend my energy. If I wish to complain about a show that had interested me once upon a time, I will. I don't need to be told not to do that.

well said@zaofrozana.

@sabrinamalik:learn to respect everyone's point of view,that was indeed really rude,even if you disagree you should be polite instead of ridiculing and hurting other members by your rash words.

Originally posted by: vena.cava.

There's truly no denying that there has been a LOT of negative backlash in this forum with regards to Shivya. Sorry but that's not criticism. Not liking the actress is an opinion anyone can hold, but starting up topics to 'change the lead' is rude and so unnecessary. Shivya has improved, and I for one completely enjoy watching her on screen and seeing her nuanced acting. So hats off to her, and may she only continue to improve in the best direction😊

there's no backlash this is how you take the things because you like her and cannot hear a single word against her,you like her is not the issue but the way you guys lashing out those members who do not like her that is rude and also very hostile, even if you disagree with the fact that she is not a good actress you can explain things that support your reasons in a rational manner.

Sorry but this is not also a way to tell people to stop giving their views, everyone has a liberty to criticize, and if members think that the actress should be replaced than what's wrong about that? this is not rude, if we see her unfit for the role she's playing what's the harm in that? no one is forcing you to change your good opinion about her, if I were you I would rather respect it and I still do but don't start lashing out members for not liking her.

Mallu

Criticism of any show by the fans signifies that the fans care about the show and want it to improve and be successful. I understand why people feel the need to criticize. That's why I did earlier! 😊
However, I would like to say that I disagree with people saying Shivya should leave. I don't think that any of the actors should be forced to leave the show... That just doesn't sit right with me, because we fans don't know where the story is going and we don't know exactly why each actor was chosen for the role. I am sure that we have not seen the full extent of Shivya's, or any other actor's for that matter, talent. Gul didn't just grab any girl off the road and give her the role. I'm sure many auditions were given! Every character, even Kurti Appa, has a role to play in the story. Their actions will contribute to the overall progress of the story. I'm sure the negative characters will help unite the leads (just like Tanveer did in QH!).
*This post is not meant to offend anyone! I'm just stating my opinion!

Originally posted by: AnjumP

Criticism of any show by the fans signifies that the fans care about the show and want it to improve and be successful. I understand why people feel the need to criticize. That's why I did earlier! 😊
However, I would like to say that I disagree with people saying Shivya should leave. I don't think that any of the actors should be forced to leave the show... That just doesn't sit right with me, because we fans don't know where the story is going and we don't know exactly why each actor was chosen for the role. I am sure that we have not seen the full extent of Shivya's, or any other actor's for that matter, talent. Gul didn't just grab any girl off the road and give her the role. I'm sure many auditions were given! Every character, even Kurti Appa, has a role to play in the story. Their actions will contribute to the overall progress of the story. I'm sure the negative characters will help unite the leads (just like Tanveer did in QH!).
*This post is not meant to offend anyone! I'm just stating my opinion!

thankyou for being polite, but no one is forcing shivya to leave the show if we say that we don't like her or she should be replaced we also keep that in mind that she will not go anywhere as long the creative team wants her to stay.

that does not fit right with me as well when it is said that the actress is being bashed for no reason, it's pure criticism and nothing else,calling it bashing is rude, like you said"Criticism of any show by the fans signifies that the fans care about the show and want it to improve and be successful."


Mallu

Originally posted by: AnjumP

Wow, so much passive aggression in one thread! Y'all, chill. Drink some tea or something 😆
That being said, here's my opinion. I think what this show needs is some revision of the script, storyline and better editing.
The script is a bit... flat at times. Some lines are great, while others are just filler. The fact that Sahir's character is so intense provides a good delivery, hence no criticism of Harshad is heard. It's a testament to HC's acting skills that Sahir's character portrayal is so great. With Arzoo's character, she is passionate but not as intense as Sahir, so her delivery, to me anyway, can come out as flat at times. I think Shivya's doing a great job with what lines she is given. I agree that the jail scene was amazing! Right now she is a newcomer, so she probably won't do any improvisation until a few months have passed.
The storyline makes no sense to me because of the choppy editing, over the top negative characters, and cryptic conversations that lead to nothing.
This criticism aside, the chemistry is believable and developing at a normal pace. Unlike IPKKND, there is no manhandling, which is a relief! To be perfectly honest I hated Arnav's excessive grabbing of Khushi. I like that Sahir told Arzoo to stand on her own feet and save herself. Much more empowering and symbolic.
Anyways, I think I'm going to stick with this serial for a little longer. It has more pros than cons. I'll just be forwarding through the Kurti Aapa portions lol!

I haven't seen any bashing post for Shivya so far except for some criticism but that's a part and parcel for actors . 10 likes and 1 dislike doesn't make difference . I am really like Shivya and each day she proves how talented she she with her acting skills. She is bringing in different shades and emotions which is good .For a new comer to perform like this is not easy and I really appreciate her.