Maha buddhuvaar - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

4.3k

Users

19

Likes

146

Frequent Posters

AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Walden

It made me realise how bland real life is. The problem with real life is that you don't have background music.

@bold 🤣

I haven't watched the episode but thanks for your wonderful play by play. If LW turns out to be Indira, I am going to be so disappointed. I mean when we watch these shows, we learn to ignore logic and reasoning for the sake of drama etc. so the only thing the the viewer can hold on to is the characters belief- their rooh ki awaaz- and now looks like Rishi's rooh has also lost its bearings.
I don't know if any of you have seen the movie Race (the original one) but the recent happenings in HD remind me of this movie. I think that movie was the worst thriller I've ever seen because you could expect the characters to double-cross each other like every 5 minutes. The same is the case with HD- first they show Zara and Indu stand with the hands on the waist pose like a million times and now all of a sudden the montage shows the LW and Indu with the same pose??? Why should I believe them now??? If Rishi now believes that LW is Indira, why should I believe his "rooh ki awaz" now? Consistency in characterization is key even for a good mystery/suspense thriller- that is lost big time in HD.

Please watch the epi. Its the last one that the rooster will appear in. In the HD track record, that was perhaps the quickest entry and exit for an artiste.

Never watched Race, so will not be able to correlate to that. But the current situation in HD actually reminds me of a poem Mac Flecknoe, a lampoon, in which the poet (Dryden) pokes fun at a contemporary and says "The rest to some faint meaning make pretense, But Shadwell never deviates into sense." If we replace Shadwell with the "writers of HD", we'll be able to tolerate a show for a bit more.

@bold: Agree completely.

-Sandy- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: AllThingsNice

So the mental Indira is handed to the mental hospital. By our brainless wonder, Kutumb.

And of all the wonders in the world, we had to witness this one! Choti Hitler being dragged away and locked away in a room!! By sauteli mamiji, of all people! The nerve of that woman...locking Indu away!! Of course, "meri ma" was being played in the background during this tearful separation. It made me realise how bland real life is. The problem with real life is that you don't have background music.

Anyway, Savita locks Indu away in a room from which she cannot escape. Because she has nothing with which to saw away the bars in the window of this room. Even the gulel was elsewhere. Point to note, Indu. Never allow these lapses to occur. You never know when you might need one or the other.

Then there is a scene in which this version of Indira is bound to a pole before the guys from the hospital come to take her away. The point of this scene was to show that zindagi jung hai. The fools who are ferrying Indira to the mental hospital first leave her all alone in an ambulance that is thrown wide open. Why ALL of them, including the lady nurse had to go to push a car to the side will remain a mystery.

Rishi, instead of accompanying his new wife to wherever she has gone, chooses to relax against a rickshaw. Indira spots him from the ambulance, breaks free, and finally manages to reach Rishi and hug him. Just when he is about to see her face, the losers from the hospital put a hood around her head and drag her back -- almost as if they are kidnapping her.

Throughout the Rishi-Zara interaction, it came across as though Rishi now does not believe she is Indira. He believes that she looks like her. Today's interaction made me believe that the scene outside the masjid had not happened at all. Tomorrow, after he sees the contents of the potli (which contains stuff that they had put on Indira when they burnt her, but is as intact as Indira is), his atma and rooh will start saying other things to him. He does feel guilty about not involving Indu as he had originally intended, but now the deed is done.

I am not expecting this "triangle" to be handled sensitively at all. The writers are just not capable of it. The scenes with the mental Indira today were anything but sensitively handled.


Kanan, that is a nice summary of the episode! I thoroughly enjoyed it. 👍🏼

Kutumb is no wonder, she has been senseless since day one. No mother sends her daughter to a mental hospital knowingly or unknowingly. As sad as it is, I have never considered Kutumb to be Indira's mother.

I think the CVs were trying to prove Savita's evilness, as if the viewers are not aware of that already. It seems like they need to include Savita-Indu scenes in every episode just to make sure that the viewers will consider their relationship as a bitter one and nothing else.😕 I also found it weird how street people where shouting "murgi chor murgi chor" at Lahorewali. And yes, "Meri maa" added that extra touch to the seperation scene. Wish we had similar background music in real life situations too.😆

The nurses from the mental hospital were really dumb. How could they leave the patient alone? And that too with wide open access to the free.😲 In stead of taking care of the patient they left her all alone to help a stuck car. 🤢 Good nurses! 👏 The car driver could have asked other people to help him out as there were many of them along the road. Well well, CVs and their stupidity...

I am still wondering how come Rishi did not see Indira sitting in the ambulance. It looked he was looking in the opposite direction all the time knowingly.🤔 It was a very unnatural act in my opinion. Inshi's reunion did not last long as the hangmen/kidnappers arrived from behind with the speed of light. 😆 Their inhuman behaviour towards Indira cannot be justified. 👎🏼

Yes, even I felt the same regarding the Zashi scene in the shop. Rishi seemed lost in his thoughts about Indira, but he smiled when Zara mentioned that she will keep Indu happy. As if he accepted that Zara will be a nice substitute for Indira. Also, today Zashi looked seemingly happy to be together, quite the opposite of what was shown in the scene at the hospital some days ago.🤔 Zara seems to be happily ready to take on the responsibilty of the whole Besharama family, both financially and in kind. She still has not any idea of Besharama family's selfish nature. I pity her.

Rishi should have thought twice about Indu before hurrying through the marriage process. Now it will make no difference whether he asks for forgiveness or not, as he has broken the remaining trust Indu had in him. It seems his life will never be at peace. "Zindagi Jung Hain" truly applies to the trio of Indu, Indira and Rishi.

Yes, keeping the expectations at bay is the only way to go. The writers are insensitive and not adequately familiar with the terms creativity and consistency. There are too many evident bloopers in HD. I cannot resist but laugh. 🤣 I am thanking the CVs for giving us top class entertainment after showtime. 😆 They keep people like Kanan and others employed even if it means a bad time for the show itself. 😆
Anu_1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: AllThingsNice

They better have a damn good explanation for this "funeral rescue" bit. I would really like to know why Rishi would burn his beloved wife if she was still alive!



Kanan, as i had little free time now, I went and saw the Oct 3rd episode online, to see whether SN people and Rishi left immediately after litting the pryre...

No they stayed there, and the pyre was burning intensely😆😆 How come LW was rescued with out any other burn scars expect hand, that to only one hand and one pinky finger.😆😆 and her belongings.

And the saree which was covered over her head as veil, how come it did not get burnt, it burnt only 1/4 part.


Definitely CVS has to give very good explanation of how LW was rescued from the fire and how she was shipped to Lahore and the reason for this act...



Edited by Anu_1 - 12 years ago
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
You did again Karan!!! I open IF and first thing do is look for your post, just for my entertainment ,, If CVs read them they will not do any blooper !!
BTW I was able to disgust this episode better that yesterday's episode !! Sorry , our Murga is gone!!!! No more sarcasm !!! We need to find other things !!! Poor murga!! great acting skill . Cheap labour !!
On serious side . Today I came to know about one thing. I was looking for answer. I came to know that why I am disconnected to LW.? Her sadness is unbearable to me!! I am INSHI fan and before the show ends I want to see this couple happy!!! I want them to enjoy themselves . At this time ,I see only pain for them !!! So total disconnect for me ! I just love Rati and her brilliant acting skills !!! SHe can switch on and off with out any affords !!! Pain in her eyes, makes me cry . Hats off to such a incredible actress!!
Indu was better today. I was able to connect to her pain !!!! She behaved like 8 yr old kid. I wanted to hug her!! And comfort her. Thank GOD Sling was not in sight !!!! For one minute I thought she was going to start with sling shot and hurt CC public !! Shruti is doing really good.
I was shock to see cruel behavior ambulance people. In US every one will be face with legal action !! I was not able to watch that and I has to turn my head way from TV !! Very sad . Again Rati was great !!
POOR Rishi . He was very disconnected with ZARA , he was thinking about INdira!!! I finally decided that he married ZARA !!! Poor thing!!
Kutumb !!! OMG, Why , why ? They portrait mom like this ? Beyond me !!!
Best thing in the episode was Rati in RED sari !! Incredible beauty !!!!!!
YOU mean to tell me you do not have music in your real life drama ? So sad!!!


Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Earnshaw

Good judgement.I really wish to meet the CVs of "HD" in person and ask them that,if they have ever read the meaning of creativity,and if they are even experienced in their field.It really is disappointing to see how one-by-one each character is ruined and demoralized;how the simple story of "HD" has been complicated and turned into a circus of emotions.


I agree with you! I see lots of great writer on IF. They should help CVs of HD. SV is great writer too , he needs to get involved, This show has great cast. Everyone is excellent in given role . I really hope they do not misuse the great collective talents !!
I read all post . Very good post and I look forward to read them !! Great writting , may be should volunteer to wite for HD.
Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
palingenesis thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
Kanan I just have one question to ask here: Where did d murga disappear to?😲 😆🤣🤣Yeh hain mudde ki baat...baaki sab bakwaas!😉😆
Edited by luminos3 - 12 years ago
backofff thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
i think LW is swetha she is wearing Indira's face mask to fool rishi😆i know its not possible but who knows in HD anything is possible😆
designersaini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
luved ur post n really nice analysis.
I 9 hd is full f bloopers but i think gonna b d biggest blooper f HD dat according 2 hindu religion after performing all d rituals f antim sanskar,dead person ki asthiya ganga mein baha di jaati hai.so my point is if indira agar bach gayi to SF ne kiski asthiya bahayi aur agar nahi bachi means all d rituals were completed den who is dis LW nd how she got dat saree nd bangles.
HD cvs agar iska reason nahi de paye to sachme buri tarah apne hi bloopers ke jaal mein phasne wale hai...
Parm. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: luminos3

Kanan I just have one question to ask here: Where did d murga disappear to?😲 😆🤣🤣Yeh hain mudde ki baat...baaki sab bakwaas!😉😆




I'm thinking in the murgh makhani dish that both Munna and Inder are going to consume 😆😆

AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Anu_1



Kanan, as i had little free time now, I went and saw the Oct 3rd episode online, to see whether SN people and Rishi left immediately after litting the pryre...

No they stayed there, and the pyre was burning intensely😆😆 How come LW was rescued with out any other burn scars expect hand, that to only one hand and one pinky finger.😆😆 and her belongings.

And the saree which was covered over her head as veil, how come it did not get burnt, it burnt only 1/4 part.


Definitely CVS has to give very good explanation of how LW was rescued from the fire and how she was shipped to Lahore and the reason for this act...



Wow!! This is great! Thanks Anu 😆

Should be fun to watch what they come up with...this "arthi escape" is more of a suspense than who the real Indira is!

Edited by AllThingsNice - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".