voice of audience lost - reason for low trps - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2k

Users

18

Likes

173

Frequent Posters

-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
I just want to know one thing...if Indira changes within a matter of few days will it be okay? will audience start connecting to her suddenly?

I don't think so...the make up of Indira's character is such that she is used to taking care of the Sharmas...if she suddenly is shown giving up on them then it would be extremely abrupt...A woman who has spent years feeding such a worthless family will take some time to detach...Maybe You and I can say sitting here she should have detached earlier...but we are not Indira we cannot imagine exactly or even judge what she should have done...

As viewer I am enjoying the gradual change in Indira- she has become a lot more shrewd than before, she might not give as much as attention to her married life as an ordinary girl would but she does care about her husband...I mean her husband itself is okay with her love for Sharmas...so its fine I guess...

More than Indira I am worried for Rishi's character...he has lost direction...he does not care about his own career...he does mind being mean, selfish and rude to the same wife on whose money he is eating...he is romantic and supportive...fine...but only when she does not force him to work or scolds him for that...basically he is proving to be the "mast maula'" who will do bhalai of everyone without doing any concrete bhalai to himself..Even Munna bhaisaab in his stupid way wanted to think for his future, recently stood up for his sister but rishi...His common sense and his self respect all seem to be going down the drain...he is not evoking any respect from the fans...

maybe the cvs should do a thorough thinking now...what they have in mind for everyone...rest of the characters as well...and balance out all the points evenly...
rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
HD lost its magic--and viewers feeling disconnected to storyline.

still i wonder why indira care her family so much when they are just useless and third rate people who never care her.

i don't feel any pain for indira as all her problems are self inflected.

new track is even more worse.
when she left home with husband then why she need to look back??can any body give me a valid reason.

i again and again posting same point if my many post in past--
how you able to like a serial when --when you are angry at lead and dose not feel any sympathy for her??how can serial get trp when you dose not like or love lead itself??

no wonder trps are plummeting and dooms day is very near.


Edited by 100raj - 13 years ago
aadk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -Rinky-

I just want to know one thing...if Indira changes within a matter of few days will it be okay? will audience start connecting to her suddenly?


I don't think so...the make up of Indira's character is such that she is used to taking care of the Sharmas...if she suddenly is shown giving up on them then it would be extremely abrupt...A woman who has spent years feeding such a worthless family will take some time to detach...Maybe You and I can say sitting here she should have detached earlier...but we are not Indira we cannot imagine exactly or even judge what she should have done...

As viewer I am enjoying the gradual change in Indira- she has become a lot more shrewd than before, she might not give as much as attention to her married life as an ordinary girl would but she does care about her husband...I mean her husband itself is okay with her love for Sharmas...so its fine I guess...

More than Indira I am worried for Rishi's character...he has lost direction...he does not care about his own career...he does mind being mean, selfish and rude to the same wife on whose money he is eating...he is romantic and supportive...fine...but only when she does not force him to work or scolds him for that...basically he is proving to be the "mast maula'" who will do bhalai of everyone without doing any concrete bhalai to himself..Even Munna bhaisaab in his stupid way wanted to think for his future, recently stood up for his sister but rishi...His common sense and his self respect all seem to be going down the drain...he is not evoking any respect from the fans...

maybe the cvs should do a thorough thinking now...what they have in mind for everyone...rest of the characters as well...and balance out all the points evenly...


@ bold I completely n completely agree with u over that...👍🏼 👍🏼
@red U said it right...Yes its high time he realises his responsibilities as a married person...Its just not enough to get your wife away from her mean family,its also necessary to cater to other responsibilities as a husband...He is portrayed as a practical person and how can a person who is practical be blind to the duties of a husband in our society...Its really sweet of him for the way he tries bring his wife out of distress,supports her emotionally and stands by her side always...But i really want the CVs to redeem the damage that they have done to his character by showing him jobless...
@blue here i find it a bit difficult to agree with you...Munna can never be compared to rishi...Just because munna stood for his sis yesterday ,he doesnt become anything great...Sometyms when a person frm whom we least expect does something good, we tend to praise him for realising his responsibilities though d realisation is just for time being...He is a brother and what he did was just what any other brother wud hav done(though we very rarely get to see him in the true colours of a brother)...i dont think we can compare rishi and munna on the same plane...
@TM really liked the point that u mentioned that rishi was the voice of the audience...As far as am concerned its true for me!!!
Edited by aadk - 13 years ago
shona90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Great post Eliza and special thanks to your mom for conveying her thoughts to us 👏

I agree Rishii -- the character who will shed Indira's Hitler roop and try to make her realize she is an ordinary girl who has dreams, Start trusting men bcuz all men are not same... Start leaving your life and life is short enjoy every moment of it... Start loving as ther is nothing more important this beautiful feeling...!!!

I guess now what the CV's are planning to experiment with Rishi's character.. They fail to understand we loved Rishii the person he is.. The fun loving, mast-maula, jovial, his shayrii andaaz...He has lots of capabilities and can earn his own, but CV's till now has not focused on his character .. But i am sure as and when each track ends Rishii characters will surely show us a growth.. We will soon be able to see him earning and much for responsible but also wants the same naughtiness, wittiness for which we all love him 😳

I agree Indira is a very strong character..After the betrayal of her father, she took the responsibility of the house, worked day and night, nourished her family, supported her in as many ways she could.. But for this she had to becme Hitler- a tough girl, strict, never smiling girl.. may b bcuz she nevr got the love from the family she deserve... In between we saw how Rishii managed to change Indira in an ordinary girl and makes her realize its always forgiving and forgiving.. Also she changed, after that secret marriage we saw the change in Indira as a personality, she started smiling, she was caring for her entire family with love and care...!!

But now as we all see the story is back to where it was.. Indira again struggling for her family, Inshii has been side-lined.. No proper track and execution.. If want to show the struggle of Indira as the original theme says so then at-least change the circumstances or situations.. A change of story with the respective characters Indira-Rishii people would love to see how they overcome all the hurdles in ther way...!!!



Eliza_D thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: -Rinky-

I just want to know one thing...if Indira changes within a matter of few days will it be okay? will audience start connecting to her suddenly?


I don't think so...the make up of Indira's character is such that she is used to taking care of the Sharmas...if she suddenly is shown giving up on them then it would be extremely abrupt...A woman who has spent years feeding such a worthless family will take some time to detach...Maybe You and I can say sitting here she should have detached earlier...but we are not Indira we cannot imagine exactly or even judge what she should have done...

As viewer I am enjoying the gradual change in Indira- she has become a lot more shrewd than before, she might not give as much as attention to her married life as an ordinary girl would but she does care about her husband...I mean her husband itself is okay with her love for Sharmas...so its fine I guess...

More than Indira I am worried for Rishi's character...he has lost direction...he does not care about his own career...he does mind being mean, selfish and rude to the same wife on whose money he is eating...he is romantic and supportive...fine...but only when she does not force him to work or scolds him for that...basically he is proving to be the "mast maula'" who will do bhalai of everyone without doing any concrete bhalai to himself..Even Munna bhaisaab in his stupid way wanted to think for his future, recently stood up for his sister but rishi...His common sense and his self respect all seem to be going down the drain...he is not evoking any respect from the fans...

maybe the cvs should do a thorough thinking now...what they have in mind for everyone...rest of the characters as well...and balance out all the points evenly...



aap ne mere beti ka pehla post shayad pardha nahi

critical reason trps are so bad is because audience has lost Rishi...rishi ka character kidnapping ke baad ityna barbaad kar diya ki audience ussey relate hi nahi kar pa rahi...wo rude nahi, irresponsible bqan gaya hey

wo rishi jo din raat Vidith ki kidhmat karta tha...was so responsible that he remembered the Vidith needed catheter even after being beaten so badly and thrown out of mandap...Indira aur Sharamas ki itney kidmat karta tha...apney easy, rich life kurban kar dee Indira ke liye...wo Rishi aaj pita hai...bin wajah jhoot bolta hai...lazy hai...kyon?

Kyon barbaad kiya Rishi ko?

we were talking to Indira through Rishi...jab Rishi hi barbaad hogaya to connection to tootega hi

Indira pehley sey hi talkh personality thi...per itnee nahi...ab to bahut hi talakh ho gaee hai...


aap ne kaha Rishi has same importance as Sharmas...I disagree strongly
koi bhi sharma serial se nikal jaye...serial chal sakta hai...Sandeep bhi kitnee der gayab raha tha rape trial mein...but because Rishi and Indira were there, carrying the storyline beautifully...serial ko koi farak nahi pada

Rishi itnee der gayab raha aur wapas aya bhi to itney badley huey roop mein...and like an appendage...serial ka kya bura haal hai

Mein phir kahoon gi....Rishi was the critical ingredient...he was voice of the audience...an admirable man...who while helping Indira had his issues to deal with to

Jab sey cvs yeh bhool gaye hein...ya unhein galat advice de gayee hai...tab sey serial her roz doob raha hai

Serial pehley din sey Indira ka hitlerpana tha aur kaisey Rishi usey dikhata hai ki zindagi mein aur bhi bahut kuch hai Hilterpane key ilawa...


Anu_1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
Awesome points. Agree with you!!!!
AnkitalovesHD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
The funny thing is Rishi is the cv's creation right? He is made by the same people who are sketching Rishi in such an odd fashion now. Like Eliza said beautifully, Rishi was our link with Indira. He asked her what we as viewers wanted to ask her. He empathized with her when we commiserated for Indu and her ill fate. He was the chosen one! the man who was supposed to bring laughter into Indira's life and help her rediscover the joys of life and fall in love again, trust human beings like before and reinstate her faith in humanity. Rishi is definitely pivotal in the whole story, the catalyst in the story or in other words the one helps Indu's life move forward.The irreparable changes in both the characters have snapped the connection we had with them. I just dont understand why the same creatives who marvelously etched Indu and Rk fail to recreate the magic once more.
Edited by AnkitalovesHD - 13 years ago
rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: AnkitalovesHD

The funny thing is Rishi is the cv's creation right? He is made by the same people who are sketching Rishi in such an odd fashion now. Like Eliza said beautifully, Rishi was our link with Indira. He asked her what we as viewers wanted to ask her. He empathized with her when we commiserated for Indu and her ill fate. He was the chosen one! the man who was supposed to bring laughter into Indira's life and help her rediscover the joys of life and fall in love again, trust human beings like before and reinstate her faith in humanity. Rishi is definitely pivotal in the whole story, the catalyst in the story or in other words the one helps Indu's life move forward.The irreparable changes in both the characters have snapped the connection we had with them. I just dont understand why the same creatives who marvelously etched Indu and Rk fail to recreate the magic once more.



@bold--

cvs not showing--indira moving forward in life.

and that exactly not going well with audience.

and new rishi is telling indira to go backward in life and
he want to make her to go back to SN and take all insults once again.

i really getting annoyed with this new indira and new rishi.

both character got big damage and story dose not know where to go.

very sad state of affairs.
HC_Meena thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
I also totally agree with you... Indira has to draw the line to be respected by her family...
rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: shona90

Great post Eliza and special thanks to your mom for conveying her thoughts to us 👏


I agree Rishii -- the character who will shed Indira's Hitler roop and try to make her realize she is an ordinary girl who has dreams, Start trusting men bcuz all men are not same... Start leaving your life and life is short enjoy every moment of it... Start loving as ther is nothing more important this beautiful feeling...!!!

I guess now what the CV's are planning to experiment with Rishi's character.. They fail to understand we loved Rishii the person he is.. The fun loving, mast-maula, jovial, his shayrii andaaz...He has lots of capabilities and can earn his own, but CV's till now has not focused on his character .. But i am sure as and when each track ends Rishii characters will surely show us a growth.. We will soon be able to see him earning and much for responsible but also wants the same naughtiness, wittiness for which we all love him 😳

I agree Indira is a very strong character..After the betrayal of her father, she took the responsibility of the house, worked day and night, nourished her family, supported her in as many ways she could.. But for this she had to becme Hitler- a tough girl, strict, never smiling girl.. may b bcuz she nevr got the love from the family she deserve... In between we saw how Rishii managed to change Indira in an ordinary girl and makes her realize its always forgiving and forgiving.. Also she changed, after that secret marriage we saw the change in Indira as a personality, she started smiling, she was caring for her entire family with love and care...!!

But now as we all see the story is back to where it was.. Indira again struggling for her family, Inshii has been side-lined.. No proper track and execution.. If want to show the struggle of Indira as the original theme says so then at-least change the circumstances or situations.. A change of story with the respective characters Indira-Rishii people would love to see how they overcome all the hurdles in ther way...!!!





@bold-

HD is in coma.--viewers hopelessly waiting for its demise.
as a HD lover--
i want it to survive--but in mind i am prepared for inevitable thing.
Edited by 100raj - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".