Hitler didi: just another COPY! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

3.3k

Users

27

Likes

66

Frequent Posters

zarahg thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21
no its diffrant as u can see the 2nd epi.
riks111 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22
Yes It seems like copy. But I don't think its a copy of "Kal ho naa ho". Here you are just assuming that its seems like a copy of Kal ho naa ho. But IMO its an copy of one of old movie of Rekha and Raj Babbar "JEEVAN DHARA". I watched that movie and it was really nice.. If you had seen this movie then you will immediately understand that Hitler Didi is an exact copy of it or is inspired by this movie.

Infact there is nothing wrong if it is an inspiration of that movie. Because that was really a very good movie, I loved that movie, and if Hitler Didi is going to be like that movie then I will watch all the episodes withou fail.

In that movie "Jeevan Dhara" too Rekha was playing same role like hitler didi. i.e. in her family she had single mother, good for nothing brother (Raj Babbar), a housewife sister in law, younger sister and niece and nephew. Her brother wasn't working and wasting all his money in drinking liquor and playing gambles (juaa). He wasn't taking responsibilities of his wife kids, 2 younger sisters and mother. Hence the sister (Rekha) had to work to feed the family and due to bitterness for her brother and struggle of life she becomes tough and strict with her family esp. to her niece and nephew and nobody in family incl. her younger sister or her SIL dare to tell anything to her. She keep taunting her brother for not working and also to her nephew to not become like his father. She fall in love with one guy but her sister too fall in love with same guy. She sacrifices for her sister and get her married to that guy. Then eventually her brother (Raj Babbar) realises his mistake and get aware of his responsibilities and ask his sister (Rekha) to leave job and promise to leave drinks and gamble and pick up job and get his sister married. Sister (Rekha) becomes very happy about it. but the tragedy again happen in her life was that her brother dies in accident and again all responsibilities of her brother's wife and kids and her old mother come on her (Rekha). Then in the end of movie, she murmur, that the girl who have widowed mother and SIL, who have niece and nephew without father, doesn't get married, but she do job and runs her family. That was a real tragic scene.

So now I just watched only 2 episodes of Hitler Didi and I immidiately understood tht it is clearly seems an inspiration of that Rekha's movie "Jeevan Dhara". Here too, Indira (Hitler didi) has single mother, father left the family and got remarried, not working brother, housewife SIL, younger sister and nephew. And her role too is exactly like Rekha in that movie, tough and strict. While her brother don't like to do job and let his sister take burden of household. However the movie was 3 hours while this is serial. And in serial they can twist and change the story as the episode go by or add more drama to the plot to run more and more episodes. I don't know what twist might take in future episodes or will it get exactly like that movie, viz. love triangle with younger sister and death of brother, but the initial plot seems like that movie only.
Edited by riks111 - 13 years ago
simidhillon89 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: AbhiyaFan_Qusim

Stop It! This is different from it! This Is Good At Its Place! Joke Of The Year!

Please Refrain from making such post! Enjoy over here and make friends!😊




Wow calm down, it's JUST a 30 minute show
Not reality, no need to get worked up over it
And I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings but I am entitled to my opinion
Of course it's different, they legally have to make it different otherwise it's a clear violation.
But what I meant was that the main idea is taken from the film
524431 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24
Yup there was a film like this in telugu too with jayapradha and rainikanth as her brother
riks111 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
Yes It seems like copy. But I don't think its a copy of "Kal ho naa ho". Here you are just assuming that its seems like a copy of Kal ho naa ho. But IMO its an copy of one of old movie of Rekha and Raj Babbar "JEEVAN DHARA". I watched that movie and it was really nice.. If you had seen this movie then you will immediately understand that Hitler Didi is an exact copy of it or is inspired by this movie.

Infact there is nothing wrong if it is an inspiration of that movie. Because that was really a very good movie, I loved that movie, and if Hitler Didi is going to be like that movie then I will watch all the episodes withou fail.

In that movie "Jeevan Dhara" too Rekha was playing same role like hitler didi. i.e. in her family she had single mother, good for nothing brother (Raj Babbar), a housewife sister in law, younger sister and niece and nephew. Her brother wasn't working and wasting all his money in drinking liquor and playing gambles (juaa). He wasn't taking responsibilities of his wife kids, 2 younger sisters and mother. Hence the sister (Rekha) had to work to feed the family and due to bitterness for her brother and struggle of life she becomes tough and strict with her family esp. to her niece and nephew and nobody in family incl. her younger sister or her SIL dare to tell anything to her. She keep taunting her brother for not working and also to her nephew to not become like his father. She fall in love with one guy but her sister too fall in love with same guy. She sacrifices for her sister and get her married to that guy. Then eventually her brother (Raj Babbar) realises his mistake and get aware of his responsibilities and ask his sister (Rekha) to leave job and promise to leave drinks and gamble and pick up job and get his sister married. Sister (Rekha) becomes very happy about it. but the tragedy again happen in her life was that her brother dies in accident and again all responsibilities of her brother's wife and kids and her old mother come on her (Rekha). Then in the end of movie, she murmur, that the girl who have widowed mother and SIL, who have niece and nephew without father, doesn't get married, but she do job and runs her family. That was a real tragic scene.

So now I just watched only 2 episodes of Hitler Didi and I immidiately understood tht it is clearly seems an inspiration of that Rekha's movie "Jeevan Dhara". Here too, Indira (Hitler didi) has single mother, father left the family and got remarried, not working brother, housewife SIL, younger sister and nephew. And her role too is exactly like Rekha in that movie, tough and strict. While her brother don't like to do job and let his sister take burden of household. However the movie was 3 hours while this is serial. And in serial they can twist and change the story as the episode go by or add more drama to the plot to run more and more episodes. I don't know what twist might take in future episodes or will it get exactly like that movie, viz. love triangle with younger sister and death of brother, but the initial plot seems like that movie only.

Book-Worm thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
@risk
u explained d story well..

i think JEEVAN DHARA was d remake of tamil movie called AVAL ORU THODARKADAI directed by K.Balachandar.. when i saw d 1st episode i also remembered tat tamil movie.. but it din't bother me bcoz d story s good n rati is doing wonderful job...
so i think if d story s gud n actors r playing well den der s no problem to watch d serial..
Keva thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
It does not matter to me if it is a copy coz today every show is copy of another show or movie. The creatives and producers are no longer creative since they can't even come up with a good creative title they have to get the title from good old songs. and btw Ekta Kapoor has been copying the background music and the stories from her previous shows for many years and hence certainly nobody can beat her when it comes to copying. 😆 In the end, ratings ka zamana hai and so copying is unavoidable.
sreevijayan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#28
even if its a copy..i wud like to see our angel diii
Simply-Nidhi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
There is a big list of movies that we have found similiar to HD. Lol!
untamedtigress thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
actually its not copy of KAL HO NA HO that much but is a ditto ov THE FILM JEEVAN DHARA 😕😕😕😕starring rekha rakesh roshan and raj babbar its somwhat exactly like that i saw it on one ov the indian channels on dish tv last week do chek it out guys ,but the ending ov the movie was a tragic one🤢🤢🤢 hope hitler didi ends up on a happy note😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".