HBP Chapter Discussion: **Ch. 7 Playing** - Page 3

Hey I want to comment about Chapter 2

In this chapter, Wormtail comes back... He is shown to be neglected and treated as a servant....

I think this is also a important point.... Might be he will get tired of the whole thing..... and in the end help Harry to succeed....

Chapter 3:

Hey I always feel bad about Kreacher....
He believes that bad is good.... Bad is correct...
Poor thing.... even if it does not like Harry... he is its master........

And yes... Dumbledore was coollllllllll...........

Originally posted by: Monaji

Hey I want to comment about Chapter 2

In this chapter, Wormtail comes back... He is shown to be neglected and treated as a servant....

I think this is also a important point.... Might be he will get tired of the whole thing..... and in the end help Harry to succeed....

we totally forgot to even mention that...yah, but even if wormtail isn't ready to be "good," he's still bound to harry with the "bond" so he has to repay harry for saving his life...so we'll see some of that in book 7

~~

chapter 3: yes..that's the particular reason why i definitely love DD's character...he's humorous in an authoritative sorta way so he can tell ppl off without them realizing it for a couple of minutes..haha..and since its the Dursleys..it'll take them a long whle to digest his frankness and ridicule of them..haha

feel free to once again talk about past chapters or include future chapters in ur discussion about any future chapters...so here we come chapter 4...that sounded lame..lol.oh well

Chapter 4: Horace Slughorn

Summary: ahh..alas we meet the "slug master" (as i like to call him)...the much awaited new professor of..well u kno..rite? hehe...well here's the summary anyway: Dumbledore take Harry with him to persaude Horace Slughorn to become a professor at Hogwarts. Slughorn is disguised as an overstuffed chair (not that he needs the disguise..he already look like one). Harry unintentionally persuades Slughorn to take the job. At the end, Dumbledore tells harry that he will give him private lessons.

~~

My Views: Wellll.....one itty bitty thing in this chappie unsettles me...Dumbledore shows slughorn the black ring on his injured hand and Sluggy understands/knows wat it is...this whole exchange is sorta implying that Sluggy knows about the horcruxes (obviously..from future chappies we know), but it could also mean the our very own annoying sluggy could help harry with the horcruxes...does this mean the dumbledore confides in sluggy with the info on horcruxes? they have obviously talked abt this...does he trust him so?

yeah!dumbledore knew that harry n only harry would be able to persuade horace slughorn into returning to hogwarts!dumbledore wanted slughorn's memory from he n he knew that it wud b possible only by making slughorn cum to hogwarts n stuff!dumbledore is such a brainy!i loved the way he said that he wanted to use slughorn's toilet n how he fooled him!it was basically a good chapter!but i definitely did think that slughorn wud b taking DADA!😳

BTW IT SAYS HBP Chapter Discussion: **Ch. 3 Playing**

it must b chapter four playing!

What I found a bit odd.. was I think after first book... this was the first time we didnt see something from Harry's Point of view!!

I mean even that riddle house chapter in Book 4 was Harry's Dream...😕

Wonder what made her change the style...

the exchange made it seem as if Sluggy knew that it was a horcrux...but u never kno