HBP Mystery Solved (***** Spoilers *****) - Page 2

The locket Harry has is a fake, that's what the note says. It's missing the mark of slytherin and the weight...

V

also...u kno that note mite as well be some "trick" to make harry think that it's not a horcrux, but in the end it turns out to be one?

I HIGHLY DOUBT THAT, tho...i mean this R.A.B. person seems real and Rowling has dropping no hints watsoever of RAB being fake and the locket being a real horcrux

~~

it's true that there r quite a few with last name starting with "B"...so far regulus fits best...and well i've heard Amelia Bones, but wat of the "R"?

Originally posted by: Anya-Hitomi

I wasn't hinting on there being a "trick" in this whole thing... "hoax" was used to indicate that Voldemort might have come to know about Dumbledore's search and planted it there. Or that R. A. B. may be having R as some title. Or that R. A. B. might not necessarily mean first name, middle name, last name order. Or that R. A. B. might indicate some pseudonym... like Padfoot for Sirius... far-fetched but probable.



All probability suggest Regulus and I am not contesting it - just not believing it... he is such a contemptuous character. And I have an "honourable" R. A. B. in mind - someone with Gryffindor-ish qualities... why would a sneaky Slytherin want to challenge He Who Must Not Be Named?

well not all slytherin are as bad as the DE's..but u never kno

as of rite now, no one can come to mind besides regulus...and i did think abt the R being a title, but couldn't go any farther...and i thought that it could be a woman with her last name prior to marriage (like Narcissa Black..instead of Narcissa Malfoy)...the possibilities are endless

(and to clear the record..lol..i wasn't saying that u said it was a trick, i was only stating my own beliefs..sorry for the misunderstanding)

dang this stinkin laptop just erased everything i wrote! damn it!.....! well could be Regulus black but i think its some1 that we wudnt expect at all i mean all this time i was unsure whether snape was good or bad but it was becuz of him that harry's parents died and 😭Dumbledore😭! well mayb the horcrux-the locket was at Grimmald place in the 5th book but then Voldemort decided to make a new horcrux and then he made it-the locket-short while some1 the RAB guy found out that Dumbledore was having a thoery that it wud b at Voldemort's special lake so he or she went over there and took it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11