could harry or dumbledore...

i know this is a far-fetched but could harry or dumbledore be horcruxes? that cud explain y snape killed dumbledore and y harry mite die at the end

I'm not sure but I think this has been discussed before...
we all gave our point of views...but if u want... we could start a discussion round again...

COULD HARRY OR DUMBLEDORE BE HORCRUXES?
Harry might die at the end of the book. Dumbledore, an extremely important character, was killed by Severus Snape at the end of book 6. So press ure points and help angel eyes out.

dumbledore refused to be the preist when snape proposed lily , that is why he killed him [lol 😆 ]

HA this has been posted like 100000000000 times....

but good observations....

the first post i wrote in IF was if Harry was a horcrux...

-hadia

Well...I don't think both of them are horcruxes. Well basically...Dumbledore's theory was that Nagini is a horcrux and as she's sharing her soul with Voldemort's(acc. to Dumbledore) "Voldemort has extra-ordinary power over her even for a parselmouth"-Horcruxes, HBP.

So, if we are to believe what Dumbledore is implying over ere...that if u share your soul with a part of a soul which is created by murdering someone...in other words if u are the Horcrux then the person whose soul is in ur body has "extra-ordinary" control over you. As such...I haven't found any such extra ordinary control by Voldemort over Harry. (Since the books are from his POV we know that!) Also, don't you think that if Harry is the horcrux...his thoughts and his ability to be humane would be marred by Voldemort's soul residing in his body???

Don't you think Harry would be darker...and have evil thoughts. Also...don't forget..at the end of OotP, when Voldemort possesed Harry...it was sheer torture for Harry and when Harry thought about his love for Sirius...Voldemort found it unbearable to possess Harry and fled??? Also Harry described the experience as "He was in the coils of a large snake like creature.He didn't know where his body ended and where the creature's begun" It's not the exact quote but still if Harry had been the horcrux..he would have physically and mentally felt the effects of Voldemort's soul!

And like Dumbledore said...Harry's mysterious power AKA love is something unbearable and painful for Voldemort! So his soul could never rest peacefully in Harry's body! 😉

can harry rest peacefully when voldemort is around ... i guess the way he feels pain in the scar everytime he faces lord voldemort , he'll be barely able to stand to throw a good attack ..

i guess it's because a part of voldemort's soul is in harry ... the way voldemort would suffer if he tries to posess harry, harry suffers too as a part of voldemort is already in him

Hmm...i am just waiting for the both of them(Harry n Voldermort) to die so that i can take over.I will be known AS" He who must be feared" Bwhahahahahahaahahah

the main reason that harry is not a horcrux is that :

1. you'll need to kill someone to rip your soul
2. that part of the soul is to place in something
3. voldemort used the AK curse to kill harry
4. which means he had something with him to turn it into a horcrux ...


plus :

You dont try to kill someone to make him/her a horcrux , that's just stupid !

well i dont kno abt logical reasononing bt i sure dont want either of them to b a horcrux 😆
thing is then thr wudnt b any surprise since its so talked out n discussed...n frankly one reason i lyk jkr is bcos of how she surprises us 😉😳
so itd b mighty disappointing if harry and/or d'dore turned out to b horcruxes....bcos itd seem so...i donno....lame 😔
bcos weve talked it out so mch n hv gotten enough reasons as to y they r or rnt the horcruxes...so basically i say we jst stay put n w8 till the book releases 😉

sorry-im new to the forum and didnt realise this has been posted before. i agree coolniyu, jkr can do anything to suprise us