Unlikely tale in the
realm of kid fantasy
Christopher Paolini's 'Eldest' is a best-seller
By Heidi Dawley
Sep 26, 2005
It's a fantasy tale of epic proportions. Topping The New York Times Best Seller List for children's chapter books again this week is "Eldest," the second book in the Inheritance Trilogy by Christopher Paolini.
But the book isn't the only epic fantasy tale in this story. How Paolini came to be a children's publishing phenomenon reaches that level too. What's more, in his unusual, indeed, unlikely background, Paolini is in the good company of so many other children's writers in this genre.
The likes of J.K. Rowling, of Harry Potter fame, C.S. Lewis, who wrote "The Chronicles of Narnia" series, and "Lord of the Rings" creator J.R.R. Tolkien have all captivated kids with tales of make believe worlds while themselves living particularly interesting lives.
But of them all, Paolini, who is only 21, seems the least likely children's book author. He was home-schooled growing up in the wilderness of Montana, and yet he managed to earn a high school diploma at just 15 years old. That was too young to go off to college, his parents decided, so rather than hang around the house doing nothing, the young Paolini set about scribbling down his his fantasies.
They proved to be worlds away from what one might expect from the typical 15-year-old. His parents thought his story, the tale of a farm boy named Eragon and his dragon Saphira who fight an evil empire, was good enough to publish. So they did it themselves in 2002.
As a rule, self-published books quickly sail off into oblivion, ignored by critics, the literary establishment, book-sellers and more crucially, the book-reading public. So Paolini's tale of Eragon and Saphira seemed all but guaranteed a quick trip to the trash heap of novels read by only a few friends and family. But wait.
It turns out that while on a fishing vacation in Montana, the step-son of novelist Carl Hiaasen discovered the book and became fascinated. Hiaasen took the book to his publisher, Random House's Alfred A. Knopf, who decided to publish it in 2003.
"Eragon" went on to sell 2.5 million and is set to be made into a major motion picture.
This summer the second book in the trilogy, "Eldest," was released and sold more than 425,000 copies in the first week, a record for a Random House children's book title.
Paolini's books have received mixed reviews by critics, some of whom believe the stories are too derivative and the writing is perhaps not as polished as it could be.
Writes L.A. Times reviewer Denise Hamilton: "It's precisely because of Paolini's storytelling gifts that one yearns for 'Eldest' to be consistently good, especially because so many of this book's shortcomings could have been fixed by a strong-willed editor with a sharp pencil."
Children seem not to mind.
Perhaps not surprisingly, Paolini is no longer so sure about heading off to college, feeling he may have already found his calling. The story of Paolini, while being different in detail, is similar in its unusualness to other top children fantasy writers. J.K. Rowling was famously a penniless mom on welfare when she penned the magical adventures of Harry Potter on a caf table.
C.S. Lewis, who created the "Chronicles of Narnia" (which has been made into another movie to be released later this year), was a great intellectual and scholar, a professor at Oxford and then Cambridge who became known around the world for his many Christian apologetics, the best-known being "The Screwtape Letters."
Another great mind involved in fantasy writing was J.R.R. Tolkien, creator of "Lord of the Rings," who was a friend of Lewis, an Oxford don and a fellow writer of fantasy.
It seems it takes an entirely different type of mind to reach into a child's imagination and make a fantasy world come alive, both the widely schooled, the unschooled and the home-schooled.
At the movies over the weekend, Jodie Foster's airplane thriller "Flightplan" finished No. 1 in its first week in release, bringing in $24.65 million. Tim Burton's animated "Corpse Bride" jumped up from No. 23 to take the No. 2 position with $20.13 million in ticket sales, followed by last week's No. 1, "Just Like Heaven," at No. 3.
In home movies, the ensemble drama "Crash" finished No. 1 on Billboard's top rentals chart for the week ended Sept. 18, pushing "Monster-in-Law" to No. 2.
There were a slew of new releases on the Billboard 200 album chart, with seven rookies in the top 10 for the week ended Sept. 18. Paul Wall's "The Peoples Champ" topped them all, finishing No. 1 and pushing Kanye West's "Late Registration" to No. 2. The Black Eyes Peas' "Monkey Business" and Mariah Carey's "The Emancipation of Mimi" were the other two non-new releases in the top 10.
Showing impressive longevity, Dan Brown's "The Da Vinci Code" topped the New York Times' hardcover fiction bestsellers list in its 131st week in release, the week ended Sept. 17, knocking Clive Cussler with Paul Kemprecos' "Polar Shift" to No. 2.
"Eldest: Inheritance, Book II" by Christopher Paolini topped USA Today's book chart for the week ended Sept. 18, followed for the second straight week by "Natural Cures 'They' Don't Want You to Know About" by Kevin Trudeau, "Hour Game" by David Baldacci and "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince" by J.K. Rowling.
17