Why isn't Snape the DADA teacher yet?

Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#1

Why isn't Snape the Defense Against the Dark Arts Teacher yet?

I have always found this odd, so I've tried to examine three of the most important angles here:

  1. Issue of Dumbledore's trust:

We are all aware that Snape was the only Death Eater who turned against Voldemort; he was the only person who risked becoming a spy against the Dark Side.

Dumbledore clearly trusts Snape as we have observed in the following instances:

  • Snape was one of the teachers who guarded the Philosopher's Stone
  • He tried to save Harry during that Quidditch Match jinx in Year 1
  • Snape is a member of the Order of the Phoenix inspite of his Death Eater background.
  • Snape was specially requested to tutor Harry in Occlumency

It is clear that in spite of his detestation for Harry, Snape would never intentionally try to kill him.

2. Issue of Qualifications

As Sirius mentions, even in his school days, Snape knew more about the dark arts than anyone in sixth year! This implies that he is obviously well qualified in the field.

Yet, even though Snape applies for the Defense Against the Dark Arts position every single year, he is rejected for teachers who are often useless and who have no knowledge whatsover (with the exception of Lupin)

3. Issue with Moral character

Little is known about Snape's background. We only got to know more about him in OoTP when Harry accidentaly sees his worst memories.

  • Snape had 2 parents and a sister.
  • His family is pureblood and deeply rooted in the Dark Arts. Hence, he develops a prejudice against Muggle families (Mudbloods)...Remember how he calls Lily a mudblood?
  • From the beginning, we can guess that he is part of a dysfunctional home - his father and mother had blazing rows and as a child, Snape was scared and lonely
  • He had a good relationship with his sister (possibly). We remember from a fragment of the memory that a girl was laughing at Snape when he tried to ride a broomstick. This is still arguable as she may be mocking him as well...the way the Dursley's mock Harry
  • He was an outcast in School and was always bullied by the Marauders (for no reason whatsoever at times)

It could be argued that Snape is not really a bad guy. He's just had a very bad childhood and his school life wasn't any better. He did join the dark side, but he returned again which implies that his heart is in the right place.

QUESTION: In spite of all this, why isn't Snape chosen to be a DADA teacher?

Your Thoughts and Opinions are most welcome!

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

3.9k

Users

3

Frequent Posters

daniel_4ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
WELL IF SNAPE IS THE DADA TEACHER IT WILL BE A PAIN FOR HARRY COZ HE'LL KEEP TAKING POINTS FROM HIS HOUSE.............. BUT ON THE OTHER HAND I THINK THAT HE SHOULD BE TAKEN AS THE DADA TEACHER BY HAVING A LOOK AT HIS QUALIFICATION
Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#3

Well, he keeps taking points away from Harry even in Potions or for other foolish reasons.

I mean, Snape does teach Harry, one way or another. Its just odd that he would not be allowed to teach this particular subject.

mumbai_masti thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#4
well it has nothing to do with harry as his student....

may be in HBP we will know the true reasons why snape is not DADA teacher. but i think he is the best available teacher for potions thats why dumbledore rejects his DADA application....what do u say???
Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#5

Thats a possibility.

Maybe the Potions Teachers are worse than the DADA applicants. 😆

daniel_4ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6
well i think sooooooo ..................... he is the best teacher for potion............... but as sirius told harry that snape was the best in DADA ...... but surely Dumbledore must have a reason behind it ......... maybe we can get to know why in the 6 th book

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".