horcrux

I was wondering....if snape is still loyal to dumbldore...and only killed dumbledore because of his orders...which i think is likely...since dumbledore wouldn;t make such a big mistake of trusting snape if he was with voldy.( also... when dumbledore was saying..severus ...please it sounded more like he was asking him to kill him) .....why did dumbledore want himself to be killed?.....i mean how would it benefit harry ....maybe dumbledore has something to do with the horcrux....i think he might have been a horcrux..if thats possible...

nah, tht doesnt seem likely

nah.... I don't think so too....

Tejas

hmmmm....but im not able to understand what could be so imp. 2 dumbledore other than helping harry in life by being there with him against voldey?????

i had tht thought after reading HBP too....but i dun think there is anything more imp other than helping harry against voldey! 😕

No, I don't think it's possible, Dumbledore being the only one Voldy feared and all.. 😊

i highly doubt that too...

i guess it was to make sure that their side still had a spy among the death
eaters... because if snape did not kill dumbledore after draco wasnt able to,
snape would die because he broke an unbreakable vow and they would lose
the only spy they had among the death eaters

Originally posted by: SpoILed BraT

i highly doubt that too...

i guess it was to make sure that their side still had a spy among the death
eaters... because if snape did not kill dumbledore after draco wasnt able to,
snape would die because he broke an unbreakable vow and they would lose
the only spy they had among the death eaters

well i think he told snape to kill him but dont u think by killing dumbledore he has put all member of the order of phonix agaist him ....

who will belive him tht he did it coz dumbledore told him???

Have you by any chance got these thoughts from www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com ?

-Sam 😳

Originally posted by: lovelyprincesst

well i think he told snape to kill him but dont u think by killing dumbledore
he has put all member of the order of phonix agaist him ....

who will belive him tht he did it coz dumbledore told him???

yea... that's true too... but its not like the members of the order liked him
very much anyway... 😆

Thats very unlikely, but I had that thought too, but I dismissed it very quickly, and the reason it happened was:
Voldemort set Draco a task. That task was that to kill Dumbledore. I think that a very powerful wizard would not be unaware of what and where he was making a horcrux of. So, that clearifies that he was either really trying to kill a part of himself (considering your theory that Dumby is a horcrux) otherwise, we should let the topic drop.

PS: Alia, what happened? Why does Tom Felton "SUCK" all of a sudden???