Discussion of the Week - Neville - Page 2

yup... you know, this is one thing i've always wondered about! 😉😛 is neville's inability inherent or all because he was using HIS DAD'S WAND??? 😕😊
that's one thing, that clears up the confusion regarding neville's wizarding abilities in ootp when he says he broke his dad's wand... i suppose a wand always works better in the hands of the one it is MADE for😃😆...
has there been ANY mention of neville doing better in 6th year??? if there is ANY info to support this, it just proves that he HAS the ability in him... just that his wand was not quite right for him...!

omg... tejas ur avi is SCARY...

Originally posted by: albusdumbledore

yeah I guess I goofed on that one..... didn't mom say too much of movies will get your brain.... should've listened to her.😉😆

regards,

tejas

😆😆😆

Well we know that both Harry and Neville fit in the description the prophecy made but Voldie chose Harry.

However I feel Neville will certainly have a big part in future where he'll avenge his parents. He is the one who has the right to kill Bella for wot she did to his parents(Harry too ofcourse for wot she did to Sirius) but Harry's got Voldie to take care of foremost.

Well maybe and I repeat *maybe* (its just a long shot) the prophecy did mean Neville not Harry(dumby can make mistakes isnt it) and "one cannot live while other is alive" so Voldie will kill Neville in the end(plz dont hate me for that!) when he's actually aiming at Harry and Harry will kill Voldie finally. Neville would die a brave death.

Dunno its lame but I'll come up with something better later. Im too lazy to grind my mind right now!

what is trevor up to

maybe trevor is umbridge, umbridge an animagus, remember how many times jkr mentioned umbridge's toad like face, remember, and i know im not the only one who thinks this 😊

Originally posted by: goth princess

maybe trevor is umbridge, umbridge an animagus, remember how many times jkr mentioned umbridge's toad like face, remember, and i know im not the only one who thinks this 😊

im not sure harooj😕

i really dont think that trevor has ne important role, he is probably in the book for some comic relief and to add on neville's personallity or sumthin...

as for umbrige, she is probably described as a toad becasue she is just plain hideus😆

Originally posted by: ashi rocks

Hey cool discussion toic! Neville! 😃

I have got a fanfiction on Neville, which I think you all should definitely read. I liked reading it!

Neville Longbottom

Cheers! 😃

thanx

Originally posted by: alia

hey evry1...
was just readin the chat transcript at mugglenet...
found tht intresting... wht do u guys think about it??

this is interesting...

i think it is a possibillity that he was subjected to a memory charm, but it was probably a very powerful one, considering how he forgets a lot of things. but i just cant think of why he would have been hit with it in the first place. could he have known sumthing or was it just a freak accident?? ...but it wont make sence that he knew sum secret, b/c hes been forgetfull since he was a kid rite? and y wat would he remember that could be potentially dangerouse info?

Originally posted by: sugar bun

yup... you know, this is one thing i've always wondered about! 😉😛 is neville's inability inherent or all because he was using HIS DAD'S WAND??? 😕😊
that's one thing, that clears up the confusion regarding neville's wizarding abilities in ootp when he says he broke his dad's wand... i suppose a wand always works better in the hands of the one it is MADE for😃😆...
has there been ANY mention of neville doing better in 6th year??? if there is ANY info to support this, it just proves that he HAS the ability in him... just that his wand was not quite right for him...!

i thought about this too, cos its the wand that chooses the wizard, remember...so i think yr right

dont u think theres more to neville that jkr has shown, well remember he is in gryffindor, even though he doesnt seem very brave, but he is, he coped with wot happened to his parent, thats bravery, i know and at the ministry he was brave too...but dont u think theres more to it...i think in book 6, he will have a bigger part 😳

Originally posted by: goth princess

dont u think theres more to neville that jkr has shown, well remember he is in gryffindor, even though he doesnt seem very brave, but he is, he coped with wot happened to his parent, thats bravery, i know and at the ministry he was brave too...but dont u think theres more to it...i think in book 6, he will have a bigger part 😳

harooj i think u ment book 7!😆

and i think, well to me, its quite obvious he will have a bigger part, sumthing ver important in the last book.