Is this a blooper?

In today's episode, Akshay tells Prathna that Gyan was living in Mumbai alone all along, and his family lives in Punjab. If this is the case, then why didn't Gyan say anything to Sid when she said living in a joint family was the reason she didnt want to marry him? Sid didn't want to live in a joint family, its not like she has a problem with a man with a family. And they have clearly shown that Gyan is unhappy not being able to marry Sid.. he wudn't have to go thru all this if he had just told her the fact in the 1st place.. something seems amiss here😕

Either Gyan didn't get it, or the director just got confused himself!😆

hehe you have a point. very often the directors lose track of the story line and forget minor details. 😊

LOL you're right Kru!

Seem like they made a little blooper...Or maybe it was just that Gyan got disturbed by the fact that Siddhi was having a problem with his family and thats why he didnt tell her?

i was wondering the same..

writers need to pay more attention cause it ppl like us will find small details..but i guess since it was so noticeable..they have point behind that statement or not!!

gyan is soo not ready for this wedding.. do somethinggg 😳

Originally posted by: Rinkalp90

i was wondering the same..

writers need to pay more attention cause it ppl like us will find small details..but i guess since it was so noticeable..they have point behind that statement or not!!

gyan is soo not ready for this wedding.. do somethinggg 😳

I really don't get the point behind that statement. Gyan is so much in love with her, that he was heartbroken when she refused to marry him, and now he is obv unhappy to marry this other girl. It seems like he would give anything to make Sid change her mind... and he never mentioned that he lives alone.. when that was the only thing standing in b/w him and Sid.

Originally posted by: *Kruthi*

I really don't get the point behind that statement. Gyanis so much in love with her, that he was heartbroken when she refused to marry him, and now he is obv unhappy to marry this other girl. It seems like he would give anything to make Sid change her mind... and he never mentioned that he lives alone.. when that was the only thing standing in b/w him and Sid.

kru he prolly didn't mention that because at that time he was with his family..
and its weird cause to me it looks like prathana's maayka and punjab is like 30 mins away. remember when Siddhi was running to meet and have dinner with Gyan's family.. more i think on this topic. i feel like writers are fooling us. cause some of the stuff dont make sense to me.. like when the first time gyan entered, where did he came from? punjab? or out of country? 😕

No, i dont think this is a blooper.. Gyan is such an obedient son and family man, that when Siddhi said she hates to live in joint family, he never told the fact that he has such a big family etc, Gyan must have felt sad...

What if they stay in Mumbai? The fact remains that Siddhi will never want to go to Gyan's family and cannot even stand them for a minute.. Probably Gyan took all this into consideration..

U can just see, if it is true that Gyan stays alone in Mumbai, for him, he is always with his family.. Bcos his family membes are so close to each other and love each other so much...

yea few thngs were left hanging in the air.

Maybe the would explain more later on when the show goes on?

But HGKKH doesnt seem the type of serial to be holding raaz's. Its more of a open book kind.
But some things dont really make sense like Gyan not telling Siddhi abt where he really lives, and Gyan's sudden entry, and Siddhi going off to London and suddenly back again! 😕

Originally posted by: sree

No, i dont think this is a blooper.. Gyan is such an obedient son and family man, that when Siddhi said she hates to live in joint family, he never told the fact that he has such a big family etc, Gyan must have felt sad...

What if they stay in Mumbai? The fact remains that Siddhi will never want to go to Gyan's family and cannot even stand them for a minute.. Probably Gyan took all this into consideration..

U can just see, if it is true that Gyan stays alone in Mumbai, for him, he is always with his family.. Bcos his family membes are so close to each other and love each other so much...

sree di. Siddhi never told Gyan that she hates joint family.. she found out when she went to Gyan's house for dinner.. she was shocked to see joint family so she left the house and after that they both told each other about it..

Originally posted by: Rinkalp90

sree di. Siddhi never told Gyan that she hates joint family.. she found out when she went to Gyan's house for dinner.. she was shocked to see joint family so she left the house and after that they both told each other about it..

Hmm, you have a point... 😳I am confused now.. hehe...