HJ analysis so far: Survival of the fittest? - Page 2

@sammy

" Lovely post Minu,, fully agree with you..

@ bellie, its implicit isn't it -- in fact more than implicit -- in the way they are casting the sisters. Just look at DAdi's reaction to her and at Sahil's dadi'd rejection of her. She did not even give her time to get to know her better or understand her more -- leave alone room to grow.

Sometimes I doubt Mahi's character too. She goes to the temple when Ishu stays back making excuses. She tells God to forgive Ishu that too loudly so her dadi and the whole public could hear 😆. Ishu at least was honest in saying mujhe bemann mandir nahin jaana and she prayed to God quietly saying sorry - that is between her and God Lolz, she is way more genuine.

i dont get it why people can just see what type of person ishu is. today the precap proves my point. who started this misunderstanding in first place? it was ishu. did she ask for details once? no simply jumped to conclusions and also conveyed this misunderstanding to sahil. she is shouting at sahil for playing a game but does she once realize her own mistakes? no. i m with dadi in this case. she wants to defeat mahi well newsflash for her she has never really been able to defeat mahi by herself coz that is what happens why someone lies all the time. she is breaking things without thinking that the same mahi who has supported her all the time cannot do this to her. well i hate her for today's behavior. she crossed all limits.

Originally posted by: vids08

Sometimes I doubt Mahi's character too. She goes to the temple when Ishu stays back making excuses. She tells God to forgive Ishu that too loudly so her dadi and the whole public could hear 😆. Ishu at least was honest in saying mujhe bemann mandir nahin jaana and she prayed to God quietly saying sorry - that is between her and God Lolz, she is way more genuine.

Also when Dai asks her to give the bangles. Ishu makes a face but still moves it. But what prevents Mahi from taking it. Bitter memories of Ishu as a child. She did not remember the things Ishu shared with her and the encouragement Ishu gave her as a child.

Yes, Ishu and Sahil are more genuine people in the show. Whatever they are thats what they are!!!

Also Ishu is fighting for what she thinks is hers and nothings wrong. She gets worked up when people encroach her space, which I think will happen with this track as well.

Well said!

@ John, tthe last two epis show so clearly the extent to which Dadi et all will go to keep Ishu out of Mahi's space. The whole misunderstanding began when Dadi played her little game to prevent Ishu from going to see Sahil's dadi when she visited them...and all the round about ways in which she put a wall around Ishu. How on earth will Ishu think anything other than herself in connection with Sahil's dadi? She is the one that has a past relationship with her and how will she dream that Mahi is somehow involved?

And did Mahi ever complete her sentence that this is the guy's pic is for her?

Ishu is a person given to extremes of temperament -- for whatever reason from the past. So the throwing things is totally understandable. What was hers till now is being taken away from her and she was deliberately kept in the dark about it. Agreed, not everyone would react the way she did, but then that's her. I can understand what she's going through.

What type of girl is Ishu.

@minu2011 and vidya

" Ishu is a person given to extremes of temperament -- for whatever reason from the past. So the throwing things is totally understandable."

personally, i can understand why ishu is all like that and respect your sentiment...but what i cannot understand is why that same logic is not applied in judging other characters of the show. Okay, her dadi deliberately kept her out of SD that day, but we all know why she did that right ? did she know that ishu loves sahil whose rishta they were talking about ? she had something evil in her mind against ishu in doing that ?? why some people cannot see the reason here when they can understand ALL THE REASONS behind ishu's behaviour n acts. (hey by " some people " i didn't mean you 2, was just speaking in general😊)

Still, after all this, okay so her dadi prevented her from meeting SD, what prevented ishu from calling her ? when you thought your would be MIL came in to your house and for some reason u couldn't meet her, what would be the first thing you would have done ? and i believe ishu especially should have phoned her coz their previous meeting was totally messed up.

Same thing with Mahi, first and foremost, okay yeah she mentioned her sister as one of her reasons, but she said it totally out of concern for her, and also that was not the only reason she was unwilling for the marriage. How cleverly others are trying to ignore that it is totally amusing. She was also afraid of money because she thought it was responsible for her parents death. Now whether with u agree with her thoughts or not is an altogether different point but it is not that really hard to see the reasons behind her concerns.

And ishu's mom is a total joke. i can bet even mahi would have played a much bigger role in the upbringing of her own daughter.

On a side note- why the like button is not working ? are others also facing the same problem...i am also not able to post anything on the fan-page of heena, earlier i thought it might be a browser problem so i tried posting with another one but still the problem persists😲

@Bellie

@Vidya

fair enough Vidya, but just wanna tell you that i never tried to force anyone to like someone, i don't know why you thought that i am forcing you to like mahi. If any of my posts looked like i am imposing my POVs or my likings on others, then it must have come out so totally unintentional.
And one more thing, yes I am a Mahi fan but also of Ishu, and I have been a fan of Ishu before Ishu was Neha Sargam. and though i dont like NS since her indian idol days but that is off-topic.

@ Bellie