Justice or revenge: would you think Tanmay villain

Poll

Has Shikha told Tanmay all?

Login To Vote
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Last night, they showed Tanmay, after seeing Shikha's wound, run all over the woods looking for RV, and eventually finding him dead. He then does the last rites and all (all single-handedly, w/ no one to support him?) and brings RV's remains back, and searing to finish off RV's killer.

So how much do you think Shikha either told him, or got to tell him? Did she deliberately withold her bro's guilt, or did she just not get a chance to tell him due to Tanmay panicking? Poll above. Since she wasn't upset when Avi revealed to everyone that he had killed RV, isn't she obviously faking her tears for Tanmay's consumption?

Incidentally, I disagree that if Tanmay wants to get justice for his bro, that would make him a villain. Even if he knew that Avi was the killer, the least he - and RV - deserve is Avi landing in jail. This doesn't mean Avi has to be physically tortured once he's in jail, like Arpi was earlier - just give him due process in a court and after landing him in jail, let him rot there for a while. If his goon pals try and work a break-out, then I wouldn't fault Tanmay for trying to kill Avi after that.
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgwy_tsKAcQ[/YOUTUBE]
Also, while RV did have his share of faults, fact remains that it was not after due process that he was found guilty of misusing his powers, but rather, as a result of BJ bribing his superior. One of the things Tanmay should do is restore his honor by exposing that fact - that he was improperly removed, and to do that, he should expose that the goons have been bribing the police. I certainly hope that he gets to do that and not only get Avi arrested, but BJ as well, as well as get RV's boss removed. That way, he can bring justice to his bro.

Of course, if he decides to go the gunda route and murder RV or others, that would be plain revenge, as opposed to seeking justice, which would make him a villain. But if he does things as per the law and lands Avi and BJ in jail, or even just Avi in jail, would you still consider him a villain?

So to sum it up, is Tanmay entitled to get any justice for RV and rehabilitate him, or would you be upset at anything done against Avi, even attempting to get him to jail? Or should he simply dance to the tunes of his sasural?
Edited by _Vrish_ - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

2.9k

Users

8

Likes

66

Frequent Posters

chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
tanus reactions were right but his acting made me laugh


i also felt tanu and rv shared good bond and more loving than shikha or avdesh cud ever have had..

when rv enterd the scene he did seem to love his brother a lot.

i want to go with ur way for some part

i dont think he wud turn full villain and he is not a cop either
from yday episode it seemed he was in some business and i also think shikha didnt tell him full or mayb tried to keep her own brother safe

it wud be in best interest for shikha to tell tanmay everything

if he is not listening she shud just put the tape on

and later let tanu go on clue hunting spree and find bahuji's role in all the drama

since pihu story is about to start tanu baby track wud be temporarily i think
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
I doubt that Tanmay will be able to land Avi in jail right away, since the authorities have been bribed. So I'm hoping for one of 2 things - either Tanmay to join forces w/ Pihu and expose BJ, or Tanmay to blackmail Avi about Shikha unless he voluntarilty goes to jail. While Shikha loves her bro and would do anything to save his life, she has to grant that she has some duties at least to her sasural, and if her bro is responsible for murder, he ought to be in jail. This doesn't mean that once there, he ought to be tortured, but he does deserve to be in jail.

What Tanmay can do is w/o necessarily torturing Shikha, he can tell Avi to voluntarily turn himself in, and his sister would be safe. Or he could plot w/ Pihu to rattle the Thakur household until BJ gets exposed. Once BJ gets exposed, expose her bribery of the police as well and get her arrested as well. Only thing about this - Arpita, after getting justice against BJ, would have to live w/ Avi in jail. Since Avi broke his vow to her not to murder, maybe she can rationalize it on those grounds.
chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
vrish about rv first of all he was no saint

he was saint when he came in mayb but his motives changed coz he thought a gunda has insulted him and his authority or power..

then rv misused all his power to torture arpita in jail

then he again did wrong by using arpita again with that so called indecent proposal

so he had to pay for his deeds

his own ego made him lose control and he had no other motive

tanu thinks his bro is god

but rv was god only to tanu and no one else and he did care for his baby brother

tanu has to know how much of a god was rv.
then he wud calm down

later stage when he finds out bahuji had bribed the superior to fire rv then he can find more clues and help pihu

avdesh for now wud remain safe andcontinue his gunda raj

bahuji has sort of emotionally blackmailed him that women folk in haveli depend on avdesh for everything and for them he wud continue being so called protector

talkie14 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Hi Vrish..Nice topic..As I see it the only good thing ABout RV was that he was a good brother...The scene where only Tanu was there for his funeral kind of summed it all up... I feel Tnu will go on to torture Shika or keep insulting her..And if we have jump of ayear before Pihu shows up we would also see a suffering Shika who Pihu will have to help in dues course... As for Avdesh I would rather have seen him jail thinking over past events & reformed fully rather than have him out as a full lfedged loser Gunda. when Pihi comes on to the scene.....
chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
no lakshmi i doubt tanu wud insult or torture shikha

till yday we dont know if tanu knows avdesh killed rv. i think he just may ignore shikha and dont know if shikha did tell avdesh killed rv.

for shikha she has proof so why doesnt she just play it out..

and a leap of yr

lakshmi r u assuming leap or was it shown as leap yday

we dont knwo that yet

hv to see todays episode to know what happens next


tanu's action made me laugh coz he was simply aping avdesh in holding the pic and falling dhadaam on the floor
thats why i was laughing
swamini5 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
Hi Vrish
At last we could see some acting skills of Tanu all these while he was like a n extra just filling the camera space.
I feel Tanu anger is justified after all Rv was his only family and he genuinely took care of Tanu
As for shika i don' think he will trouble her......
And for revenge he will take his own sweet time and plan out something very drastic cause he knows BHAIYAJI se revenge lena is not that easy
talkie14 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Tanu's acting leaves a lot to be desired... I guess that why we just had him smiling till now..I am just assuming there is a leap Di..Di aap ne toh mere predictions ko immediately reject kar diya...🤣
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: laxmi73

Hi Vrish..Nice topic..As I see it the only good thing ABout RV was that he was a good brother...The scene where only Tanu was there for his funeral kind of summed it all up... I feel Tnu will go on to torture Shika or keep insulting her..And if we have jump of ayear before Pihu shows up we would also see a suffering Shika who Pihu will have to help in dues course... As for Avdesh I would rather have seen him jail thinking over past events & reformed fully rather than have him out as a full lfedged loser Gunda. when Pihi comes on to the scene.....



Laxmi, thanks!

If they show a year's leap, they have to show a baby w/ Shikha & Tanmay. Incidentally, the way Shikha has been acting - like last night, helping lift Ammaji back on her wheelchair - who'd think she's pregnant? Has she digested the fetus? 😆 Maybe Tanmay can torture her by naming him (if it's a guy) Ranvijay or Walkvijay. 😆

I don't think that Tanmay needs to, nor should, insult Shikha. Even if she plays out RV's confession, he can still claim that murder was not the right answer, and insist that Avdesh turn himself in if he wants peace b/w the families. Incidentally, Shikha now has an idyllic sasural - no jealous jethanis or wheelchair bound ammas to take care of.

But I dearly want to see a Tanmay-Pihu coalition against BJ. Still hoping Pandit is secretly against BJ, and fills him in on how BJ got RV removed, so that instead of concentrating on just Avdesh, he can turn against BJ

And yeah, the guy who plays Tanmay is doing a pretty mediocre job acting - reminds me of Hayden Christiansen.
Edited by _Vrish_ - 14 years ago
chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
hahaha reject totally nahi kiya hai.. lage raho who knws mayb ur prediction is right hahaa

mera toh ho hi nahi raha tumhara hi sahi


and hey swamini i also feel tanu hasnt had much to do apart from giving smiles

still i think compared to rv character and avdesh character he seems out of place.. but u know what they say the ppl u underestimate they only give u run for ur own money

he cud very well turn out to be dark horse here.

as per sbs segment seeing avdesh back in gundagardi mode

it seems he still hasnt realise how much of bewakoof he is again

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".