New OS:A Mother's Dilemma updt Pg-4 - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.4k

Users

12

Likes

122

Frequent Posters

minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: alanta

*deep sigh*...If only my words could do justice...my memories went back to those days when the show was on air and those scenes kept on flashing through my mind all through reading this OS...Alanta,thank you so much

The show went off air about 5 months ago,..but this forum proves , what an effect this show had left on us...even every single dialogue of Gulsar is echoing all around here.so true😊.and this OS thread simply marks the evidence ...great job...👏..both of u..and it has to be na?? The result would be always greater for a combined effort..and so it did.awww thank you😳.and the concept itself is very innovative and very interesting and coming to the OS they are the typical Kesar and Gulaal and that too from such a phase of the story where there was a Gulaal, whom was in search of her Kesar in him and a Kesar who used to avoid his Gulaal to the best as far as he could hurt her, but a single negligence from her and he could hardly be survived...Excellent portrayal of the respective POVs of Gulaal and Kesar by Mini and Aditi👏 👏 ...I agree,Aditi brought out that frustration and fear wonderfully na.and kyun na ho Kesar tho uska apna hai😆actually that's what inspired me to write my bit about Gulaal otherwise this was strictly supposed to be only about Kesar
and I had requested her to write this piece which she agreed to immediately😊

I would like to join Piu and I too wish if u both would write something on the probable convo between Kesar and Panba on the day when Gulaal left the badi haveli..if only Panba had not brought the topic of Talli in between to escape from his doubts and sharp questions that remained unanswered till the end..Alanta,good one na.will consult with Aditi and think about it

Hope u both would come up with another one soon...🤗🤗


Thank you so much for the thoughtful comments Alanta🤗You are a sweet heart.I am so glad that you enjoyed this OS😃
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: kiran_trudecent

res 🤗

edit:

wow wow wow mini n aditi, fantastic guys, hugs to both of u 🤗 u brought the old memories back, i was able to see kesar n gulaal in front of me yaar the plight of gulaal, the pain which she went through, n kesar's pain also how gulaal was trying hard to find her out of this young man who had returned from the hostel n on the other hand, kesar trying to hurt gulaal but instead he ended up hurting himself... wow yaar lovely write up from both of u, i loved both gulaal n kesar's point of views, waiting to read something more from u guys 😃


Kiran,that was the best phase of Gulaal.We could empathise with both the characters.I mean if in one episode we got angry with Kesar and sided with Gulaal the very next episode we would go awww for Kesar and get angry on Gulaal😭Those were the golden days of Gulaal for me😊
Thank you for the constant support yaar🤗
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: nneeiill

that was very will written...in show i guess we got some of the feeling of kesar coming thru his letters but gulaal's feeling abt kesar's rude behaviour were not explicitly shown...so it was nice reading that part...


Thank you so much Nithya🤗I am glad you liked it.
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Kesarmania

Hi mini loved it totally. Purani yaadein taaza hogayi :-) Shradha🤗thank you
i have sum scenes of kes-gul in 3gp format in my cell, which i watch wen i m bored or wen i feel low. One of the clip is of this scene .I too love this scene a lot.makes me emotional every single time😭
Last para was so emotional, it brought tears in my eyes:-(Credit goes entirely to Aditi.She brought out Kesar's pain,anger,frustration everything so beautifully😳
keep up the gud work of writing such beautifull os.
Thank u aditi , for helping my frn :-)


Shradha,thank you so much for the support yaar🤗Take care.
enchanted23 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: minizz


Piu,thank you so much for the support yaar.I am so glad you enjoyed it.now I want to see both a Piu Turba and a Tantrum😆
Mini I like this idea chalo try karte hai...Piyu thanks for the lovely idea we will try our best😳

minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
Aditi,me too,yep let's try it out.will talk about this later😃
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
Guys,This is our take on the infamous PB and Kesar conversation where Talli was dragged into unnecessarily.Most of us wanted to see PB answer Kesar's questions,make him understand about Gulaal's state of mind but instead she played the Talli card and conveniently washed her hands off the issue.Aditi and I have tried our best to make it convincing.Hope you all will like it so here goes



A Mother's Dilemma


"Gulaal chali gayi...woh hum sab ko chod kar chali gayi...",the picture of Kesar breaking down in tears crying for Gulaal in front of her once again brought tears to her eyes.She had never felt so helpless in her life.Her son needed her the most now and she had no idea what to do,how to comfort and help him.what did that say about her skills as a mother?But sometimes it felt as if she did not know a thing about him.That thought made her all the more restless.She knew in her heart even though she would never acknowledge openly,Vasant had been her favourite,her first born-he had a special place in her heart that none of her other children could ever claim.She knew that mothers were not supposed to be partial but she couldn't help herself.and Kesar,well she loved truly loved him but Vasant had always been the best person to handle him and his tantrums.After Gulaal came into the house as Vasant's wife,Kesar quickly laid his claim on her.She should have realized it at the time that her son was becoming too attached to Gulaal but in a way she was relieved that there was some one else who would take care of Kesar.At the same time there was a tinge of jealousy too that Gulaal had soon become the most important person in Kesar's life along with Vasant.Kesar did not need her anymore and that thought sometimes hurt her.

Vasant's death had been a huge blow to them all and Kesar may have suffered the most.Even before she could properly mourn her beloved son's death, she had to come to terms with Gulaal's decision to go through the ritual of DV with Kesar,her 12 year old son.Though at first she had been disgusted and angered by this,slowly she started to realize the sacrifice hidden in her Daughter-in-law's decision.She never once thought of herself or her future.Her love for Vasant and her concern for his family especially Kesar overwhelmed her.As a woman she could understand her young DIL's courage and pain but as a mother she still held that grudge against her.

She could empathise with Kesar's feelings.yes,she had been shocked to hear him say that he was in love in Gulaal but didn't she always know it?yes...she did,she knew it when he came in drunk on Holi and insisted on Gulaal serving him food because she was his wife,she knew it when he cried himself to sleep in her lap muttering Gulaal's name and saying how could his Gulaal slap him?She always knew but then when he was sent off to Hostel she thought that the problem was taken care of.Now she realized that she underestimated her son's feelings.To everyone else the DV was just a ritual in name but for her son it was the biggest truth of his life.Gulaal was his wife and so how could it be wrong for him to love his wife?

Panba knew Kesar needed her support and guidance now and even if she couldn't help him out she could at least be there for him.

Panba decided to bring him his dinner.Kesar had not eaten anything since Gulaal's hasty departure yesterday and he had not come out of his room the whole day.She saw him sitting on the ground in deep thought,silent tears streaming down on his face.She came near him and sat down beside him.She looked at her son,the pain in his eyes made him look far more mature than his years.She ruffled his hair lovingly and called out "Kesar...beta".Kesar turned around in a daze and slowly blinking his eyes silently hugged his mother.For the first time in a long time she felt needed but it did not comfort her in the slightest instead it hurt her beyond reason to see her baby in pain."No", she decided determinedly..."I need to be strong.For once I need to his mother and be there for him".She comforted him,let him cry patting his back and slowly held him back.She wipes away his tears and then slowly speaks "beta,kuch khaa le.Tu ne kal se kuch bhi nahi khaya...kha le beta".Kesar silently refuses to eat,taking the plate away from his mother and keeping it aside.

PB: Kesar I understand your pain, your distress and your turmoil son,but you need to understand mine too,I can't see you like this,How can you expect me to eat when you have refused to put anything in your mouth from last 24 hours'.

Kesar:(with resigned sigh! putting his head in PB's lap) Ba I am sorry I have been really selfish in past few days,please forgive me,I am trying to find answers to my questions that have been bugging me and I have been so focused in searching for these that I have become oblivious to my near ones sufferings'.

PB: Kesar I know what's bothering you son, and let me make something very clear, you are not wrong to feel the way you feel, Yes I accept that loving and caring for someone is not something that you can control it happens naturally, You are not wrong to harbour love for Gulaal what is wrong is to expect the same in return, to anticipate that she will also feel the same way about you, For her Vasant was her past and he is her present, She has never seen or accepted anyone in that place,If you want to be part of her future you need to rise above this expectations,put her first,put her needs first,understand her heart and way to her happiness,rise beyond your wants and embrace her choice, love doesn't teach you to be selfish son,pyaar sharto pe nahi hota Kesar,aur agar hota hai to woh pyaar nahi hai'..

Kesar: Ba why does age matter in love? if a man falls in love with a woman who is 10 years younger than him,the society doesn't have a problem, why is that more acceptable?but when the same is reversed and a guy falls in love with a woman 10 years older than him,the society disapproves,isn't this hypocrisy?

PB: Kesar this is the way of society, we cannot change outlook of the society but that doesn't mean we have to live by the norm, MB and I are together because we did not believe in this norm and that's why I would advise you not to give up but keep trying to win her over, You have to make place in her heart and all these rules, society, ageism will come crashing down, it's her that you need to win over we need not fight with the society and their ideology nor do we redefine the way world looks at older woman and young man relationship, I am with you and will always be, my son you need to understand one thing that when a woman loves a man she gives herself completely to that love, totally encompasses herself for and within the boundary of her man's world she will always find it difficult to move out of that enclosed world, her world, the boundary that she binds herself in is something she will not cross within the proximity of this life and to gain insight into this world you have to be that guiding light that will not only penetrate this strong boundary but will also make her follow it outside her world,It's called journey to woman's heart ,the day you are able to successfully take it you will find answers to all your question'.

Panba then goes on to take the food she had brought and slowly feeds Kesar,who now had a small smile on his face.He looked a lot less restless and Panba could feel the tears threaten to overwhelm her when he proceeded to feed her from the plate.When she looked at him questioningly,Kesar replied "ba,aap ne bhi kuch nahi khaya na.mujhe maaf kar dijiye ba,main kamzor pad gaya tha lekin aap ki baaton ne mujhe honsla diya hai,ek umeed di hai.shaayad ab bhi kuch nahi bigda..."

Panba looked at Kesar with a genuine pride.Kesar was so different from Vasant yet they were so similar, both were honest and loyal to the core.Kesar might have different and sometimes less than desirable ways to show his concern and love but she knew that he was still learning and was sure that a day would come when Kesar would prove himself worthy of being Gulaal's life-partner in every sense...and who knows maybe Gulaal will fall in love with him...after all how long will she be able to resist her charming son?-Panba thought as Kesar made her eat a bite of roti and dal,concentration etched on his face...


Do read and comment cause it will help us.Thank you all for all the comments and the likes.we appreciate it a lot😊


Edited by minizz - 13 years ago
MR21 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28
res 😳

Edit:

Mini n Aditi 🤗...this is one of the scenes which we wanted to see...great that u did it as we always wished it to be in this way...
Coming to PB...her love for vasant n kesar...not sure whether she loved vasant more than kesar...but but but...she did understand n support vasant much more than kesar...whether her wish to see gulaal as her DIL as she could see her son's love for gulaal...but she did not see what does kesar feeling for gulaal...she was vasant's support in all the things that he did including going against MB to find Nirja...but she is unable to be the support when her son kesar needs it helplessly...I liked her when he explains him about being sahaara to gulaal n he did connected what she said...Coming to the scene that we r discussing...he so desperately need that support but what she did in the show...she brought talli in between n made him feel guilty...agree that he did not do correct with talli but bringing it now n making him feel even bad/miserable...is this the way a mother console her son who is in this condition... omg meine PB ke bhaaremein ithna kuch likhdiya 😲
Loved how u brought that she understood him n she also made him understand abt gulaal's side aswell...that vasant is gulaal's love even now...n to make gulaal understand n accept his love...he has to grow morally...above everyone's expectations...above gulaal's expectations...loved that she made him feel better n gave him that hope which he needed now very badly...the last part where they feed each other is also very good...if this scene is done in this way in the show...it would be a treat to watch...but no issues...u both r here to make our wish possible...

Haha...I wrote a big essay now ...I pity u that u have to read my rambling 😆
Need another one ASAP 😍

Edited by MR21 - 13 years ago
without-fathom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
Perfect treat for lunch break!!!

***

Okay, so I'm really happy you guys chose the circumstance and content that you, completing a scene that had felt like an opportunity so terribly missed back in the day when the episode was aired. i remember Shelly making a post about it - how PB had been a let down in that scene - and remember the whole debate that had followed over it.

Anyway - so its really good to see someone take a shot at changing how that scene had gone, cause it could have easily been a changing point if it was a card played right. Before I start off on PB, I want to compare and contrast this with Kesar and MB's talk right after the KT wedding was called off, where MB - so much more sensible than PB - brings to Kesar's attention BOTH sides of the story. His plight, and the consequence of his decisions. In his own way - much better than PB - he not only guides Kesar to find out where his heart truly lies, but at the same time makes him aware of the injustice he has bestowed upon both Gulaal and Talli in the wake of his recklessness. Encompassing therein, PB's point, but implementing it much better because Kesar needed more than being told what all he had done wrong!

Anyway - now coming to this piece - I love the fact that PB relieves him of the allegation of immorality of his love - and that in a logical manner, while also making sure she puts Gulaal's side forward and laying her truth of Vasant being the only one before him. I do think that the PB in the show - even when it the nice original one - did not have the foresight of having comprehended Kesar a decade ago, and honestly I also don't think there was much insinuation of her insecurity with Gulaal's role in Kesar's life - but yes, I love that you have explored that nuance, because it could have been a very natural shade to her character. One that mostly didn't get the space and time to be shown and grown - because we did see the slightest glimpse of it that time when PB tells off Gulaal for never having taken PB into account while deciding for KT a decade ago!

I want to add that I would have loved greater elaboration from PB over the whole "ritual" and essence of a DV as such - given that scene she had with Gulaal in the pre leap times when she tells her about MB and herself, and then later again, when Gulaal is widowed how she talks gravity and acceptance into her - I always thought when Kesar posed all these questions to her at this point, she had the perfect chance to share the same kind of empathy and maturity with him, as she had with Gulaal back then - and you did touch upon it in her mention of MB and herself, but just in that one take, I would have liked to see more elaboration.

Other than that - like I said in SUCH length above (geez the size of my comment!!! 😲) love the point you've picked up, and the way you've used PB-K talk the way it ought to have been in the first place. Kesar's return to some calm at the end, his realization of his multitude of responsibilities - very well portrayed 👏 ps: you know that dialogue PB and Kesar once had in the kitchen after Kesar had overheard rumors about GD in the village - it was the one time she had done him justice and I had wished this scene would have been sort of a follow up from there - thank you for doing it now! 🤗

xx
JZee
alanta thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
res.*.rush to read*

Edit..

Mini and Aditi..it was such a beautiful piece👏...loved it so much..so sensible and much convincing than from the show..if only the Panba of the show could tell Kesar the same...he was so alone at that time, no one was there with him and even when seek help from his mother, she seemed to be more concerned for Talli, and when he went and apologized to her, what she did also was accusing him..but Kesar didnt gave up na..he is such a strong guy and that was which caused him rise in his love..what u both wrote here was something like my long term wish has come true...for so many times I have wished to see a true mother in Panba ..what u have written is so true...I do felt the same..Vasanth was her all time favorite beta..but that was not entirely her fault na...as u said Vasanth was there for him always and after his death or even before that Gulaal came to his life and became the most important part of his life..and esp at the Talli-Kesar engagement day when Panba comes to know that Gulaal's K-T marriage plan was something based for a decade..our heart really goes for her na...we could really feel her pain...but the accusations laid on Gulaal by the second Panba was some thing way too much..if it was done by this Panba...then it would have been better...*sigh*...and ur Panba have given a logical explanation to his questions and am so happy to see a relieved Kesar at least here..Thank u so much for this wonderful gift😳
Edited by alanta - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".