New Beginnings, and Old Skeletons[CAPS(Nur)-pg4,5] - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

72

Views

5.4k

Users

16

Likes

159

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: surithy

Jezz and Reemz-I wasn't in anyway justifying PB, MB or any other characters. What I tried to say is our expectation of this show is so high and when it is nearing its end we are counting on each one of the final episodes. For me this show always dealt mind-blowingly with the human complex emotions that I was expecting something better with the aftermath of Gulaal concealing truth fiasco. To show real emotions for which we can see every characters and feel their pain instead of clear cut right and wrongs. I felt that last few episode has let us down in conveying the characters except GK and few others. Could I say the character of PB has been assassinated for whatever reason-acting combined with writing? I am disappointed with the execution of the aftermath. Instead of dealing with the actual issue fingers are pointed at Gulaal's character, ignoring her presence when she was allowed to stay in the house and taunting.

When I said about MB's punishment to Gulaal what I meant is for her to see and fell their disgust of themselves, shame of what all they had done to their son's killer, and the humiliation of so much at his own house while he is been giving verdicts to other as the village leader of appointing D to look after the village. I was not criticizing I was just talking about what they should show about these characters. Now it has come to a point we don't feel for these parent's great lose and tragedy.

Kesar leaving the house was not wrong, I am not asking for MB-Kesar convo either. I wanted it to be more powerful and justified since the show is nearing its end. These writers have the capability to make it more power pact. Not that he chosen to stand by Gulaal that bothers me but it could have been more justified. He is one man, who could feel both parties pain, the leaving talsagara house could have been more realistic rather than zombie PB ranting to some random people. I am talking more on the way it was executed than the character's fault. The episodes had more scope than what was delivered to us.



Surithy, I totally understand your point...somewhere I also feel that as we are winding towards the end, some things are not living up execution wise to the level they are capable of given this show's history in powerfully depicting the storyline...PB ofcourse being the focal point of this downslide...this is not to say the story is down the drain or the scenes aren't good...they are, still much much better than all the other nonsense on TV...but yes, I too somewhere have this expectation...a hope that we get something powerful to tie everything up by the end...

But I'm not sure how much of that will pan through given the time restrictions and the way they've maneuvered some characters like PB to set up this last phase...so time will tell how this culminates I guess...
surithy thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#72

Nur-Totally agree with you, if it was some other shows I wouldn't even bother to say things like this it is just the way they made this beautiful piece of art that even the tiniest things are bother me.

Many times in the past I have embarrassed myself complaining about the little things in one episode and got back to back brilliant episodes just due to the way the not so bad episode paved. So I crossed my fingers.

PS-It was my big expectation ever since Gulaal nominated D for sarpanch, that is why I am bit overreacting. Thank you for understanding, I am not good at expressing my view.

We sure need some happy happy moment of Gulser.
Edited by surithy - 14 years ago
without-fathom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#73
Did you watch today yet?! I need to watch it all again to get grip of chronology and logic - Nur, I personally loved the Giga showdown (if there wasn't all the GKI stuff in the second half, it would have been my favorite part of the episode) Raman's tears are probably of a weak person - somebody who is plain spineless. His regret - unlike Dushyant's - even if it is near honest for this moment has no power of reform... Anyway, Giga was brilliant and thank heavens he gave JK all that right left center. The presence of (if not solely) and then mostly excellent actors really made that scene worth watching - dare I say much better than the GK confronting before leaving the house?!

And of course, the GK scenes themself had so much underlying meaning and progress.

Overall - I'm happy with today, after 4 days of some nice GK teasers but mostly half baked scenes and sequences...

I too would love for GK to get some memorable moments. And even though the Giga matter seems like it might pave the way for packing off Kesar back home - but after today I want to believe again, what Reemz said yesterday - the CVs have a plan. No disagreeing with their slack in the last week and a half or a so - but the slack, as we all admit, is when compared to the usual high standard of the show... and while it is disappointing to get those kind of episodes which just flare into redundancy and melodrama - today was like a reminder that this show is brilliant, beneath it all! If the CVs have a plan - I just want to watch what it is about. I know GK will be brilliant, this way or that. And Monday precap certainly seems promising atm.

BTW - it struck me today, that the making of Kunal's character is somewhat like Vasant - only more contemporary. The difference between Talli and Gulaal is what makes Kesar a better partner for Gulaal, even though Vasant loved her with all his heart too. She's far more convoluted a person - than Talli - and Kesar and his complications just match up! Anyway - the whole Kulli drama is still... a space eater... but I suppose there's no getting rid of them really!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".