Originally posted by: Aslesha99
It's good nah she isn't limited to flashbacks and actually coming back because it will finally be a closure to Antara's chapter. AJ and Guddan will finally come to realise their love for each other and then confession and consummation. Antara coming back will make AJ realise that Guddan is the perfect life partner for him over Antara and also an end to his talks about loving Antara and what not.
I don't think its necessary for Antra to come back for her chapter to get closure. By her closure i mean her death mystery & AJ comming out of his guilt over not saving her.
For AJ to realize Guddan is a perfect life partner, Antra doesn't need to be any less perfect. For Guddan to raise in his scale of perfectness, Antra doesn't need to go down in the scale.
Guddan's position & importance in his life shouldn't depend on how less perfect Antra was as his wife. His love, realization & acceptance of Guddan should be free of any influence of how perfect or less perfect Antra was. Antra shouldn't be a deciding factor of Guddan's position in AJ's life.
Both Antra & Guddan hold their own separate positions in AJ's life, in his heart. Till now he has never compared both of them nor did he ever tried to imply any such thing as, he loves Antra for this particular reason where Guddan is falling short. His loves for both of them is different & of different intensity. The only problem here is he feels he can't love Guddan cause he loves Antra. And he needs to realize & accept that he can love both of them like he does & this is not cheating on Antra.
About his talk on loving Antra & what not, he doesn't do that now. He last did that during the Rawat track back in february & that too twice only & not directly. 1st he got angry during boxing fight when Rawat questioned him of forgetting Antra & accused him of killing her. 2nd when he asked Rawat calmly if he truly feels he can kill Antra ?
Right now he just misses Antra just like any decreased loved ones. That doesn't need to stop. His love for her is more of respect than any romantic inclination & that doesn't take away or reduces anything from the love & feelings he has for Guddan.