Who was the Best Husband Ji for Savi? - Page 7

Viewer Polls

Poll

Best Husband Ji for Savi?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

4.7k

Users

18

Likes

214

Frequent Posters

TUKI.MICKY thumbnail

Team Dr. Neel Pradhan

Posted: 4 months ago
#61

I voted for Baji Rao but I've no idea who's that 😁

Sukorameni thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#62

Originally posted by: ThaneOfElsinore

Good professors don't really humiliate students which he did, I guess. Also, no professor teaches a separate subject for the IAS specifically. Even if you would like to guide someone for the Civil Services Exam, you don't give them cartons of books really. So I said that he was quite stupid because no professor does all that. No professor brings a fellow professor who was actually their ex-fianceé to their home. And most importantly, professors don't marry their students in college. 🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

But I understand your liking for the character. I just said that in an objective way. No hard feelings 🙂


Well thats unfair .Ishaan did not bring reeva home because of being professors .He bought her home because he was almost married to her .So this argument dosent make sense honestly.Although it was not ishaan who asked reeva to come .She came herself and overstayed because of his family primarily . Although noone in their senses would bring their ex fiance home after marrying someone else but it's itv so anything is possible .The point is him being a professor had nothing to do with this .

Also regarding cartons of books - if you see the show you will realise after a long period of misunderstanding ishaan trully understood savi was a good student and he wanted to do everything he could for her to succeed because he saw the same potential in her that he had once .So no ,this too cannot be generalized as professor giving cartons of books .It's looked absolutely fine in the given context.

Edited by Sukorameni - 4 months ago
925059 thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#63

Originally posted by: TUKI.MICKY

I voted for Baji Rao but I've no idea who's that 😁

Maybe you liked the name because it probably reminded you of the popular movie, Bajirao Mastani. smiley36

Maybemaybenot thumbnail
Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Ace Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail

Team TejNeil

Posted: 4 months ago
#64

Originally posted by: Sukorameni


Well thats unfair .Ishaan did not bring reeva home because of being professors .He bought her home because he was almost married to her .So this argument dosent make sense honestly.Although it was not ishaan who asked reeva to come .She came herself and overstayed because of his family primarily . Although noone in their senses would bring their ex fiance home after marrying someone else but it's itv so anything is possible .The point is him being a professor had nothing to do with this .

Also regarding cartons of books - if you see the show you will realise after a long period of misunderstanding ishaan trully understood savi was a good student and he wanted to do everything he could for her to succeed because he saw the same potential in her that he had once .So no ,this too cannot be generalized as professor giving cartons of books .It's looked absolutely fine in the given context.

I can't say what happened in the show because all of this was told by many people here and the comment was my understanding of that.

Professors do not really marry their students, no matter what the circumstances are. That's usually considered an ethical boundary all across the world. But like you said, ITV can do anything, so yes, I do find the actions of his character stupid because I perceive it was written in that way. Perceptions can differ so you can have your opinions about the character. Like I clarified earlier, I just typed that because I viewed it objectively and found it absurd. Differing opinions can occur, can't they?

Edited by ThaneOfElsinore - 4 months ago
missFiesty_69 thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#65

Originally posted by: ThaneOfElsinore

I can't say what happened in the show because all of this was told by many people here and the comment was my understanding of that.

Professors do not really marry their students, no matter what the circumstances are. That's usually considered an ethical boundary all across the world. But like you said, ITV can do anything, so yes, I do find the actions of his character stupid because I perceive it was written in that way. Perceptions can differ so you can have your opinions about the character. Like I clarified earlier, I just typed that because I viewed it objectively and found it absurd. Differing opinions can occur, can't they?

I’m not too sure about the situation in India, but in other countries, even though it’s a common trope in books and shows, professors can only get into relationships with their students after the students have finished their course or graduated. Otherwise, it crosses ethical and sometimes even legal boundaries, and they could get fired for it. Even then, it’s frowned upon. The regulations are even more stringent for mental health professionals such as psychiatrists, who are generally prohibited from marrying their patients, regardless of whether a formal therapeutic relationship still exists.

As for India, I don’t know if there are specific laws or how often it actually happens, but culturally, it’s generally frowned upon. A professor is seen as a Guru, someone who should be respected deeply. So the idea of getting into a romantic or marital relationship with them isn’t something that’s usually accepted or encouraged.

Edited by missFiesty_69 - 4 months ago
Maybemaybenot thumbnail
Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Ace Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail

Team TejNeil

Posted: 4 months ago
#66

Originally posted by: missFiesty_69

I’m not too sure about the situation in India, but in other countries, even though it’s a common trope in books and shows, professors can only get into relationships with their students after the students have finished their course or graduated. Otherwise, it crosses ethical and sometimes even legal boundaries, and they could get fired for it. Even then, it’s frowned upon. The regulations are even more stringent for mental health professionals such as psychiatrists, who are generally prohibited from marrying their patients, regardless of whether a formal therapeutic relationship still exists.

As for India, I don’t know if there are specific laws or how often it actually happens, but culturally, it’s generally frowned upon. A professor is seen as a Guru, someone who should be respected deeply. So the idea of getting into a romantic or marital relationship with them isn’t something that’s usually accepted or encouraged.

Yep. In most countries, it's against work ethics and in many cases, legal boundaries of a teacher or professor to engage in a relationship with a student while they're their student. Many times it lies in the sick idea of grooming, although one might also say that it's applicable for minors yada yada. But like you said V, unless they have completed their studies and attained a different status as an individual, professors are not the romantic subjects for a student nor vice-versa in real life.

Sukorameni thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#67

Originally posted by: ThaneOfElsinore

I can't say what happened in the show because all of this was told by many people here and the comment was my understanding of that.

Professors do not really marry their students, no matter what the circumstances are. That's usually considered an ethical boundary all across the world. But like you said, ITV can do anything, so yes, I do find the actions of his character stupid because I perceive it was written in that way. Perceptions can differ so you can have your opinions about the character. Like I clarified earlier, I just typed that because I viewed it objectively and found it absurd. Differing opinions can occur, can't they?

Differing opinions are not just fine but it's welcomed.


But in this context when you are generalizing a character and his actions( who has many flaws and there are no two ways about it ) just based on hearing other people's comments and not watching it first hand makes it a biased opinion.

So I simply pointed out the scenarios where the comments you made were too generalized and the actual context behind those scenarios was more nuanced and were not very triggering at that point.


Regarding teacher student relationship yes I might have an issue while they are still in college because school would be too minor .But once the student has graduated and is a consenting adult , i couldn't care less who dates whom and honestly it's nobody's business to judge either.

Edited by Sukorameni - 4 months ago
jasminerahul thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#68

Professors do marry their students after they complete their course.But very rare.


Originally posted by: ThaneOfElsinore

I can't say what happened in the show because all of this was told by many people here and the comment was my understanding of that.

Professors do not really marry their students, no matter what the circumstances are. That's usually considered an ethical boundary all across the world. But like you said, ITV can do anything, so yes, I do find the actions of his character stupid because I perceive it was written in that way. Perceptions can differ so you can have your opinions about the character. Like I clarified earlier, I just typed that because I viewed it objectively and found it absurd. Differing opinions can occur, can't they?

nutmeg7 thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#69

I voted for Neil because usko koi vote nahi karta smiley37

nutmeg7 thumbnail
Posted: 4 months ago
#70

Originally posted by: Nivedha1

If I am not wrong, Omi kaka was a cop too and he got vrs to help Kaku in Santara business. 😂😂

that was Ninad and he was an Army Officer.

Related Topics

Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin thumbnail

Posted by: Lennie · 5 months ago

Just a polite post/thread on her return. Respect. Thanks. Loved Savi and been throught her journey since start so i never thought I would ever...

Expand ▼
Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin thumbnail

Posted by: Partyc · 5 months ago

She lost her parents as a child and as an adult she lost her remaining family and later, husband. Then she saw her new husband's ex wife dying...

Expand ▼
Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin thumbnail

Posted by: Partyc · 5 months ago

It's nice to see FL as a rich competent modern girl for once and also a mom. Ruturaj won't be able to fight her back so easily

Expand ▼
Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin thumbnail

Posted by: Partyc · 5 months ago

When writers decided to copy YHM, I left watching the show and came back to see Savi's happy ending which may end in tragedy now. I never liked...

Expand ▼
Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin thumbnail

Posted by: Tanvi_vault · 4 months ago

I don't hate any except 3.5.I did not even watch 2.5 episodically but by clips we can definitely judge which one is better

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".