Discussion: What if Saxena was ur dad?

Hey guys,

as u know neha has rejected saxena as her father. and why wouldn't she? who wants to have a criminal daddy?

he hated her even before she was born, he made plans to kill her and her mom. he tried to kill her several times after that. and now just because they have a blood relationship he suddenly has feelings for her and wants her to forgive him?

Don't you think neha is doing the right thing? Should she forgive this criminal just because his blood is running through her veins??

What if saxena was your dad? would you forgive all his past and recent mistakes on the basis of one birth certificate??

What would you do in neha's place? How would you react? Do u agree with neha's decision??

So nobody has an opinion on this?

I have an opinion. 😉 [like on everything else 😆]

okay so. I think Neha is doing the right thing, Saxena has never loved her, he killed his mom and planned to kill her too. She doesn't know that he's changed if he has. He's losing his property and he finds out that the girl who's taking it away from him is his daughter. Obviously now he's going to try and use her. I think she realizes this too. He hasn't only ruined her life, he's helped ruin Kakul's life whom Neha is very close to. He's just a horrible person and deserves to pay for what he did.

If I was Neha -- I would definitely get him punished, he's not going to get away with anything JUST because he's my father. But that doesn't mean I'm going to use him to get him in jail. I just started watching the other day where she tells him that she'll meet him tomorrow and calls someone else that he's meeting her. I think that's wrong. He seemed to want to talk to her and genuinly looked sorry. That does not mean that I'm saying that he's a good person now, no. He might be pretending, but isn't she going to be stooping down to his level to give justice.. that's where I think she's wrong. I would never pretend to be all daughter-like to a man like that. Yes, give justice to all the people's hurt including yourself, but don't use him like that.

That's what I think. Hope I made some sense. 😃 😉

as an outsider i say neha is right.. everyone deserves a second chance but he got one too many.. i mean he couldve stopped at a lot of stuff!! for his daughter v-watsherface! i don't see neha punishing her father.. i see her punishing a criminal.. i mean think of it.. some guy RANDOMLY one day says im ur daddy.. well so called daddy.. where were u all my 20 years of life..(estimate) blood is just a think god gave as a power to help u live.. i mean if i have posA blood(hypothetically) then there are mills of others who have posA too.. not only daddy/mommy! thats my opinion

Very good point, blood doesn't mean anything. 😉

Despite everything Saxena has done in the past, I feel as if he is now repenting for his mistakes. In the past he wanted Mohini and the baby killed, so when he found out that Neha was his daughter he could've still killed her, but he didn't, he saved her. Once his jail time is over, and he has paid the price for the crimes he has committed, and once he begins to show a solid effort for becoming a better person, Neha should forgive Saxena.

Forgiving him just because he seems sorry. I guess he's paying in a way, but still.

I personally feel that life is too short not to forgive. I don't think that neha should become buddy buddy with him, but should simply put everything behind her and move on with life.

Thanks kuldeep, brainychild92 and sanuckfun fro your detailed comments and structured arguments 👏 😊

Originally posted by: canuckfan

I personally feel that life is too short not to forgive. I don't think that neha should become buddy buddy with him, but should simply put everything behind her and move on with life.

I agree with you. They dont have to be very close or anything but at least they can get on talking terms. I mean will she now destroy her own father? Okay he killed someone, but can she not forgive him and then move on?

Maybe its easy for us to say as we are not in her position. But i do think now that she is overdoing it