Created

Last reply

Replies

855

Views

51.3k

Users

76

Likes

1.8k

Frequent Posters

640638 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
If we wanted to read based on other characters we would read the thousands of regency romances out there. I want to read it as Maan-Geet. Priti please continue soon.
-Crayon- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: aanappin


Haha..!!! Another newbie...
Looks like this thread has become a place for u all to come and give ur crap...
u know what...report her...
We are there,for her and we will trust her and support her...

We are stupid enough to let a newbie come and ruin it all,...

Now go and do read ur authors update now that u have managed to ruin our story.!!!

Isn't plagiarism a crime? 😕
It's like stealing someone else's property which is highly unacceptable. I don't think we should support such acts . Usually strict action is taken against such acts.
One more thing... newbies are not always trouble makers .Even I was a a newbie when I first joined this site! If was sure about her works then why did she remove all of them and ban herself ?😕
..AnushaGeet.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: nennedoll

@ aanappin

If your writer is such an original, why don't you go to http://www.wattpad.com/story/995344-a-penny%27s-worth-of-affection

The original writer has posted concerns and discovered that the writer you're trying to defend has copied her work, just changed the names and set it in India.

If you really want to support this writer of yours, then encourage her to use her original talent. It's not hard to write a story.

Rosesarered, original author, worked hard on A Penny's Worth of Affection. It is an injustice for someone to take her hard work for their own.

I wouldn't be surprised if her work has been taken down. I'm sure the true author and/or her fans have also contacted administration.

Next time, when you defend someone, put some real meat into it. Original ID, darling, I haven't been a member of this site, until today. After we have learned from the original author that someone is using her story as her own. If your sweet writer is not guilty of plagiarism, why would she take it down? I mean if I wrote something and someone tried to steal it from me and made it look like that I was the plagiarist, I would keep my story up and when questioned, be prepared to show the evidence of originality.

Point is...and reality is that if someone does something wrong, be prepared to take the consequences.

Anyone else who has probably bashed your "honest" author must be other fans of the original.

Don't be a hypocrite. Nor should you be a blind follower.

I do not ask for your trust. I don't know who you are, nor do you know me. Bottom line is, in the world of creative writing, plagiarism is unacceptable.

Try writing a story? Sweetheart, been there. Done that and still doing so. That is why circumstances like these is unacceptable.

Yes, I am not a saint. Neither are you or your "writer". I'm an advocate though for original writers who have been victimised by plagiarists.

Yes, accusations like this, a writer must pay a big price. If you are in the industry and know the concept of Intellectual Property Rights, you'll understand.

Jobless idiots...Funny. I'll remember that when someone from your country is in my caseload to assist them in looking for a job so they get off unemployment welfare. *wink*

And finally, don't be so dramatic! It's not down the drain for your beloved "writer." If she or he is creative enough to change settings and character names, then she will have the talent to write a story. She could have fantastic writing skills. She could even have several originals in her computer or journal somewhere and just taking a long time to complete or develop. Taking another's work as her own is not the way to go. And you, as a supporter, should know that.

No, this is not harassment. This is fighting for someone who truly worked hard. Put yourself in "Rosesared's" shoes. Read her work and then tell us if there is no resemblance in the narrative.

This is not an attack on you. If this writer is innocent, she can defend herself and provide evidence that she is the original author.


I don't know what exactly made her take it down...but the fact is I trust her...and I am sure the people who know her trust her...
I know her more than I know any random person coming here and talking all this...Moreover you mention a different country.. .which doesn't make sense to me p...sorry no offence
The writers here are not professionals as u call it to be...they just write it out id sheer craziness and love for 2fictional characters...but they are not insensitive enough to copy someone's work...
Well leave it...u felt ur author had been cheated...so be it...
The writer is not continuing her story...So ur work is done here.
Not that I am telling U what to do..but try not coming ack..as it won't help...and this thread will be closed soon..so no point. In we ranting over here...
It will anyhow get u banned...but will get me in trouble as well...which I don't wish to invite...specially for such a reason...

I am not blind...but I trust her...cause we know her better then you do..and we are confident enough that she is honest...

..AnushaGeet.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: World-of-Dreams

Isn't plagiarism a crime? 😕
It's like stealing someone else's property which is highly unacceptable. I don't think we should support such acts . Usually strict action is taken against such acts.
One more thing... newbies are not always trouble makers .Even I was a a newbie when I first joined this site! If was sure about her works then why did she remove all of them and ban herself ?😕


Plagiarism is a crime...that no one can change..I agree to that...
But frankly..what proof can a writer give when the stories are written just out if craziness and love..??? Well I don't know why she took it down...but I am sure she has proof which will be good enough to clear this mess..
I guess she is just too upset to come out and answer.. But I am sure she will...

That's all I have to say...
nennedoll thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: World-of-Dreams

Isn't plagiarism a crime? 😕
It's like stealing someone else's property which is highly unacceptable. I don't think we should support such acts . Usually strict action is taken against such acts.
One more thing... newbies are not always trouble makers .Even I was a a newbie when I first joined this site! If was sure about her works then why did she remove all of them and ban herself ?😕


Yes, it is a crime. It is unfortunate to read that there are supporters who encourage it. Fair enough that there are some who would like to see the story adapted into their own culture and seeing the image of another as the characters. Therefore, the right thing that Priti should have done was to get permission from the original author if she could make an adaptation and credited Rosemary Ani for it...In the meantime, they want her to continue--it is unfortunate that she is dependent on the original author's idea on this particular one and she's temporarily banned.
nennedoll thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
@ aanappin

I don't know what exactly made her take it down...but the fact is I trust her...and I am sure the people who know her trust her...
I know her more than I know any random person coming here and talking all this...Moreover you mention a different country.. .which doesn't make sense to me p...sorry no offence
The writers here are not professionals as u call it to be...they just write it out id sheer craziness and love for 2fictional characters...but they are not insensitive enough to copy someone's work...
Well leave it...u felt ur author had been cheated...so be it...
The writer is not continuing her story...So ur work is done here.
Not that I am telling U what to do..but try not coming ack..as it won't help...and this thread will be closed soon..so no point. In we ranting over here...
It will anyhow get u banned...but will get me in trouble as well...which I don't wish to invite...specially for such a reason...

I am not blind...but I trust her...cause we know her better then you do..and we are confident enough that she is honest...


Good on you that you trust her. Let us hope that she realizes the value of your trust on her. All creative writers--professional and unprofessional write out of fantasy to create fictional characters and scenarios. Wattpad is a site for amature writers as well. However, whether a writer is an amature or professional, there is a code of conduct/ethics to follow. You would be surprised how many writers out there plagiarize other people's work...In this scenario, your author has contradicted your statement "not insensitive to copy someone's work." That's why, I challenge you to view the link and tell us here that there is NO resemblance with "A Penny's Worth of Affection" and what Priti has presented you with.

No one is trying to ban you. A fan is entitled to their opinion. Just because you refuse/deny to see our point of view, regardless of the evidence presented, shouldn't be a basis why someone should report you. I admire your gusto in defending someone out of trust. Just brace yourself, in case she is indeed guilty. For your sake, hope that she is honest. If not, let us hope that she at least has the decency to apologize to the original writer and to you. I don't think there is a need for her to apologize to Rosemary Ani's fans as Priti's accountability is with her reader's and her sources.

If there are points that don't make sense to you or if everything else doesn't make sense; read, read and read some more. Otherwise, I'll try to explain it to you.

Anyway, have you written anything?
Edited by nennedoll - 12 years ago
..AnushaGeet.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
@nennedoll : Yup..I hope so too that this mess gets cleared...
I see your point..and even I am waiting for Priti Di to come and have say on all this... but it would take time as she is banned...Yet we are trying to contact her...
Wouldn't be fair that we are arguing over this issue when things are not clear... well atleast not from Priti Di's side...
She deserves a chance to speak...rather than justified and accused by you and me 😊

Nope..I am not into writing yet...
nennedoll thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: aanappin

@nennedoll : Yup..I hope so too that this mess gets cleared...
I see your point..and even I am waiting for Priti Di to come and have say on all this... but it would take time as she is banned...Yet we are trying to contact her...
Wouldn't be fair that we are arguing over this issue when things are not clear... well atleast not from Priti Di's side...
She deserves a chance to speak...rather than justified and accused by you and me 😊

Nope..I am not into writing yet...


Of course she deserves that chance to speak, most especially if she hasn't done anything wrong. Otherwise, our side will conclude that she has indeed done the wrong thing.

Yet? I suggest that you start getting into writing. It's fun.
tenishia thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: aanappin

<div align="center">@nennedoll : Yup..I hope so too that this mess gets cleared...
I see your point..and even I am waiting for Priti Di to come and have say on all this... but it would take time as she is banned...Yet we are trying to contact her...
Wouldn't be fair that we are arguing over this issue when things are not clear... well atleast not from Priti Di's side...
She deserves a chance to speak...rather than justified and accused by you and me 😊

Nope..I am not into writing yet...
</div>




I agree with both of u guys but a word to the wise IF she was plagiarizing she will not admit to it. Also she will not continue the story on this site under the same name or story name or reply to any of these messages in here. I've seen many stories plagiarized from many writing sites and the same thing always happens. The person plagiarizing stops story, takes the story down and cancels there account. Sad but true. Im basing this off of what ive seen them do on wattpad, fictionpress and fanfiction. Hence why I say she la guilty becuz of past examples. I doubt she will contact any I u guys but best
of luck

🥱
..AnushaGeet.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: tenishia




I agree with both of u guys but a word to the wise IF she was plagiarizing she will not admit to it. Also she will not continue the story on this site under the same name or story name or reply to any of these messages in here. I've seen many stories plagiarized from many writing sites and the same thing always happens. The person plagiarizing stops story, takes the story down and cancels there account. Sad but true. Im basing this off of what ive seen them do on wattpad, fictionpress and fanfiction. Hence why I say she la guilty becuz of past examples. I doubt she will contact any I u guys but best
of luck

🥱



Excuse Me..? ...I would ask you not to be judgmental about her...
She has been here more than any of you know..She has friends for her support if she is not at fault and nothing will stop us from supporting her... And we know her better than you do...
So I am sure she will speak up...
I would say rather than being judgmental about her without knowing her beyond ur accusations... Give her the time to come up and speak... As far as I can see...she is banned... so nothing allows her to come and speak here...
Well everyone is not the same you know...So give the matter some rest for the time being..

Edited by aanappin - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".