Originally posted by: --Nargis--
I don't care for his state...any state DOES NOT excuse his behavior and his BRUTAL words. Ok i GET that he doesn't TRUST her...but he also has no cause to MISTRUST her either!!!
ML or no ML...when maan had not lost his memory...and he said something like this originally...HALL mach gaya tha...and rightfully so!!
Those WORDS were WRONG then and they are WRONG now!!!
She should just BURST his bubble and show him that Maan transferred 51% of KC shares to Geet's name...BUT than he will accuse her of SWINDLING that too!!!
why doesn't he have the right to mistrust her?? When maan loved her unconditionally even with her past, she didn't trust him enough that she bursted and hurt him in front of the board and the media...that is ok...cause she had "things" a part of her past a reason enough to make her innocent..
Miscarriage happens...even then her state of mind was the reason as to why she behaved the way she did...it was okay for her to roam around with the man that ruined her life...it was okay for her to play holi with him...ok enough to forgive him...for the biggest sin he commited...but when her husband who has gotten a real head injury...whose brain really is screwed up right now...is wronged? The man who dealt with soo much shit for this same woman...she cannot hear his some insults...if he was in the right state of mind and didn't have amnesia do u think he would be saying this?? Beeji insulted maan left and right in amritsar even despite geet forgiving him...had she spoken up then even when she knew her aunt was wrong!
Funny occurance to me everyone...whenever there was a heated argument between Maaneet...never is it geet's fault...kabhi MC...to kabhi trust issues...but here Maan isn't even at fault due to amnesia he is blamed even then? Anyone ever think that perhaps he says these things because perhaps Sameera screwed him over in this way which was why he says these things?
Why is geet allowed to get away with the stupidest things she does...but Maan isn't??
Geet is allowed to blame and insult maan in front of everyone because she heard a half assed conversation...and saw Dev...it is okay for her to not trust the maan that has done nothing but love her...
but Maan is not allowed to trust a stranger "geet" whom he doesn't know?
Maan came back from the hospital with a clean slated mind...about Geet...but even then she was forced on him...from everyone! Soo many things must be going through Maan's mind right now...as to why he is forgetting things...who is geet that everyone is loving soo damn much...why is she running around in front of me every where...why am i forgetting things...why do i think it is 2010 when it is actually 2011? Who are all of these people living in my house...
why does this girl keep coming close to me...soo many questions...not once has he been able to rest and clear his thoughts...after spending the whole night in the same room with Geet on the same bed...the next day when they want to leave geet starts to do natak about a headache..which he is very clearly aware that she is faking it...then he goes for a meeting and sees that he is married to her...how do u expect someone like him to react?? Obviously he will think wrong things...why wouldn't he??? Does that mean that Geet should stand there and listen?? No she can yell back and tell him now that she is his wife...but NO i don't blame maan for how he reacted...and neither do i blame geet either...i feel both are innocent in this situation...but no...everyone here just always finds Maan as culprit. As if all he has done is yell at geet all his life...never had anything good to offer...maan was with geet through thick and thin...shouldn't geet be with him then?? When Geet lost the baby Maan did everything in his power to bring his geet back...he didn't leave her!! But circumstances had other things and they separated...and just like that is the case here...
Nope i am not saying that geet should stand there and listen to his harsh words...they were mean and she should speak up...BUT Maan is not wrong...his reaction is completely justified in my POV...as he is a patient of Amnesia...and the situations that have occured in front of him...it is completely in his character to do this.
Edited by mysterygurl1427 - 14 years ago
Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin
