Originally posted by: jshaila
allowed to bash me i am used to it now but if u think deep u will surely get what i mean .even u can say me to leave its okay i wanted to say what i feel and if anyone can speak to the cv's to convey this-
we assumed something we are getting something
first of all amnesia track in all the serial are horrible but i thought in geet it will be different
sorry to compare genda phool amnesia track was far better atleast main lead were given importance-
give me one reason is geet interesting than before -answer will be no.
I have to disagree with you here. I think the month of July has been riveting! Nothing was too long-drawn out and I do think it is more interesting/exciting than the Amritsar track, which preceded it. Amritsar lacked a strong storyline and direction which I feel is there now. I am getting the feeling for the first time after marriage that CVs know the story more than a few episodes ahead.
The amnesia track has just dug its foundation. I like that they are not just repeating what happened before. the reactions of the characters are natural and accordingly different with the situation. Both Geet and Maan changed over the course of their relationship and they are showing so well the new and different interaction of old Maan with changed, confident, self-assured Geet who is no longer the victim in need of rescuing.
What did you assume prior to the track that you feel you are not getting?
points--
1.is dev-nano that important were there space is more.
Ok this I have to agree with you. But I think they seem like a waste of screen-time because of their patchy storyline rather than the fact that they are not important. They could really be a story we enjoy and if CVs invested more in associating them with characters other than each other. They seem at the moment in their own little happy bubble, oblivious to all the problems that face the other characters. But I see potential there too with Dev worrying about Nandini finding out things about him and his mysterious handshake with one diamond-ringed, female hand đ˛
2.was mamaji required there
NO. Adi-Pinky-Lucky were providing enough funny moments and I really don't see how Mamaji fits into the new, serious tone of the track. But he does make Lucky seem more tolerable for some reason(?). His entry kind of ruined any hopes I had of him being non-intrusive as he came just as Maan had some chance to be impressed by Geet's dedication. To me it felt like Mamaji literally cut that moment short.
3.dadi-tandon ---frienship required .
I like this! I think it's funny and cute. It is helping the Maaneet storyline along, rather than taking away from it and shows one of the most unique things about the show, our hot hot Dadi!đ
4.maaneet-are u happy to see them 5-6 minutes in which maan yells geet keeps mum.
chemistry nowere to be seen.
I think out and out chemistry at this stage would be a little unnatural. But they are bringing subtle hints. the fact that Maan keeps yelling and trying to distance himself from Geet shows that he is uncomfortable with her for some reason, if not for the return of his memory then the introduction of Geet as a self-assured woman with plenty of family-support.
5.lucky -what is he doing eating pizza and pastry and chatting with pinky.
Making Adi jealous, of course! And don't tell me you don't like jealous Adi! But I agree he is getting on my nerves a little. They should show him talking to Preeto sometimes to assert his long-term goals and the seriousness of his character.
6.pinky -returned just for eating chips and gulab jamun.
Aw, come on, Pinky is back so we can have a romantic side track that we don't hate and she is so sweet with Geet, especially when the Adi-Geet-Pinky trio were working on the party/presentation.
7.maan ---is it amnesa no amnesia only yelling program confusing us its not suspence but irritation.
I am certainly feeling the suspense! But, yes, a bit irritated at how little they seem to focus on Maan's thoughts/feelings apart from his outward behaviour.
8.geet---no diagloues for her why ?only eye contact that's it
She is still in the phase where she doesn't want to disturb him in any way. I am sure she will speak up soon, not being able to control herself any longer. Also, I can't wait to see her prove her worth to him. I would love for him to be impressed by work and fall for her that way, just like before the Kurban Hua party!
9.sets---horrible small sets
I know, I do miss the old KM but there is nothing much to be done about that and as long as they make the leads look good I don't mind the background so much đ
10.maaneet clothes ----sidetrack ppl are given better dreeses
This is one of my biggest grievances too. But Geet is supposed to get a new wardrobe sometime next week. What I don't understand is why they abandoned her lovely bankruptcy clothes? I really liked those outfits, with the pretty waistbands.
11.dadiji-what'she doing cameo 2-3 scenes
Even if she is not appearing much she is doing a lot for the progress of the plot so I have had no problems with that aspect. I am still running on the high of her being back and not being killed off or recast!
12.maaneet scenes no proper flow they end abruptily why cv's amritsar maaneet scenes were far better-
Yes, but Amritsar had no real story so they needed great Maaneet scenes to keep the story afloat. Now they have a good plot and even though there are fewer scenes they fit into the story perfectly. But the scene of injured Geet taking notes was cut short brutally and I hated it!đĄ
-----sorry from the start of geet no festival is celebrated no holi,no dewali,no dasara now no tej celebration.
-only celebration was chrismas why?
is festival not allowed in geet?
How could you forget they did have Holi?? Anyway, probably better to forget those sad times
If they did more festivals people would complain it was like a saas-bahu drama so there is no winning for CVs.
leave that ME party was it a party 10 minutes slideshow and recycle of clothes.
But the scene was so short and so sad that I think it would have been a waste to give her a new saree. Maan would not have even noticed and we would just feel bad about it.
-----ph if ur least bothered about geet which gave u immence sucess better end in a very good note or come up with season2 like totally new story with gurti like college story ---why u breaking each and everyone's heart few fans have left few are patiently waiting for the day when geet comes back and few even glimpses of maaneet is making them happy .
---this is how u treat ur loyal viewers ?
I am so sorry you feel so badly about the new track and though yesterday's episode was a bit of a let down with the Amritsar flashback (instead of the Geet flashback we were expecting) I still have hope for the over all plot. You definitely don't deserve to be bashed for expressing your very valid opinion, even if it is negative. So I have just tried to share some of my views regarding the same issues. Hope you liked the discussion!
Shiv Shakti
30