Deep Thoughts Coming from Geet, DISCUSS!

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I know everybody is discussing the memory-loss track and anticipating the separation, but there is something else that I wanted discuss with you all about Thurs. and Fri. episodes. Thursday's episode was beautiful and will definitely go down as one of my favorite episodes of the show. I loved Geet's maturity and understanding and I have to say I learned a lesson or two!

If you have read my previous posts, you know that I was passionately for Geet working alongside Maan and his male ego being taken down etc. But when Maan tells her he is uncomfortable with her working, she reassures him that it's not forever and that she will live in luxury once he is back on his feet. At first the feminist in me was outraged but then I thought, what a good wife she was being. He was sad and tired and hurt and she put his comfort first and didn't argue but rather found a way to frame the situation so that he didn't mind her having to work so much and he felt peaceful and happy, for that moment, at least. And in the end she accomplished what I would have wanted from the situation anyway, that is for Maan to understand the depths of her strength and to learn that he can show weakness in front of her and she won't think less of him. So my first topic of discussion is, how would you handle this situation? I mean I thought I knew but the maturity of Geet's words changed my mind that day!

Secondly, in Friday's episode. Even though there weren't any traditional Mahii scenes, the Maan/Geet scenes that were shown were really effective for me.They showed that Geet knows Maan so well, she can see see him sinking into his angry, irrational mode (which hasn't made an appearance since Holi) because of his frustration at not being able to find a job and listening to what people are saying, but is mostly helpless because anything she says or does can trigger his craziness. I can't even imagine how to handle that!

My mother was watching with me that day and when that milkman finished his bakhwas and Maan was getting angry, she said, "great, now go and take it out on your wife" and then he did, when he refused to take the breakfast. So it just made me realise that they must be portraying marriage in such a real way that someone who has actually been married for 25-odd years can relate to it! Geet
can't stop working because they need the income and even though it is clear he is proud of her for it, it is still causing him discomfort because the roles are reversed and now she is somebody and he isn't. So I wanted to open this discussion to people like me, who are not married but have certain ideas about it and of course, people who are married: how do you/would you handle the extremely sensitive situation that Geet is in???

PS: If there are any boys/men on this forum, you are most welcome to discuss too 😉 I would love to hear a male perspective.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.2k

Users

7

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

Craziest_MG thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
This happen in actual dear...men and their ego always create problem in their personal lives...thats why they always say that a girl should marry a boy who earns more than what she earns...

Though i feel maan would never be sad coz of his ego...i think he feels that coz he cannot do anything, geet has to do a lot of hard work...i have faith in my maan...n what should i say abt geet...she is such an understanding wife.

Nice post ...written beautifully.
Binge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Great thread, once again!! 👏

Ok, coming to your first question, I took notice of what Geet said about her taking up the job as a teacher and that she would live like a queen once Maan re-establishes his business. But then I thought maybe Geet doesn't want to work and has no ambitions regarding that. I accepted it as that and just bcuz I don't believe about staying in home once you're married, I do respect the kind of endurance housewives have to go through. Hence, I'm ok with her decision.

Regarding how I would simplify the situation, I'd tell the milkman that my hubby has encouraged me to work for the welfare of the kids and I enjoy doing that. It wouldn't have been possible without his support and approval.

Somewhere I felt Geet should have said something when the milkman belittled Maan..when she knows that he is a man with humongous ego. I mean look at the same instance with a role reversal... someone says something to Geet.. I'm sure Maan would have snapped back at the outsider. 😊
Edited by shreya- - 14 years ago
pippa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Very interesting topic!

I love what they are showing now-a-days!

Who said men aren't emotional and do not have knee-jerk reactions?

They do...they are like kids and we women have to treat them with kid gloves...pun intended (a poor one, I know!😆)


Maan's ego is hurt poor guy, but, in his case, I think it goes deeper than that...the thought of Geet working..is hurting him...less as an MCP issue and more as a deeply loving husband who worships the ground she walks on. That was shown on Thursday and Geet's quick balm eased the situation, clever girl!

However, the Friday epi seems to be a harbinger of an Abhimaan-like situation (no pun intended, this time, though it's a good one !).

To be known as your wife's husband instead of the other way around can do things to a man's psyche...unless you are Maan...ordinarily, I wouldn't suspect Maan of anything so cliched but, going by the reports of relationships souring and the earlier promo...some issues are bound to come up.

Having said that, not all husbands are so ego-centric that they wouldn't let their wives work under such circumstances. I know my husband would support it fully. And, really, no one like that silly dhoodhwaalh normally comes and says things like that to your face...that made poor Maan feel worse.

I doubt if Maan's going remain upset for long...he will come around and since the ML track is coming along close on its heels, there is surely no way he can remain pissed off.

If you ask me, he's going to support Geet to the hilt.

Edited by pippa - 14 years ago
AayaTohModiJi thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
awesome thread.
ok come to the discussion
beautifully point out
now come to the first point
geet doesn't want to job after maan re-establish KC
and she assured him it's for temporary
ok I have two mind regarding this
one is geet's doesn't have ambitions , she want to stay home and make maan's house home and handle his or their house
and after coming from HP geet take the job cause it's her need that time to for her survival but not now as she has maan ( not for all , may be for geet, completely my assumption)
second after marriage still we don't see she work like before the marriage
after they return from Amritsar they faced this problem so un till we can see after maan re-establish the empire what she will do

second
I personally preferred geet should handle the situation after doodhwala say those things to maan like she tried in front of sarpanch and other villagers
he feels humilitated cause he (maan )thinks he can't provide his geet basic needs that 's y he went from there. he can't bear it, he never losse in his life now he is loosing from the first time so it'll take time to understand it
one after another blow is coming on maan.
now what is maan want , is he typical male or now it's temporary cause his ego bruised, his near and dears one break his trust, he lost everything
again personally I think don't know may be or may not be but this time maan needs lots of reassurance from geet and moral boost from geet.
cause only geet can know him more than maan know himself only get can manage him control his anger, temper.
only geet can show him right way.
maan's self confidence is shaking now so geet have to increase his confidence and make him understand but politely
this is very delicate situation now for both maaneet.
till now I loved how geet, maturely handle the situation and handle maan.
she indeed know maan well and know to control his temper.
well now many of want to know y geet has to do this things ,y maan will not himself understand
cause this delicate situation maan's condition is not good, he is loosing from every side,
his mother(step mom) break his trust, snatched everything, some villagers, doodh wala bruising his ego, intentionally or unintentionally hurting him
he is not getting any job, he is not getting any contract

this time he needs assurance and that only geet can give him

but maan is happy about his misthy but he feel helpless that he can't help, provide basic necessary to his geet
it's like failure to him but now geet has to make him understand .
give him support, confidence,moral boost.

I have lots of hope from cvs that they will handle this track delicately not hurriedly
but I also want geet work and maan support her , maan understand her and geet also make him understand but before that there will be some tiff or some problem cause both of them have to understand each other more.
now this time they have full chance to explore their relationship more
there is only two maaneet two different individuals but one entity

will add more point little later


Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: shreya-

Great thread, once again!! 👏


Ok, coming to your first question, I took notice of what Geet said about her taking up the job as a teacher and that she would live like a queen once Maan re-establishes his business. But then I thought maybe Geet doesn't want to work and has no ambitions regarding that. I accepted it as that and just bcuz I don't believe about staying in home once you're married, I do respect the kind of endurance housewives have to go through. Hence, I'm ok with her decision.

Regarding how I would simplify the situation, I'd tell the milkman that my hubby has encouraged me to work for the welfare of the kids and I enjoy doing that. It wouldn't have been possible without his support and approval.

Somewhere I felt Geet should have said something when the milkman belittled Maan..when she knows that he is a man with humongous ego. I mean look at the same instance with a role reversal... someone says something to Geet.. I'm sure Maan would have snapped back at the outsider. 😊



You are right! Geet acknowledging Maan's support like that would have really improved the whole situation. But after your post I re-watched the scene and realised that she was kind of tongue-tied like she wanted to say something but couldn't, rather than wouldn't. I guess this is a difference in their basic makeup. Maan's first impulse is to say and act on what he feels because he is used to the things he says being listened to. Geet, on the other hand, has a "be seen and not heard" mentality grilled into her, which she is only now breaking out of and so I think she is a bit petrified in the face of confrontation. It has been one of her character flaws from the beginning. But it is these flaws and differences that make their love story so intense to watch and create necessary tension to keep the plot going!
x-affy-x thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: shreya-

Great thread, once again!! 👏


Ok, coming to your first question, I took notice of what Geet said about her taking up the job as a teacher and that she would live like a queen once Maan re-establishes his business. But then I thought maybe Geet doesn't want to work and has no ambitions regarding that. I accepted it as that and just bcuz I don't believe about staying in home once you're married, I do respect the kind of endurance housewives have to go through. Hence, I'm ok with her decision.

Regarding how I would simplify the situation, I'd tell the milkman that my hubby has encouraged me to work for the welfare of the kids and I enjoy doing that. It wouldn't have been possible without his support and approval.

Somewhere I felt Geet should have said something when the milkman belittled Maan..when she knows that he is a man with humongous ego. I mean look at the same instance with a role reversal... someone says something to Geet.. I'm sure Maan would have snapped back at the outsider. 😊

This scene spoke to me i dont know
this stuff actually happens and the response Geet gave is usually the most common
Loving this track
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: pippa

Very interesting topic!

I love what they are showing now-a-days!

Who said men aren't emotional and do not have knee-jerk reactions?

They do...they are like kids and we women have to treat them with kid gloves...pun intended (a poor one, I know!😆)


Maan's ego is hurt poor guy, but, in his case, I think it goes deeper than that...the thought of Geet working..is hurting him...less as an MCP issue and more as a deeply loving husband who worships the ground she walks on. That was shown on Thursday and Geet's quick balm eased the situation, clever girl!

However, the Friday epi seems to be a harbinger of an Abhimaan-like situation (no pun intended, this time, though it's a good one !).

To be known as your wife's husband instead of the other way around can do things to a man's psyche...unless you are Maan...ordinarily, I wouldn't suspect Maan of anything so cliched but, going by the reports of relationships souring and the earlier promo...some issues are bound to come up.

Having said that, not all husbands are so ego-centric that they wouldn't let their wives work under such circumstances. I know my husband would support it fully. And, really, no one like that silly dhoodhwaalh normally comes and says things like that to your face...that made poor Maan feel worse.

I doubt if Maan's going remain upset for long...he will come around and since the ML track is coming along close on its heels, there is surely no way he can remain pissed off.

If you ask me, he's going to support Geet to the hilt.



I love what they are showing too! And I love your Abhimaan reference (and the unintended pun therein)! That is exactly what this situation is shaping up to be. And even though I am all about Geet being a liberated woman, I do feel sorry for Maan. His ideal world is coming crashing down around him. I am beginning to understand also that he is not an MCP, even unintentionally, just a doting husband. I was afraid Geet would become a trophy-wife but the way they are re-establishing the strength of her character, it seems unlikely, even if she is not working, and that is really all I wanted to be reassured of. I think it is possible that Maan and Geet will be upset/feel distance from each other just before the separation, which will make Geet all the more frantic to find him, which will tear at our heartstrings all the more and make their reunion all the more magnificent, because it will be reunion after a fight+accident+separation!

Also, it is good to know that I have higher chances of finding a supportive husband than a snarky dhoodhwalah 😆

roseinbloom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
First off, Great Post!
Really thought provoking :) I am not married, still in university. Still haven't gotten a job but shall get one this year as getting a job and earning is a pretty basic necessity in our lifestyle. So I have gotten to learn the importance of having to work and getting up on your own two feet.
Coming to Geet's situation, we have seen her having to grow up way too fast at the age of 18. I am 18 and would not be so confident as her to do some of the things she's done. Especially leaving my family to go to another city and get a job in such a firm like KC. So Geet already has that kind of work experience prior to their marriage. Maan is and will be known for his ego. Well I say it's ok if he has one because at this stage of his life when he has not had to depend on anyone for anything and has built this Empire with just his Daadima, he must be pretty self-dependent. He has all this ego built up over the years -- so getting blow after blow at his ego and his reactions to it are very much acceptable in that situation I believe.
Coming to Geet, I loved that she was implementing the factor of education into those kids who couldn't go to school due to high fees. So she takes up the job as Masterni. Of course in a place where they are living where people have sort of the same mindset. We saw many of the men coming and saying things like they live on their wife's salary and are actually ENJOYING IT! I was shocked to see this side of life for the first time actually! I am glad they brought it out in GHSP because I didn't know men had tihs kind of thinking too.
More than Maan being hurt that he is just being thought of as Geet's husband and not The Maan Singh Khurana like he used to, I think he has a problem with Geet making a living for both of them while he is still struggling to get his proposal accepted by a company that hasn't been bribed by Pammi.
That's where his ego is getting bruised I think. Geet is already successful and he's in the struggling stages because everything used to come so easily to him. I'm sure he's seen struggling days before perhaps when KC was still in its early stages but now that he's had all this power and it suddenly goes away .. it can do many things to a man like MSK.
I believe this little tiff they are going to have about work is going to be small and resolved that very day. It won't go on for a long while because 1) the ML track is going to start and 2) Maaneet know how to communicate well now -- they've learned from past mistakes of not talking to each other when problems arise -- and that can easily put rest a lot of their issues.
About Geet saying the dialogue of her resting like a Queen when he gets his work back, I think she did it for many reasons. One was to soothe Maan's hurt about her having to work under these conditions. It sorted boosted his confidence when she said it because it made him feel that she's sure he'll be successful again in no time. And two, well Geet has seen the tough life far too early in the 18 years of her existence and if she wants relief from all that then why not right? She always has that option to go to work and if Maan feels she doesn't have to work and she agrees to the same then everything is ok. Not just because Maan says so but if it's her decision then I'm ok with it.
Boy, I talked a lot :P Thanx for making this post .. it was really intriguing!
Z
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Mk.Gh


...
About Geet saying the dialogue of her resting like a Queen when he gets his work back, I think she did it for many reasons. One was to soothe Maan's hurt about her having to work under these conditions. It sorted boosted his confidence when she said it because it made him feel that she's sure he'll be successful again in no time. And two, well Geet has seen the tough life far too early in the 18 years of her existence and if she wants relief from all that then why not right? She always has that option to go to work and if Maan feels she doesn't have to work and she agrees to the same then everything is ok. Not just because Maan says so but if it's her decision then I'm ok with it.
Boy, I talked a lot :P Thanx for making this post .. it was really intriguing!
Z



No, thank you for responding! I loved all your points, but especially the last one, which I am quoting. I felt, during the episode, that that moment was more about making Maan feel good about himself than about her choice between being a housewife or working. It made me consider that maybe there is a place for campaigning gender equality and place for just giving your man the confidence he needs to wake up in the morning and face another day. That moment was not about her future, I don't think anything was really decided. Whatever she said was for Maan's benefit. And I am sure if she changes her mind later and working would make her happy, Maan would have no objection, since all he wants is for her to be happy!

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Chup Chup ke Part 40 on page 66- 24/6/25

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Binding by Love Pt 29 page 47- 10/1/25

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

4 months ago

Maan Geet SS || The Unyielding Heart||

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

1 years ago

Geet teaching kis*

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127
Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

4 years ago

Geet ff do dil part 7 on page 6

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".