THE ISSSUE IS NOTHING

Page

chaitucute

@chaitucute

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

IF THE TIFF BW MAAN &GEET IS FOR GEETS WORKING THEN BOTH MAAN &GEET ARE RIGHT IN THEIR VIEWS...IF GEET WANT TO WORK IT SHOWS THAT SHE WANT TO HELP HER HUSBAND &Share some of his burden...it shows geet is right

BUT IF MAAN IS STOPPING HER &DOESNT WANT HER TO WORK EVEN HE IS RIGHT...IT SHOWS ESPECUIALLY IN INDIAN DRAMAS...THAT HE IS INCAPABLE OF TAKING CARE OF HIS FAMILY...HIS SELFRESPECT IS HURT...THAT INSPITE OF HIM BEING THIER HIS WIFE HAVE TO EARN...&THERE IS NO WRONG IN THINKING LIKE THAT &NEITHER HIS EGO BEING HURT..THIS ISSUE DOESNT HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH MAAN BEING MODERN OR NOT AS MANY PPL ARE SAYING ON THIS FORUM... FOR .A PERSON AS STRONG AS MAAN IT IS NATURAL TO FEEL BAD IF HIS WIFE WORKS...BUT IT DOESN'T MEAN HE THOUGHTS ARE OLD FASHIONED IT JUST SHOWS HIS CONCERN FOR HIS WIFE...AND THE FEELING THAT HIS WIFE HAVE TO EARN &GET TIRED INSPITE OF HIM BEING THERE...

WHEN IT COMES TO EARNING THERE ARE 2 PPL IN THE HOUSE TO EARN AS DEV IS ALSO THERE &QUALIFIED AS LIKE AS THEM THEY WILL GET VERY GUD JOBS...

Edited by chaitucute - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

chaitucute

@chaitucute

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

hey no views &no replies...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mysterygurl1427

@mysterygurl1427

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

i agree with u...good explanations.

Quote

Sri_Radha

@Sri_Radha

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

I agreed ...Both maan and geet is right in their points

Maan is concern about his wife . . So she doesn't want to work

Geet want to help his husband...So she decided to work

Both are understanding each other so the tiff will be clear soon

Quote

KrishnaSourav

@KrishnaRukmini

Achiever

+ 10

Posted: 14 years ago

Totally agree with u and ur each and every point.

Quote

Samanalyse

@Samanalyse

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

I think I may be one of the "many people" you are referring to who are discussing whether Maan is modern, is me. I started the thread about the Social Issue. And I just wanted to bring up some points. Firstly, the issue is not "nothing", it is very relevant and controversial all over the world, and the fact that we are discussing it is in no way a negative criticism of the show or the characters. It is just an analysis of some of the issues the show might address and actually is positive because us having so much to discuss means we are being made to think by the possible new directions the show is taking. I find it really funny how people just cannot wait to jump to Maan's defense. Pointing out his flaws as a character does not mean I am bashing him. A character is a literary device usually used to further the plot and/or send a message and I like to discuss how the writers are doing this, that's all. What I tried to say was that his protective attitude, not wanting Geet to struggle etc. is, while very romantic, some what demeaning because it implies that Geet should be totally dependent on him, which, yes, is typical of other serials but also why Geet has been different from the beginning. I also did say that it was a SENSITIVE issue because both sides of the argument are valid. As I have said on all my posts, I love to discuss/argue about my opinions even, actually especially :), with people who disagree but please don't just dismiss peoples' opinions/thoughts off hand and call it "nothing". Thanks for reading. Hope to discuss more with any of you.

If you want to read here is the link to my original post:
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1716793