Was Maan wrong? They listened!!!

Page

Next Last

Roshni

@* ~ Roshni ~ *

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

This was the original lol but made a comment on page 8😊 reg this and 2days epi😳

Hey Maaneetians😊 between child vs mother who would you pick if u were in Maan's situation? forget the logic of the drama lol

Ok yes the baby is very important . . . esp in this story as Geet fought her family, society to save it so that she can bring the baby into the world. But for Maan - Geet is his everything. He changed because of her. He would do anything for her. She is his life! I don't think Maan made any mistake in choosing her.

Surely if there was a choice given to Maan then Geet should be able to understand why Maan would have chosen her over the baby and how difficult it would have been for him to choose between them. Its a complicated situation to be in especially if the child isn't biologically yours and your partner could mistake that its because you don't love the child or haven't accepted it because it isn't your own 'blood' but hasn't Maan proven time and time again that he loves the baby? Geet has seen all this so it would be silly on her part to think otherwise.

They could always have another baby but if there's no Geet then Maan loses his life partner. If he chose the baby then he could resent the baby for taking Geet away from him. Your life partner is the person who spends the rest of their life with you and often when you think about it if you have to choose between ur child and partner I always think ur partner stays with u through thick and thin but ur child/children go their separate ways once they've grown up. They make their own lives so for me I prob would choose partner. Although I guess its easy to say it but going through it is different.

IMO Maan made no mistake in choosing Geet. But yes maybe he should tell her or bring about the situation in a hypothetical manner infront of Geet.

I understand where his thinking is coming from and why he thinks she would be upset etc and how he has broken her trust but I don't think he has! Plus Dadimaa was there she knows exactly how everything had a toll on him.

Hmmmmm ok . . . comments?!

Edited by * ~ Roshni ~ * - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

mysterygurl1427

@mysterygurl1427

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

Yes Roshni....i agree with u!!!!!

I don't think that what he did was wrong in any way....and that when the time is right....he will tell Geet....cause he is our maan....and he hates lies.....and he will tell her!!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

jaspreetm2815

@jaspreetm2815

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mysterygurl1427
Yes Roshni....i agree with u!!!!!

I don't think that what he did was wrong in any way....and that when the time is right....he will tell Geet....cause he is our maan....and he hates lies.....and he will tell her!!!

1000000000000000% Agree with you...👏

Quote

Roshni

@* ~ Roshni ~ *

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mysterygurl1427
Yes Roshni....i agree with u!!!!!

I don't think that what he did was wrong in any way....and that when the time is right....he will tell Geet....cause he is our maan....and he hates lies.....and he will tell her!!!

Thanx😊 I think he'll tell her in good time but when they were at the hospital that deffo wasnt the right time! I just hope Geet doesn't misunderstand and realises where he is coming from

Quote

_Invincible_

@_Invincible_

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

i agree roshni.................

maan's decision was quite right and practical.............................

any1 would have gone 4 dat option only coz if geet is not dere den wat would b left coz baby is geet's dream i think u must stay alive to see ur dreams coming true..............

god forbid in any case if dreams dont come true den atleast if u r alive den u can again see dreams and make efforts to make dem come true......................

Edited by pooja83 - 14 years ago

Quote

saanjh rathore

@saanjh11

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

maan was not wrong anyone wud do same ,just don't want any track regarding this mess up whenever geet comes to know she shud understand maan otherwise wht's the use of showing heights of love

Quote

suprise007

@suprise007

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

AHHHH, i think i prefer yesterday's epi LOL, at least i knew it didn't make sense, today's made me angry, cos i'm thinking they made all this crap just so maan can choose Geet and so we can have more crappy episodes in the near future after the wedding, i really hope i'm wrong here, but from Maans words how Geet will never forgive him, i think they have set the satge for that 2day, but i really really hope it doesn't happen

Edited by suprise007 - 14 years ago

Quote

_Invincible_

@_Invincible_

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: sanjh1234
maan was not wrong anyone wud do same ,just don't want any track regarding this mess up whenever geet comes to know she shud understand maan otherwise wht's the use of showing heights of love

@ bold red

very well said....................if u dont understand each other den u cant b in love dat too which is projected as so divine and eternal love................

Quote

Absoluv

@Absoluv

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

👍🏼

Originally posted by: * ~ Roshni ~ *
Hey Maaneetians😊 between child vs mother who would you pick if u were in Maan's situation? forget the logic of the drama lol

Ok yes the baby is very important . . . esp in this story as Geet fought her family, society to save it so that she can bring the baby into the world. But for Maan - Geet is his everything. He changed because of her. He would do anything for her. She is his life! I don't think Maan made any mistake in choosing her.

Surely if there was a choice given to Maan then Geet should be able to understand why Maan would have chosen her over the baby and how difficult it would have been for him to choose between them. Its a complicated situation to be in especially if the child isn't biologically yours and your partner could mistake that its because you don't love the child or haven't accepted it because it isn't your own 'blood' but hasn't Maan proven time and time again that he loves the baby? Geet has seen all this so it would be silly on her part to think otherwise. 👏 👍🏼
They could always have another baby but if there's no Geet then Maan loses his life partner. If he chose the baby then he could resent the baby for taking Geet away from him. Your life partner is the person who spends the rest of their life with you and often when you think about it if you have to choose between ur child and partner I always think ur partner stays with u through thick and thin but ur child/children go their separate ways once they've grown up. They make their own lives so for me I prob would choose partner. Although I guess its easy to say it but going through it is different.

IMO Maan made no mistake in choosing Geet.👍🏼 But yes maybe he should tell her or bring about the situation in a hypothetical manner infront of Geet.

I understand where his thinking is coming from and why he thinks she would be upset etc and how he has broken her trust but I don't think he has! Plus Dadimaa was there she knows exactly how everything had a toll on him.

Hmmmmm ok . . . comments?!

Hey Roshni, I totally agree with u dear...Me tooo think that MAAN was not wrong in choosing Geet over the baby....that doesn't mean that MAAN does not love the baby or does not want it...Agar aisa hota toh, he wud not have accepted Geet in the first place....I totally agree with u on the red part.....

I feel that Geet shud not get angry at Maan for choosing her BUT instead try to understand his situation....Hopefully Dadi will also be able to make Geet understand what Maan went thru while she was critical...

Quote

Roshni

@* ~ Roshni ~ *

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: pooja83
i agree roshni.................

maan's decision was quite right and practical.............................

any1 would have gone 4 dat option only coz if geet is not dere den wat would b left coz baby is geet's dream i think u must stay alive to see ur dreams coming true..............

god forbid in any case if dreams dont come true den atleast if u r alive den u can again see dreams and make efforts to make dem come true......................