3 IDIOTS - LOGIC lost at the cost of DRAMA!! UGH!! - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

483

Views

18.3k

Users

26

Likes

594

Frequent Posters

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: imraana

hey guys!!!!!....relax!!!!!!i think dat we had all forgotten dat daily soaps at times do get illogical!!!!!.....i knw 2day it was a bit tooo much!!!!...but look at da funny side!!!!!....i'm sure dat maybe by tomo those dialogues will be edited!!!!!...like how it was done wid dadi's reacn wen maan fills geet's maang n gets her home next morn.....rem 1 day b4 dadi had said ..."rukiye maan...."

n the next day we hear her saying only "maaan"...n she was also not angry at maan 4 filling geet's maang!!!!!...so this too may change!!!!




So true Imu....they will edit it out of the episode tomorrow...they have done it before!!!
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: LavZ

exctly Nags....coz da miscrg wil lead to MU den da shaadi tho hone se rahi.....n da hype cretd da shaadi is frsure.....dey r workin soo ahrd fr shaadi....so Miracle it will b....da rest of da shw was fine...flow was fine...one dialg chngd da whole scnrio....bt i think kal thak saab teek ho jayega...





Lavzu....tu mujhse ignore ker rahi hai
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: --Nargis--



Lavu...if MISCARRIAGE happens..then SHAADI will not, and with all the hype and the preparations for the Maneet wedding....i think the wedding is a definite!!


SO...its FINAL...no MISCARRIAGE!!!



I dont know but i feel ki even if there is a MC shaadi hogi...I know Geet will be too traumatized......But my thinking is too wild....and i feel this is the reason Maan takes the oath to marry her in 12 days.....

But then it would not be a Dream Wedding.....

Its nice when we can't Pinpoint what and where the track is leading us to😉
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: --Nargis--



Lo...Viju...the BATTLE of the TAVEEZ!!😆



Oye GC aur DD ko Ghussa mat dila....Its TABEEZ not TAVEEZ

LavZ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: rickks


The dialogue was crap because that was the only thing one would grasp after seeing the EPISODE.....its the track that got screwed up at that particular seq...Barry gave dialogues as per what the track/Story writer the director must have asked him to

yes Viju...da dialog was crap...BD was askd to do so...... da flow of the track was fine till den...Geet gettin unconz cos of the heat.....pulse reducin....Maan all worrid.....if da dialgo was avoided da track lukd fine to me...da logic wnt ven dey said dat dey can save only 1......coz dat was RUBBISH!!!! track lukd rubbish aftr dat......i get da point dat BD was askd to do so...bt iske liye we cnt blame da whole track naa......dey wil mak it up....sure...
LavZ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: kuls11





Lavzu....tu mujhse ignore ker rahi hai

arre arre...kullu maina aaj kissiko hi nahi kaha.....main aur thumhe ignor??😲 NOT possible....🤗
-sann- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#97
may be ishtupid doc is out of her mind...may be she wanted to say tht if MSK choose to save both thn geet ki jaan ko khatra ho sakta hai...baby ki survival ki chance bohot kaam hai...in order to save both of thm...they can lose both...

see...the cv's affected me...😆
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: LavZ

yes Viju...da dialog was crap...BD was askd to do so...... da flow of the track was fine till den...Geet gettin unconz cos of the heat.....pulse reducin....Maan all worrid.....if da dialgo was avoided da track lukd fine to me...da logic wnt ven dey said dat dey can save only 1......coz dat was RUBBISH!!!! track lukd rubbish aftr dat......i get da point dat BD was askd to do so...bt iske liye we cnt blame da whole track naa......dey wil mak it up....sure...



lavz i am talking about the logic of the the usage of the dialogue for such a track....and thats why naming it STORY/Seq.....Plus nobody can blame the entire episode...only the hosp seq....and the entire doctors Seq was what made the episode crap.....the Doctor usage and track was fully flawed
-honeydew- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#99
My take: updated on page 1

Its like ... when there is story we want moment
when there are moments we want story ..
when there are sequences we look for logic..
when logic is brought in we look for execution...

either ways there is something or the other that we complain of ..as for today .. it was not one of the best... but it was not that horrible as well...

The episode had story... and i guess thats what we wanted .. didnt we.. we wanted things that would take a track forward ...

Geet in the sauna and the door getting jammed was a logical explanation to why she couldnt come out ...Brij was consistent in character... it was more like aadmi khatam-kaam khatam !! they left it at that point so show the man will strike this time big time after learning she has survived the worst as well.. he will also realise that the bigger danger at hand at the moment he faces is from maan singh khurana himself .. and unless maan is out of his way, he will not be able to touch Geet !!

Maan's fear and tension was apparent when he realises he could lose Geet, and even at that moment he looks at the taveez...
is it Taveez part two i wondered.. remember how the taveez had found its rightful owner? This time also i thought aisa kuch hone waala hai .. But Maan places it around her arm ... in anycase, it was touching to see how a man like him had turned this vulnerable and was willing to believe a superstition for the sake his beloved ...

geet or the baby.. well yeh toh hona hi tha ..looks like it .. sadly, it was a twist that was perhaps expected ... but, unfortunately we the audience of star one are not tuned to watch something like this .. however, i feel there was no other way out .. and this episode was needed ... to clear a few things .. and bring in a few dilemma ...

in a crisis situation like this who would maan choose- the baby or the mother? Obviously he is attached to the baby only through Geet, and only for Geet but now he is attached to the baby as well...
remember the kasam he had taken for Geet's sake? will it find its place now? we dont know time will tell ...
however the pace of the episode was a little slow esp the Maaneet sequence...

Anwesha and Arjun: loved how she asked him to win her back and how he was taken aback when she gave it back to her .. it looked like he was beginning to realise she is important to him after all.. and admiting to her that she is perhaps the only person he has explained himself to her, and his shock when she spoke of NT showed Arjun is taking steps in a positive direction ...

I like where the story is heading .. and after this ... my prediction stays where it is ...

just a predikson :
Geet passes out in the bathroom and she is rushed to the hospital and while she is unconscious she dreams of Maan and herself and him taking her away, and all this while everyone is worried and scared as to what would happen to her ...
But then she see's herself sinking and, its the hope to be with him that brings her back !

Love,
niha
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: -sann-

may be ishtupid doc is out of her mind...may be she wanted to say tht if MSK choose to save both thn geet ki jaan ko khatra ho sakta hai...baby ki survival ki chance bohot kaam hai...in order to save both of thm...they can lose both...

see...the cv's affected me...😆



Oye nanu ki jaan🤗.....Kaha ho.....
Nanu ko bhool gayi na😭


Toh batayi Doctor Sahiba...what did u think of the whole hosp track???

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Dragon-Heart · 2 years ago

Introduction As I already told you that I am going to write period fiction... So here is it... Let's see how is the response. That will decide...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".