3 idiots- josh uda de acche accho ki hosh....

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

ravenheart

@ravenheart

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#71

I watched the slap scene again and I am sorry to say Maan really deserved it. They have ruined Maan's character big time. Geet at least had a good reason to behave the way she did. Maan ko itna ghussa kis baat ka yaar? Ok if he is angry, then open your damn mouth and speak out what is troubling you. Aise sab dil mein rak ke, Geet will not get telepathy abt his feelings. Maan, my dear, this is not PKYEK. You are not a vampire and neither is Geet.

I see a long separation ahead. Abhi toh NT ka drama start bhi nahin hua.

Quote

-Amrita2010

@-Amrita2010

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#72

Maan was teaching Geet the rules to be followed in the office...Why not he learn some rules to live a happy life with a woman?

Rule #1. Learn to respect women

Rule #2. Understand/learn that feelings and emotions do exist

Rule #3. Believe that women are not weaknesses.....There is a woman behind every successful woman.

Maan needs to learn so much about woman and their feelings if he wants to live a life with a woman.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

something

@Silentsoul

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#73

Originally posted by: Pari76

I am not quite sure which Geet HSP some people were looking at, bu the one I looked at MAAN WAS FORCING HER TO DANCE WITH HIM!

Maan was not forcing himself on her.

There is a big difference between forcing someone to dance and forcing yourself onto someone. And it is pathetic and a shame that people are ready to FALSELY acknowledge forcing someone to dance as rape, but is so reluctant to acknowledge that what Dev did to Geet was rape (legally rape).

I agree Pari....I am with you....He was forcing soemone to dance...than forcing yourself is...direct reference to rape...But I would add let wait for tommorrow

Quote

ravenheart

@ravenheart

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#74

Originally posted by: kuls11

I agree Pari....I am with you....He was forcing soemone to dance...than forcing yourself is...direct reference to rape...But I would add let wait for tommorrow

Agreed. Maan's behaviour today cannot be construed as rape.

Quote

something

@Silentsoul

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#75

Originally posted by: dolphinUSA
I'm sorry but I think what Dev did to Geet is not rape. Rape is forced sex which often includes sexual assault. She was a victim of fraud. Just because her husband left her does not mean he raped her. That way, all women who suffer betrayal from their husband would be called rapers. And what about women who don't even know their husband is cheating on them? Geet was not forced into spending the night with him. She was ignorant and was tricked into it, but this cannot be called rape.

P.S. - this is just my POV...you are welcome to ignore me.

Nope DOl......according to one of clause...of rape...if sexual relationship is made on false pretense or on fraud without girl knowledge its classified as rape..according to Indian law..I have read that clause as it is...And than girl can file case of rape against fraud husband boyfriend anyone

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#76

Originally posted by: dolphinUSA
I'm sorry but I think what Dev did to Geet is not rape. Rape is forced sex which often includes sexual assault. She was a victim of fraud. Just because her husband left her does not mean he raped her. That way, all women who suffer betrayal from their husband would be called rapers. And what about women who don't even know their husband is cheating on them? Geet was not forced into spending the night with him. She was ignorant and was tricked into it, but this cannot be called rape.

P.S. - this is just my POV...you are welcome to ignore me.

Okay Dols Let me tell you....Sexual Act without Consent is Rape.....I agree that she is a Victim of Fraud...But she gave consent coz she was made believe in she is Married.....when she actually was not married......(Remember that the Pandit was fake everything was fake)....so its equivalent to Rape.....

Quote

maanmeet1

@maanmeet1

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

#77

rape is a very strong word and what maan did wasnt rape at all.........pls yaar dont make him stand in d category of dev and other rapists..........what he did to geet was not acceptable at all but dat wasnt rape..........dont insult him, his character and his love for geet by saying dis...........

what dev did was rape coz she wasnt aware of d fake marriage and if she knew she would never have consummated d marriage so dats rape...........

Edited by maanmeet1 - 14 years ago

Quote

_Invincible_

@_Invincible_

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#78

guys as nihu said it was rape of d track and FB's..........

maan didnt rape geet.........................

it was word war and den physical war but not rape............

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#79

Originally posted by: pooja83
guys as nihu said it was rape of d track and FB's..........

maan didnt rape geet.........................

it was word war and den physical war but not rape............

Exactly Pooji...That what we all are trying to say...Ki its Not Literal Raping....Its a Usage of Phrase...It was the raping of the execution......They wanted to show something but ending up showing something else😊

Quote

-honeydew-

@-honeydew-

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#80

okay baby!!

relax! it was a figure of speech, i meant he assaulted her sense by the way he handled her ...
i understand his pain and he is frustrated, but the way brought it out, ended up looking shaddy...
i have issues with the way the whole sequence was directed, as i could see and sense what they wanted to show but what they ended up showing!
also ... i havent been able to sense Maan's pain in while now, he looks only angry ...and i once again blame the direction for it ...
itna lamba post likne se pehle ek PM toh kar deti meri maa .... !! why are you jumping to conclusions ...
its not always man vs woman .... we all want them together and have their issues sorted ..
so chill out

Originally posted by: nanditasingh
Sharing something i just posted on Pari's post...
link https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1532745&PID=35834489�

to begin with ..i would like to add something that i had few days back posted at our thread

i fail to understand or rather what disturbs me most is

When a Woman's Pride is hurt we name it as Self Respect being wounded
but When it comes to a Man's Pride ...we easily say 'oh! his Ego is hurt'
why? Do woman not have Ego or Man Self Respect ..why the gender bias ?
at times i feel if guys could display or exhibit their tears then may be we could see their grief
but poor souls their heart bleeds but we care is for the outward tears ..

.......now coming to today's episode ..though i still feel their was no reason for this whole drama....yet i cannot help but say i liked today's episode...yes i did
yesterday after the SBS news i was worrying myself how the slap will be executed ...... & today i must say the played their cards well
it was not a slap ...if it were then Geet's reaction to her done action could be all different ....it was a reflex not a slap for real...
& i end it there

Now the Dance lolzzz....Rape .....!!!!
was 'kurban hua' that was a forceful dance called same nay!
though i say this dance is but insult to Kurban hua memory ....
but still to be fair wasn't it same .....he forced her to dance
yeah he dint know of her pregnancy then....
but mind u guys Geet herself has scared us to core with her disastrous self maintainance ways that made her always to question her pregnancy ...but how conveniently we remember that now to rub it on Maan's face ...

Rape!!
any idea what a big sin & crime Rape is guys that this term is so losely used .... i'm not shocked but feeling sick having read the dance being called 'forcing himself on her ' & 'Rape'
i'm sure i don't need to supply the dictionary meaning to the term....

use words carefully friends ..they just don't make or break images, thoughts, heart but lives too.....

Quote

1 ... 6 7 8 9 10 ... 27

3 idiots- josh uda de acche accho ki hosh.... - Page 8

Related Topics

Explore Topics