3 Idiots - Parivaar Ya Pyaar, Maan ka Faisla

Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

Idiots' Tantra Mala



Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

Considering that we are all idiots and we need some semblance for we have a pool of writers, analysts and observers, who contribute to increase, improve and help our understanding Geet the serial, characters, plot and other aspects and symbolism in the story. We have people who find elements like water, color and let's not forget inanimate objects like dupatta in their analysis.
So here is the tantra mala for those who don't understand so much Hindi it is a system well it is not idiot proof for it is for idiots..

Tantra

1.The first post is the TANTRA Mala

2.The second post is the Index & Spoilerz


3.The Third post is for the ROTA

4. Topic opener's post

4. The first FOUR pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.
5. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.
6. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyze the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.

7. We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.
8. The thread will be opened in a rota system and the list will be available on the thread as well.
9. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

Please feel free to join this and discuss everything under the sun, moon, stars' anything related to the episode, doubts, different pov, should be done on the main thread let everyone get to know what you are thinking'


The Idiot Family-VM

Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

561

Views

25.9k

Users

31

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Index of analysis beyond pg 3....

aditi123_78


cxw1065


Vinu's spoilers....


******************************************************
Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago
Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

ROTA

Week starting 25th October

Monday ' Rev

Tuesday ' Pooja

Wednesday 'Nargis

Thursday ' Muniza

Friday ' Rickks

Week Starting 1st Nov

Monday ' Kulz

Tuesday ' Fahsaad

Wednesday ' Jes75

Thursday ' Nandu

Friday ' Nags

Week 8th Nov

Monday ' Imraana

Tuesday ' Sann

Wednesday ' Aditi

Thursday ' lily _k

Friday ' Rev

Week Starting 15th Nov

Monday ' Lvraaz

Tuesday ' Sigma

Wednesday ' Rushtrip

Thursday ' sksg

Friday - Anisha


Anyone wanting to open the thread please send pms to the founding members, RushTrip, Revv and Nargis

IDIOT Assignments:

Aamir Khan ... Rancho - Nargis
Kareena Kapoor ... Pia - dolphinUSA (Dol)
Madhavan ... Farhan Qureshi - RushTrip (Vrush)
Sharman Joshi ... Raju Rastogi - MaaneetDD (Rev)
Boman Irani ... Viru Sahastrabudhhe - Rickks (Viji)
Omi Vaidya ... Chatur Ramalingam aka 'Silencer' - mysterygurl1427 (Shivani)
Javed Jaffrey ... Ranchoddas Shamaldas Chanchad - Yasu09
Mona Singh ... Mona - blueangle13
Rahul Kumar ... Millimetre - MM - SIGMA (Param)
Ali Fazal ... Joy - NanditaSingh
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre - Neha
Rajeev Ravindranathan ... Lead Ragging Senior - pooja83
Akhil Mishra ... Librarian Dubey - Maneetforever (Amerra)
3 IDIOT Audiance - aditi123_78 (Aditi)
Mona(Geet's) Unborn Baby - --sann-- (Nupur)
Shoaib Ahmed ... Chote - jamoshi2507 (Neha)
Meghna Bhatia ... Raju's Wife - pickle6586 (Soumya)
Amardeep Jha ... Raju's Mother - macho_muffin
Malvika Singh ... Mona's Baby - Star Struck- Anisha
Chaitali Bose ... Raju's Sister -LavZ
Vidhu vinod chopra aka VVC- Niha (honeydew)


The Open positions are:

Parikshat Sahni ... Farhan's Father
Jayant Kripalani ... Campus Interview Panel Head
Chandrashekhar ... Airlines Ground Staff 2
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre
Achyut Potdar ... Machine Class Professor
Atul Tiwari ... Minister in Auditorium
Arun Bali ... Shamaldas Chanchad
Supriya Shukla ... Matron in Hospital with Pia
Farida Dadi ... Farhan's Mother
Omi ... Chatur - pondicherry boy
Pooja Goswami ... Air Hostess
Harvinder Singh ... Mr. Dhillon
Nishi Singh ... Maid at Pia's House
Dinesh Kumar ... Mona's Husband
Aakash Dabhade ... ICE Student 2
Pitobash ... Junior 1
Rakesh Sharma ... Minister at Shyamaldas' Funeral
Michael Joseph ... Exam Hall Professor
Captain A.S. Duggal ... Pilot
Dr. Praful Kulkarni ...Doctor startled by scooter in hospital
Sarvanna ... College Security Guard
Trilok Sadhwani ... ICE Student 4
R.S. Kodange ... Doctor at Airport
Mukund Bhatt ... Raju's Father
Tanveer Ahmed ... Professor in Induction Motor Class
Hitesh Tak ... Ragging Senior 2
Sitaram Sharma ... Manager at Pia's Wedding
Raghunathan ... Professor in Corridor
Vaidyanathan ... Professor Vaidyanathan
Rajendra Patwardhan ... Govind
Sanjay Sood ... Peanut Vendor at Shimla
Annapurna Kaul ... Airlines Ground Staff
Pandit Prayag Raj ... Panditji at Pia's Wedding
Dr. Kishor Patil ... Doctor in Ambulance with Raju
Dayal Sharma ... Caretaker at Shyamaldas' House
Shankar Sachdev ... Ambulance Driver
Dharmendra Bhurji ... Airport Cab Driver
Apul Jaisinghani ... ICE Student 3
Shailaja Dhar ... Lady at Mona's Wedding
Saurabh Agnihotri ... Housekeeping Boy at Pia's Wedding
Kumar Veer Singh ... Waiter at Mona's Wedding
Sonu ... Library Clerk
Dileep Desai ... Priest at Joy's funeral

3IDIOT Index
(Last Several Threads we made as one Big Idiot Family)

Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
I am not Least Bothered about the Up-coming MU track........(If there is Going to be One)...Nope Nope

Because i Have full Trust On CV's and still more trust on Maan the character....

If He could sense that Geet was suddenly Shocked and all nervous and had questions in her heart regarding his Sudden announcement of their Marriage....

If he could see that her Eyes were Brimming with Tears .....

If he could Follow Geet and tell her that its her Habit of eaves-dropping and taking things in the wrong sense.....Him assuring that their Dor is not weak etc

I am sure Geet's insecurities and wrong Notions will be well taken care off by none other than Maan Singh Khurana...

So i am going to sit back and relax....


Edited by rickks - 14 years ago
Pari76 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Res

Guys: if there is a complete "misunderstand and separation track" I doubt that I will continue to do a take. I am going to wait and see how tomorrow's episode goes but'

An episode of doubts, broken promises, misunderstandings and the possible loss of one the foundation stone to this story the "soul mate theme",
What a load of utter stupidity! It is confirmed that the CVs and Nissar have lent/loss their brains. We will see if it is official tomorrow or not depending on what route is taking/completed.

I am so, so, very extremely disappointed that today's episode and that it is the making of a "misunderstanding and separation track" for Maan and Geet. Especially when there is no need for a "misunderstanding and separation track". It seems forced because the storyline at this point at time does not require it nor does it have the space for it.

If you, CVs, Nissar and whoever else has lost all your marbles then hire a new creative team and fire yourselves. If you, CVs and Nissar complete this "misunderstanding and separation track" that would ruin this show badly and make just another show.

This show is packed with talented actors and actress straight across but its' Story Writer, Swati Pandey, Series Director and Nissar doesn't seem to think so nor do they harness the ability of their actors.

Remember one thing; your work is a reflection of who you are. While people will remember the wonderful actors and actress as being talented they'll recognize the rest you as careless and talentless.

I say this because you have a show that has been holding the ranks at number one even when your "main lead" GC was out sick because your viewers stuck by the actors' and actress' side and also by the show's side indirectly by your side. So to deal them an unwanted and uncalled for hand is just a slap in our faces. To this we say "NO THANK YOU"! Enough is Enough. We support unforeseen circumstances but not stupidity.

If the show would call for a "misunderstanding and separation track", then we wouldn't be upset, BUT IT DOES NOT CALL FOR A "MISUNDERSTANDING AND SEPARATION TRACK".

To the episode itself'

What happened to the taveez?

Where is the taveez?

Where is the logic in today's episode?

What happened to Geet's character groW*H?

The acting by the actors/actress was good.

Keep in mind just because the acting is good doesn't mean the story is good.

While Maan taking control in the media situation is his nature, Geet didn't exactly step up to the plate.

Does Geet's mouth has a lock and key or does it operate by remote control? I ask this because the girl who wanted to leave the Maan who she loved so much because she can't stand anyone saying of pointing a finger at stood quietly like the media attacked him. What happened to her care about is izzat, what happened to standing by his side?

Keep in mind this is a girl who argued with the host of an Italian restaurant over crab, but she couldn't stand up for the Maan she loves, the same Maan she risked her life and unborn child's life to go back to HP to save him from going to jail? What the hell?

When Maan interlock his hand with Geets, she did not immediately reciprocate as she has done before.

Maan clarifying to Geet about wanting to marry her is good. This was a nice romantic moment amid the craziness.

Geet convo with Meera, why the heck is Geet having any doubts about Maan's marriage proposal after the Maan clearly said "he truly wants to marry her"? Where the heck is the doubt or misunderstanding in this?

Dadi Ma, Dadi Ma this I didn't expect from her to ask Maan to bail Dev out. Both Maan's and Dadi 's character sketch have been portrayed as the epitome of truth, the murti of truth. So it is beyond me why the CVs and Nissar chose to give Dadi a black spot ruining her character sketch.

When Dadi asked Maan to bail Dev out and he refuse; Maan was totally right. But then Dadi played the emotional card, but this emotional card was life and death, she says "if YOU want me to be better'" These words place Maan between a rock and a hard place. However, Maan should have called Geet at Meera's and he would have known that Geet was on her way to Khurana's house. Maan would have spoken to Geet and Geet would have agreed. Maan has broked his promise to Geet here. The problem is we didn't get to hear exactly what Dadi asked Maan to do. So was it just to bail Dev out or something additional? The CVs and Nissar really messed up Maan's character sketch here.

It seems like Dadi didn't ask for NT'

Maan clearing dadi's mistaken idea about the reason behind Maan-Geet wedding was well needed. Maan's words to Dadi regarding Geet were quite clear and profound about his feelings. Also it illustrates that he knows how much she trusts him. Clearly you can see here that Maan without a doubt loves Geet.

Geet overhearing part of the conversation and then running out, Maan stops her by grabbing hold of her dupatta. Maan thinks Geet has heard the entire conversation. Maan repeats the very words Geet wrote in the letter which she left along with the taveez on his bed. Geet once again doubts him here by saying he puts family first. What is wrong with this girl?

Nice of you CVs and Nissar to weave the words back in, but what happened to the taveez?

Geet wants to speak to Maan because she has doubts about what Maan said to Dadi.

Geet scolds herself after Maan leaves for the office due to board members freaking out over current Khurana family situation. She tells herself that she trusts Maan more than herself. How can she doubt him? And yet she is on the boat to go to the office out of all places and considering the Maan said some important work came up that he had to leave and not just leave but leave in the middle of their important conversation; she wants to go talk about her doubts.

Geet bumping into Dev is cement cast to lay the tile of misunderstanding to create separation.

Of course Geet will be shocked to see Dev and she stands there and asks him "Dev, you? How come you are here?" Dev answers her that "bro bailed him out because'" doesn't say another word for about a minute or so and Geet stands there long enough to remember the sentence that she overheard Maan saying to Dadi and then rushes. She stood there all this time infront of Dev, her rapist, her victimizer and she couldn't wait to hear his sentence out or to ask why. So here we have the CVs and Nissar victimizing the victim all over again by having Dev corrupt her life yet again.

1. This entire episode show Geet is on the verge of squashing one of the stones that laid the foundation for this show and that is the "soul mate theme"; by Geet being the Queen who doubts Maan, the human being that risk his life for her twice and then has risks everything else just for her just because he loves her as his life, she doubts him. Granting the meeting of Dev and Khurana's house is a bit on the edge, but when has Maan ever let Geet down, when. The one time he couldn't be by her side, he was hospitalized. What makes her think he is not in a bind this time?

2. Geet in this episode portrays :

a) her love as a lie

b) she has no trust or faith in Maan or their love

c) she spoke lies when made promises of love, happiness, truth

d) she made a mockery out of him and their love

e) she doesn't understand Maan

f) she isn't different from any other girl.

3. The CVs and Nissar have managed to destroy three (3) important character sketches today, Geet, Maan and Dadi.

4. CVs and Nissar why did you guys show this episode instead of showing an episode that answers the numerous unanswered questions.

Precap: No precap.

My concerns:

Maan said to Geet that if she is tired and wants t leave then he has been defeated because he couldn't protect her from people. Will Geet choose to leave or to stay with Maan.

Will Geet still go to the office and another incident creates yet another misunderstanding?

Separation of Maan and Geet on a temporary basis. Utter stupidity if it happens.

It also seems that the CVs and Nissar are making way for another entry, but whose?

Vicky's entry?

Sameera's entry? This seems more likely

What needs to happen'

1. The taveez needs to go back around Maan's neck!

2. The misunderstanding needs to be cleared out between Maan and Geet.

3. No separation of Maan and Geet

4. Dev's mother and sister need to be mentioned as part of the criminal crew.

5. Maan needs to become the ferocious tiger. Remember his words to NT that if she made Geet cried, he would take revenge for each tear drop. I don't think NT can pay this debt in its' entirety in this lifetime.

6. Also Dev's mom and sister need to be punished.

7. Maan and Geet needs to support each other.

8. Maan still needs to know

i. That NT poisoned Dadi's mind

ii. That Dadi kicked Geet out of the house.

iii. That NT lied to Geet about him not wanting to see her

iv. That NT lied to Geet about the taveez and again Maan not wanting to see her

v. That NT moved him from his original hospital room in order to prevent Geet from seeing

Him and that she stopped Geet at the door of his hospital room from entering to see him.

vi. That Sasha is the reason why the story came out at the office.

9. Maan will have to handle the office situation, but is should be Geet that handles Sasha.

10. Myra needs to come clean about what she knows to both Maan and Geet while revealing her connection with the Khurana.

11. Is it Yash or Aditya? Aditya, Yash's middle name?

12. Geet's "blind" promise to Yash needs to be dealth with.

CVs and Nissar, you will be VIRTUALLY DEAD if you'

1. SEPARATE MANNEET, EVEN ON A TEMPORARY BASIS AND TRPs WILL SINK! THERE IS NO NEED FOR A MISUNDERSTANDING OR SEPARATION TRACK for the story to move forward... (CAPS OF EMPHASIS ONLY).

2. If you have Geet misunderstand Mann that he was a part of the Dev and criminal crew scam/Dev rape. Mann saved Geet twice putting his own life in danger and that's just two times out of a zillion that he has helped her. It would be really stupid for this to happen.

Edited by Pari76 - 14 years ago
LavZ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Edited....

Pooj - nice title...
2days episod was heart wrenchin fr me.....i cnt see dis happenin in my show.....cnt even imagin dat i hav been so emotionally attachd wid a show dat each n evry episod leaves a mark on my heart......i havnt lost da faith i hav in CVs...so vil nt judge Geet nw....
Not much of analysis frm my side....
Love ya Maan - yeh duwa hai meri ki har ek ladki ko aap jaise pati mile...har ek maa ko aap jaise beta mile....har ek parivaar ko aap jaisa wariz mile.......he neva fails to do his duty...be it towrds his Daadi or Geet.....he follows it all....
Geet - she is upset..she wants to trust him...bt her mind says sumthin n her heart sumthin elz....she noes he wnt do nythin to upset her...she noes he lovs her...bt still she is forcd to see wat she can...she cnt see thru it....my only requst - talk to Maan clear off da MU.....think...think...think...abt wat all he has done fr u.....Think n talk to him.....
Maneet is bonded fr lyf....MU r a part of lyf.....wateva happens dey wil b togthr..dey wil clear off evrythin.....i noe all des....bt y do i feel so low aftr seein da episod?!😕
I hope to see Maan convincin Geet.....Geet askin Maan n belivin him.....i hope to see Geet think....n talk it out wid Maan....i wnt to c da show bck wid its style.....
CVs - please dnt let us dwn...please...dnt spoil Geets charctr.....please bring da charm of our show bck....bring our GEET HSP bck to lyf again.....
Please gv us one light hearted episod...one episod ver v can get old Maneet moments bck...one episode ver v can forget all woris n enjoy Maneet.....okie am i being greedy here??😕 break tho bantha hai naa boss....😉
Loads of luv,
Lavz....
Edited by LavZ - 14 years ago
-honeydew- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
I dont like what i am feeling,
but i know my heart weighs heavy ..
i know those promises were no lie ...
i know you would never wanna make me cry ....

my heart refuses to believe this could be your face ...
show me some mercy, give me some grace ...
what you feel for me cannot be a lie ...
oh why oh why then, do you make me cry ...

i know i trust you, i always will...
please dont break my heart ...
or the insides of me you will kill ...

Maan you mean love to me ..
You mean everything in my life ...
Its alright if you dont make me your wife ..
But dont shatter my dreams ..,.
Dont belittle those hopes...

i think i know you more than this ..
but its this damn mind thats playing havoc ...
i know i trust you ...
i know i love you ...
though i may never say this to you ....

oh please oh god!
let this night pass...
i am not talking of geet ...
but i am talking of myself ...

i know she is shattered ...
i know she is shocked...
anyone in her place would react that way ..
thats why i curse my self for watching k soaps night and day ...

i know this one will prove me wrong ...
come to me friday...
sing me a lovely song ..
maan i love you ...
for once prove me wrong ...
sweep her off her feet maan!
Thats all i want!!

where is vinu ??? i havent lost hope! come back soon .. guys i need a hug .. guys .. bahut disturbed hoon.. dil says .. kal sab theek ho jayega .. lekin fir bhi bahut darr lag raha hai ... i feel just like geet .. please let me pass this night ...

love,
niha

Edited by -honeydew- - 14 years ago
lily_k25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
now take a deep breath....
n let it out slowly....
calm down...
just clear ur mind...
cool down..
n activate ur ur brain cells again..

this is wat am doing since the epi...trying to clear my already jumbled up mind.
now again..my dear sweet brain n heart...just cool...dont get tensed...




plss..help needed to get myself back to normal
Edited by lily_k25 - 14 years ago
nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
don't want to see my Maan heartbroken.....bas


update as for now .....
hopefully not the last smile me seeing on these two faces in episodes to come.....



i don't want to believe & think about what i saw & felt today.....
so much in the name of trust & faith....haa!

Maan was so right...too much tears does makes brains functioning go numb..

Trust...Faith & Love ....is it so easily lost ...that too when the person you are losing all these emotions on has hard earned them all time and again.....




not sure if i will be back.....
i'm totally 😡😭 today...Vinu ji u better not meet me today
Pooja kahan ho??????😕
Edited by nanditasingh - 14 years ago
--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Jinkey Vishwas Par Main
Vishwas Kar Baithha
Vo Ab Bhi Nahi Kartey Hai Vishwas
Mere Vishwas Par
Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

4 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Binding by Love Pt 29 page 47- 10/1/25

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: priya_21

8 years ago

KASAM tere pyaar ki/PT4/5/pg29/32/11 feb

Can anyone love to another person to this extent, he killed someone... Can anyone love to another person to this extent, he fall so low in

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: priya_21

2 years ago

Tere Pyaar Mein Marjawa/pt16/17-pg29/31- 1 feb

previous thread - which get closed now you can read here - click here

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: priya_21

2 years ago

thread #2 Kuch Rang pyaar ke ase bhi/pt24/pg36- 13sept

Concept This is story about two strangers which tied in sacred bond and one partner fall in love with another at first sight. Two individuals...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

4 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Chup Chup ke Part 40 on page 66- 24/6/25

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".