Poor Show CVs *thumbs down* M/N p10 - Page 4

@ harpreet - =) thanks, at least for seeing the point. there's nothing we can do about what the cvs give us at the end of the day - but take it. still, it doesn't make the wrong right by default. =)

@yasu - in specific response to yours (because u actually talked of things i mentioned at least partly) daadi going sour on geet was never my issue, i did say that in my post. it was her ganging up and gelling with NT. she trusted NT? fine. we could have had a scene about 'their interaction there' as to what NT did tell daadi that was so believable to her. it would have explained more, not needed GC/DD and left less to speculations/assumptions. not doing that is what i call a lose track. and absolutely don't understand why NT isn't questioned at all, to begin with. if daadi has to turn tables, can she do it without losing her marbles? they could have simply used her angst on geet to being bad - and it would have been plausible - but A) they went over the top. B) they did nothing to justify it.

and of course Dev now. since you already agree to that, i have nothing to add. except that i don't brush off half baked character sketches as 'that character is just confused' a character is confused, because the writer creating him/her has not given it the due amount of thought or attention. and that doesn't do much to defend the 'stressed cvs' in my opinion. do i make a point?

once again, if you care to know, i'm NOT bashing cvs. i'm saying they have let down at least some viewers (like me) who care about more to the show then just awesomeness personified in lead pair's chemistry. period.

cheers,
nj

Originally posted by: spln

last word - if you don't have a sane point to make in that respect - save your breath. this post is obviously not for u, cause u don't understand/care about script glitches.

there are enough posts on the forum advocating support for cvs, and im capable of reading them without prompting. =)

😆😆😆😆Yes,I guess no..actually im sane enough to not to reply in ur post again,actually dats y i didn't write much in my previous post as myself didn't find *d reason u gave" sane enough to talk abt..& yeah i can understand u only-really care/understand about script glitches...Oh ! u r capable enough to read other post in d forum..Opps!@My bad i tried to help u wid dem...😲
To tell u honestly.I didn't wish to say this thoughSpare dis forum😃We have faith on CV's as of now.When we goona loose all our faith dat time u can post such a post again..:) When its doing gud let ppl enjoy instead of ruining it,Or a better idea what we ppl usually do as CV's demself gives us dat platform,Post on der FB wall,whenever we dont like something we go der & simply give our feedback..*oh my*Im again giving u a source which may make u feel better..*opps*

Last word- If u wish to "not agree wid dis " Ignore..& find other to reply back directly..Its a goodbye from me to u here:)


If u were not replying me back (indirectly) abt d post thing & if ur friend were not talking abt some "another forum" here i 'd not have bother to reply here @ 1st place..But dont worry,Now i've nothing more to add + wanna save my breath as u said..So TC.

Originally posted by: spln

@yasu - in specific response to yours (because u actually talked of things i mentioned at least partly) daadi going sour on geet was never my issue, i did say that in my post. it was her ganging up and gelling with NT. she trusted NT? fine. we could have had a scene about 'their interaction there' as to what NT did tell daadi that was so believable to her. it would have explained more, not needed GC/DD and left less to speculations/assumptions. not doing that is what i call a lose track. and absolutely don't understand why NT isn't questioned at all, to begin with. if daadi has to turn tables, can she do it without losing her marbles? they could have simply used her angst on geet to being bad - and it would have been plausible - but A) they went over the top. B) they did nothing to justify it.

and of course Dev now. since you already agree to that, i have nothing to add. except that i don't brush off half baked character sketches as 'that character is just confused' a character is confused, because the writer creating him/her has not given it the due amount of thought or attention. and that doesn't do much to defend the 'stressed cvs' in my opinion. do i make a point?

once again, if you care to know, i'm NOT bashing cvs. i'm saying they have let down at least some viewers (like me) who care about more to the show then just awesomeness personified in lead pair's chemistry. period.

cheers,
nj

dear dear piya - if thats your name - again, you were bothering with too much that gave no answers. u dont find my questions 'sane enough' but u find reason to refute with long posts anyways?! well thanks. thats considerate. my thread is becoming popular, and btw, thats good reason to 'still stick around the forum' =) and yes, thanks again, since u plan to save 'further' breath on this matter. much obliged!


@yasu - sorry about mis-communicating myself if i did with you. no i didn't think u were being repulsive about my post at all. u were merely discussing back, and that's one reason i replied to u individually =) so thing is i didn't think the dadi-NT scene sufficed as justification, except to tell the audience that they were transiently on one team - u say the cvs can show ahead what NT actually said to daadi ... and what im saying is that because the leads are not around, isn't this the best time to actually clarify each one these characters? give them right space? and all the scenes they need? i also thought NT meera interaction was half baked. they clearly showed friction, but they could have gone deeper, thus covering episode time, and giving us a background that is needed, now. daadi will eventually come around of course - although people also think there was a preset CVs decision on turning her bad which i have reason to believe - but that's my next disappointment. they didn't have to make daadi unjustified at all. she could have just been hell bent mad on geet - and that would have been justified (even with a little over the top drama like throwing her out of the house - cause seriously, NT hurt Dev too... no matter how long daadi lived with her, she still has the reason to throw NT out for the same reason) but there's no accepting NT and daadi on team like thick mates... it could have been daadi being to geet and at least cold to NT but NT taking her chances to regain her position... and of course, there is the dev point, which i dont need to raise with u - we're in agreement there =)
thing is - people will miss maaneet till they are back. viewers like me, who maybe few but aren't not there at all, who sort of ignore the cvs blunders in the presence of leads, find much more disappointment minus the fancy artists to cover up. it should be more reason for the cvs to give the script more thought. just that. and honestly, if you will buy this, that was the sole purpose of this post. unfortunately, fanaticism doesn't escape any place - not even random forum posts. too bad.

cheers,
nj

@Spin....Whoaaa girl!!! You've braved this one out:))) Surprised i didn't see this post earlier. I also agree with your part of the CVs in assassinating the characters unnecessarily. My contention was Geet walking out of her engagement after all that Maan's done for her!!! If her facing Dev was going to have such a drastic effect shouldn't that interaction have been saved for a time other than just before the engagement? The leads falling sick does not excuse script glitches.

@ S.Maan & sophee

LOL! i saw your posts and breathed a sigh of relief - and went 'there comes my rescue team phew!' 😆 😆

no seriously.

it amazes me people can't just take 'points of view' coming from a countering end. whatever!

so yeh, script glitches are the most unfortunate ways to assassinate characters, and eventually a good show which had far more potential to survive and do better.

This is Geet at its peak. so people may not give a damn. but bad script writing comes to miserable ends when ridiculous glitches pile up beyond a point. it was my plain concern to that which made me put up this thread. i'm glad about some people agreeing. and i only hope that unlike all those here who didn't agree, the CVs themselves will find time and occasion to question their lapse and fix it, in time.

cheers,
nj


ps: - S.Maan (since i don't know ur name) hahah! i know what u mean by i dont give a damn as long as maaneet get their happy forever after! its not that i haven't gone all *Rolls eyes* at the script glitches before, but maaneet's absence just accentuated all that lapse. and somewhere, even when i don't really care about the other characters, i still want to watch an overall sensible script (and i know people say all that indian tv stuff to justify, but come on.... didn't we get the likes of rishta.com? a show with every single extra carved out with such dedicated thought!) the reason we dont care about extras is because they actually haven't been carved out well... but that's another thing... right now, i wish they'd give the script some logic. and logic has nothing to do with sympathy votes or excuses. period.

Originally posted by: spln

@yasu - sorry about mis-communicating myself if i did with you. no i didn't think u were being repulsive about my post at all. u were merely discussing back, and that's one reason i replied to u individually =)

not a problem NJ 😃 u can call me Yaz 😎

so thing is i didn't think the dadi-NT scene sufficed as justification, except to tell the audience that they were transiently on one team - u say the cvs can show ahead what NT actually said to daadi ... and what im saying is that because the leads are not around, isn't this the best time to actually clarify each one these characters? give them right space? and all the scenes they need?

this is indeed a very good time for the CVS to explain the NT-Dadi vs Geet track further... but i feel that perhaps they didn't want to provide a proper explanation just yet because they plan to drag the show by revealing the justification behind this bit by bit at a slower pace.... or maybe because of the shortage of time and the added stress they didn't even think that far ahead....🤓

i also thought NT meera interaction was half baked. they clearly showed friction, but they could have gone deeper, thus covering episode time, and giving us a background that is needed, now.

again i think ther CVs were just briefly introducing the NT vs Meera track last week... but may go deeper into this track bit by bit in the coming epi's, as part of the dragging plan... they didn't want to give everything away in one go.... i feel they're doing this as a precaution just incase Guru is not well enough to return to shooting.... this way they can stiil continue showing this track while the leads are away....

thing is - people will miss maaneet till they are back. viewers like me, who maybe few but aren't not there at all, who sort of ignore the cvs blunders in the presence of leads, find much more disappointment minus the fancy artists to cover up. it should be more reason for the cvs to give the script more thought. just that. and honestly, if you will buy this, that was the sole purpose of this post. unfortunately, fanaticism doesn't escape any place - not even random forum posts. too bad.

LOL... to be honest blunders increase immensely while the leads are away for any show that's why i don't really care for it much... 😛.... i actually think the Geets CVs are one of few creatives team who handled the situation well... even if there were a few blunders.... 🤪

im hoping that the CVs do address these issues though even if it is done at a very slow pace....

ur right in saying that as there's more screen space without the leads more explantions could be provided for the mentioned tracks... but i feel that becuase of the shortage of time maybe they didn't have enough time to spend more thought on one particular track, therefore by introducing multiple tracks (ie NT and Dadi teaming up and the whole NT against Meera) this gives them time to focus on aspects of a track rather than the whole track altogrther... Does that make sense.. or did i just confuse u 😆

cheers,
nj

NJ MERI BACHIIIIIIIIIIII!! 🤗 KAHAN THI TUM!! ME MISSED YOU LOL

@ Mrs Maan Singh Phurana: