Devil's Den Luka Chhuppi Bahut Hui..Samne Aaja Na

First Previous

Page

117

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

Today's episode was good in terms of a neat flow and execution👏...Dialogues in the second half of the episode was outstanding⭐️⭐️...and thats what left an impact for me and sort of wiped off the other cliched stuffs that were shown in the episode😃.....

Chalo let me get on with the scene by scene analysis today😛

The first few minutes of the episode was more of a hide and seek game between Maneet which could hv been avoided but sinse its a daily soap which sometimes need to b a dragged a bit..I m fine with the hide and seek game here😊...I was not convinced with Geet's reasoning though..the way she said to herself that Maan should hv stopped her in the conference hall itself;Well she needs to see things from Maan's POV as well;The guy just got the shock of his life after knowing the facts of her past ,so u can't expect him to hv instant reaction there..he will obviously take some time to process and realise before he can stop her...she should hv waited for him in the outhouse rather than taking the instant decision to leave the city;But again if I see from Geet's POV,I guess the dialgoue spoken by Maan that "I thought u r only mine" affected her the most and the reason why she took the instant decision to leave the city🤔..so mayb somewhere both r right in their own place;Mayb thats why I love the CVs of Geet..because they do make the viewers think in every scene and dialogues spoken by the characters👍🏼

Today I loved the rose,handkerchief and coffee FBs😳..it does give u a nostalgic feeling of Maneet sweet and pleasant memories😳;Maan's eyes too conveyed silent and unconditional love for Geet today when he was desperately searching for her inside the train..Gurmeet was back with a bang today with his flawless acting👏;Yes I willl say it was perfect today..he din't do any overacting..his eyes were portraying the right amount of pain thats needed to b shown that moment..it was not over the top melodrama from him when he was searching for Geet..I thought he was perfect here👍🏼......

Geet's bag getting stolen by those kids...I had a serious issue here where kids r portrayed as thieves😡 even though I know its a common problem in India thanks to the never ending poverty crisis in our country😔;But I liked the fact that both Maan and Geet gave an earful to those kids regarding this issue and somewhere CVs very smartly touched a very sensitive issue about the future of our country where we hv so many kids standing in traffic signals and stations trying to CON the tourists or get involved in robbery;Having said that I willl love to see Maan and Geet after their public confession giving some advice to those kids about their future in tomorrow's episode ..that can give out a very good message to our future of India😊...

Now the Taveez again comes in the picture and it seems Mr.Taveez is actually enjoying this passing the parcel game here between Maneet😉😆😛;Once again its back with Maan:the real owner of Geet's spl taveez;But I want Geet to get this taveez back and put it on Maan...which should complete the journey of this spl Taveez😳...

Here I would give full credit to Gurmeet for awesome display of emotions when the train leaves the station..he recollects those moments in the conference hall and drops tears from his eyes for the first time😭...Knowing MSK's reserved nature,I always knew that we won't see any volatile shouting or outburst from Maan in public when he sees Geet leaving her..he will b in tremendous pain but it will b reflected only through his silent tears of pain and agony and thats what was exactly portrayed today👏;Also lets not forget that Maan knew train is going to Ahmedabad..so he had all the option in the world to stalk her all the way to Ahmedabad by boarding a flight and reaching there before her train arrives😉😆😆;From here on I loved the instant change of his expressions ..from tears of pain to that adorable smile of satisfaction and happiness once he sees Geet scolding those kids in the station😳;He knew that he has found his smile again...No wonder I said Gurmeet was flawless today⭐️⭐️

The scene where Maan runs after Geet to stop her was very OTT because of poor editing and camerawork...but again I liked the fact that Geet does not board the train here and Maan is not chasing that train like those 60s ka hero😆..now that would hv been filmy..but not this😳...

Now the use of Jhalar in this confession scene was definitely symbolic ;I hv seen such things used in punjabi weddings where the bride-groom r tied up together with something similar and here we see Maan in a very romantic manner is trying to free Geet from the jhalar but he himself is still stuck in that jhalar with her😳...hmmm a good symbolism which is open to many interpretations😉;Also the fact that jhalar later becomes a catalyst for Maan-Geet ultimate gatbandhan itself proves that Nissar and CVs wanted to show a "Forever" bond here with the use of this jhalar😳...and it was done in public because they wanted to show that whole world becoming a witness to their divine love⭐️....

Now comes the best part of today's episode...Maan's confession and some brillaint dialogues written for his character⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️..so kudos to Barry Dhillon today👏👏..Romance is not just about passion and desire..sometimes u need some divine words also to express your love...it need not b cliched ILU but mayb something that can connect two souls forever..and this is where we hv these wonderful display of dialogues in this scene😳

Let me dissect each of these dialogues that Maan speaks today

1)Geet maine tumhe pehle hee kaha tha...jitni bhi koshish kar lo...tum mujhse door nahi jaa sakti:Indicates the amount of confidence Maan is hving on his love..he always knew that Geet will never board the train..mayb this explains why he had those silent tears of pain but not a complete outburst in the earlier scene because somewhere his heart knew that Geet cannot leave him😃

2)Tumhare bina main jee nahi sakta Geet:This was Maan's reply when Geet asks him why he wanted to stop her😳...now this is MSK...he doesn't twist his words and comes straight to the point...Today his life has no meaning without her presence😳

3)I m sorry Geet...Mujhe maaf kar do...Galti to meri hai...Jo maine tumhe jhootha samjha..galti to meri hai Geet...jo mujhe laga ki tumne mujhe dhoka diya:This sentence is again open to many interpretations especially the use of words like "Jhootha" or "Dhoka"🤔...Earlier Maan thought that why Geet had hidden this big truth from him and that was dhoka for him..but after realising the depth and compexity of her whole truth in last episode,he realised the reason why Geet had hidden it from him as it was his mistake that he never gave her the opportunity to speak earlier....So he realises that she has never given him any dhoka and he straightaway confesses it😃..About the jhoota part..I m still a bit confused..as per my buddy Doodle,she feels that Maan had a misunderstanding regarding Gurvinder and the fact that Geet told him that Gurvinder was only her friend's hubby whereas he was hving a doubt that mayb Gurvinder is the guy with whom she was involved and this was cleared in the last episode again..so he confesses that it was his mistake that he thought she was a jhootha...but I m still not convinced about whether this is the exact context in which MSK used the word jhootha...🤔

4)Geet...mujhe tumhare guzre hue kal se koi farak nahi parta...magar tumhare ane wale kal ka main hissa banna chahta hoon...main tumhari zindagi mein...tumhare saath jeena chahta hoon Geet:This is my personal favourite dialogue here...Here Maan doesn't ask Geet to become a part of his life..instead he asks her whether she would allow him to become a part of her life😳;In short the grt MSK today wants to b a part of someone else's present and future😲👏;The guy who planned everything in life now wants someone else to make a decision for his life😲;He is not asknig Geet to come in his life..instead he wants to go in her life and become a part of her world which includes the baby as well;😳What a splendid work by the dialogue writer here👏👏

5)Geet...tum iss ek angoothi ke saath kisi ki sari duniya peeche chod ke aa gayi thi:This dialogue actually indicates that Maan indeed is incomplete without her presence in his life..his world just cannot move without her now😭;For Geet it was just a ring but for Maan it was his entire world which is now revolving only around Geet😳;Now which girl can reject someone who is opening his heart out to her in this manner...He is almost submitting himself to Geet today through his words😳

Maan going down on his knees in the precap does not mean just proposal or confession..it means his submission to his lady love...he has submitted his entire life to Geet now😳...Many had issues regarding why this confession is done in public...so here is my reply..there is a strong purpose why its done in public...lets not forget that Dev-Geet marriage happened in private and after that Geet's entire life was ruined;Today MSK declares his love...submits himself ..and puts the ring on her finger in public just to give her the respect and honour that she truely deserves;CVs wanted to show the irony here...Here is a man who is declaring his love for his girl in front of the entire world..thats what Geet at this moment needs..she wants someone who can make her feel special in front of the entire world..and thats what Maan did today with his public declaration which Dev could never do😊;Why I m comparing both cases here is because tomorrow when Geet will find out that Maan and Dev r brothers,she can clearly differentiate between the two ...Dev being a coward whereas Maan being the courageous one😉😃...thats the main reason why the declaration was shown in public..but I m sure a more intimate and passionate confession between Maneet will definitely happen in the outhouse this week itself..so CVs better don't disappoint us here😳...

There was one sentence spoken by one of the kids in the station while watching Maneet romance..they said "arre yeh toh filmy scene hai"😆..I loved that dialogue..,because CVs here r actually making a fun of their own creation and telling the viewers that yes we made it filmy but it was deliberate😆😉...thats what makes even the filmy scenes look not very filmy because u know the intention of the CVs here for making it filmy deliberately😃...

Even though I don't mind Maan's confession in public...because of the reasons I hv stated above..but still I had some issue with those over-the-top crowd in the station clapping and wistling which was not needed there😡;Crowds should not take away footage from Maneet in tomorrow's epiosode😡😆..also CVs remember we want to see a private outhouse confession now which is more passionate and intimate😳......

Finally Dev-Myra scene...today I din't mind this scene as it was important to show Dev finally confessing his sin to someone at least😆;Yes there can b questions raised like why he is confessing it to Myra and not to his own brother or Dadi..well even in real life if we do something sinful,we will always confess it to our best friend rather than our parents as we feel more comfortable sharing it with a friend..so mayb thats why I don't really mind Dev confessing his sin to Myra today🤔;But hving said that I really don't want to see Dev becoming a saint here and Myra guiding him to the path of sainthood simply because its fiction and we want to b entertained here..so making all characters positive will kill the curiosity element in the show👎🏼;Yes Dev can feel guilty..Myra as a friend can guide him..but once truth is out in front of Maan,he should give severe punsihment to Dev for playing with Geet's life and I also want to see Geet giving few tight slaps to this jerk for his sinful acts;He just cannot go on saying that he did everything because of NT😡;As far as I remember NT never asked him to go and sleep with Geet😡;So he has commited a sin by playing with that young girl's life and he deserves to b severely punished here..no redemption of his character will work in this case😡...I hope CVs keep this in mind and bring out the devil in Dev soon after he is punished by Maan😎...And yes we want NT back in action now...she brings the extra spice to this show😛...Parneet as Myra was good with her expression today👏 but I found Abhinav completely wooden in his expressions despite the fact that it was such a cruicial scene for his character😕

My Rating for today:8.5/10...For me dialogues of Maan's confession was enough to give it a high rating today⭐️..Also Gurmeet and Drashti were fab with their performances today..no real melodrama from their ends which is what I liked⭐️

Edited by jyoti06 - 15 years ago

Quote

Lana Ghosh

@lghosh

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

Hi all!! Hope today's episode made u all happy, yes it made me too! But I have some minute issues as well. The more I watched the episode the more I started liking & connecting to it. It made its avenues open to my perspective.

Initially the train station concept didn't appeal to me, I have seen similar scenes in many films or serials & so didn't find it unique or innovative. But later l understood that train station symbolises a journey, a momentum of moving forward to some destination & this is what exactly I believe Nissar wanted to capture. Its their journey together towards the same destination, their life of Love & Happiness! So as far as the symbolism goes it was perfect! I know many will raise their eyes thinking 'oh not again, not another symbolism', 😃 but that is what came to my mind watching the train station. What to do, have to justify here the king of symbolism, Nissar!! 😃

Though I understand the reason for the station but somehow the entire set looked a little below the ordinary! That is where I felt it was cliche! But l will let it go, not possible to show a huge station like New Delhi in a small budget serial. And also felt the passengers were unnecessarily trying to look their busiest best which kind of stood out. But this r mundane factors which I will pass. Some portions looked a little exaggerated specially the hide & seek part of Maan & Geet! Too cliche about their standing back to back & yet not realising that the other one is there. That entire part I found a little inane because we have seen many serials & films in that exact same scenario. Hustle & bustle of the passengers & the hero & heroine getting lost amidst the sea of people unable to locate each other is too commonly used.

The fb's whatever Geet had, reflected all her positive memories of their love story so far. Maan's giving her the white rose indirectly which she had to throw away forcibly, the coffee though not up to Maan's taste but yet he accepted it lovingly, his caring for her offering his hanky............all positive reflections essaying the turmoil of her mind. She is leaving but her heart is left behind, she was already missing Maan. No wonder the dupatta stuck in that iron column immediately brought his name to her mind. In heart of hearts she wanted him to be there asking her to stay back, holding her back from leaving him!

When she first saw him running in the station looking frantically here & there her immediate reaction was to hide, obviously she didn't want to face him after all he said on Friday episode about her not belonging to him wholly! And this is a natural reaction. And I understand also that what he said then he meant it from his heart but Geet why will he use his head to come after u now? Is it just ur annoyance talking or u really mean it? If he has come to take u back then too it has to come from his heart. MSK can do his deals with his head but as far as Geet is concerned his heart always ruled his head! 😃

Again as I said earlier that hide & seek & the hullabaloo didn't appeal to me much but knowing the reason for station they have to justify the setting. But never understood why those people were going around them! Or for that matter when the train left why didn't they leave with the train? If they didn't want to board the train why were they busily walking around? Ok too many practical questions I think but again I will give it a go as they had to show a busy junction with many people around. 😃

But I would say after this section I liked the episode. First of all Nissar showed a nasty reality which we often come across India! Children muggers, thieves, pickpockets r pretty common there & to highlight that fact it was a good take Nissar! In fact we all know about the scams of children being trained in the arena of stealing, shop lifting & swindling! So definitely a bitter touch of reality here. But here at least they came to some use! The Taveez through them found their way to its destination, Maan. And in fact for love what not people do!! Even MSK had to bribe the kids to get to her!

And Geet's first reaction was her concern for the Taveez! I loved it when she said that it was the only symbol she had & we all know here she implies Maan & his memories. And Geet I thought ur bag was blue but u said yellow??

5th time we saw tears in MSK's eyes!! That look of devastation & hopelessness was so beautifully etched on Maan's face when he saw the train leaving! As if he lost everything is his life right then & there. All I could see was he looked destitute of love & life! And here all his fb's reflected his mood, all the fb's showed how grave he was feeling, her confessions of her past, his scolding her when she gifted the roses...........it showed his helplessness & melancholy.

And the moment he saw her the expression changed to disbelief, relief, happiness, hope & all his emerging love from within! And Nissar that entire act of getting that 'jhallad' on them was done nicely. I mean the execution of it. Perfect blending & timing. And u already laid a base about it earlier which made it more logical when this happened & didn't look out of the blue.

The 'jhallad' was a fantastic touch towards the completion of Parineeta metaphor. Another step ahead. It symbolised the veil of a bride & a 'sehera' of the groom & later we had the real 'gaatbandhan' this time when the 'jhallad' got stuck to his watch when Geet tried to leave. Nissar brilliant touch here. A ritual was completed there. His look of love & devotion there was amazing, it was special.

Here many people might wonder about the purpose for the segment of Dev & Myra in between! But today it had a major purpose!! Dev confiding in Myra about his misdeed & how he through his guilt lets Geet out of his system for good. Very very symbolic to see the contrast of feelings between the 2 brothers. One is letting Geet free from his memories & life & the other is accepting Geet in his life!! Again brilliant touch Nissar! And here the reactions of Myra is very well enacted by Perneet. The shock & disgust showed on her face.

Maan's apology to her at that precise moment made more sense because that moment looked auspicious. And here Nissar & Barry Dhillon thank u, thank u, thank u!! We all requested for Maan's declaration of his love to be an unique one & u all made it so. There was no cliche ILU but some beautiful touching dialogs that touched my heart to the core. This is what I expect from Maan. Thank u once again.

Under the roof & blessings of their love represented by that 'jhallad' he not only apologised for his erroneous judgements on Geet & her personality & character, only for a fraction of a second, & how he repents about it. His look of devotion & love at that moment said it all. He knew she won't be able to leave him in her life & that is what happened. Everything was so apt & beautiful here. His declaration of not being able to live without her as to her query of why does he want to stop her, again a big thumbs up. And his sincerest apology ever for misunderstanding & misjudging her thinking she lied to him about her past by not revealing it to him earlier & also thinking she has cheated & deceived him with someone!! That was so honest MSK!! That is where u differ from ur own brother & maybe men in general. Today I have grown immense respect for the character of Maan. Thank u Nissar. It takes a lot of guts for someone like MSK to admit his mistake & apologise for it so openly & sincerely.

And I adored the fact when he said I don't care about ur past but he wants to be a part of her future. He wants to live her life by just being with her!! Geet u left behind some one's whole life when u left this ring behind implying how she left him all isolated & desolate! I was totally floored by it all. And all along Geet had that hurt & full of pain look on her face, kind of she dared not hope too much!! She was still hurt by all his earlier insinuations.

And all along when he was taking that 'jhallad' strip one by one off Geet I kind of was reminded how husbands slowly takes aside the veil during marriage to put the mangalsutra & sindoor!! I am not saying Nissar meant that here but just it reminded me of how husbands put aside the veil of their brides. And today was a valid 'gaatbandhan' we saw! Previously we inferred it from various scenes wishfully thinking it was so but today the hint was much more clear & final. She goes forward to leave & her dupatta gets stuck to the 'jhallad' which in turn got stuck to his watch just like a bride's veil is tied with a knot with the groom's dupatta & they slowly take the phera. Here too Geet was going to lead & maybe Nissar will complete this tomorrow. He always connects one situation with another in the following episode. They r destined to be together, Babaji has allotted that in their future & he is giving them ample signs indicating so & thus we get our foundation of 'union of souls' embedded in their relationship.

And Nissar another fantastic touch was that 'self' dig that u took from those people when they commented about the filmy scene! Yeah even I would have commented that this scene with the 'jhallad' & stuff definitely did look filmy but that cheeky comment made me smile. U have the guts to take criticism & critique ur own work like we all do. 😃

Ok I was never for a public proposal or display of emotions but I understand why u did it here. Last time one brother did a hush up job while marrying Geet hidden from the entire society all under the wraps of dishonesty & deceit but here another brother is so bold, honest & honorable enough to declare his love openly in front of everyone. He didn't have any scruple to propose in front of the world or to make her his own by slipping the ring, (symbolising themselves to be bound by their circle of love) on her finger! That is the contrast Nissar wanted to show here & thus this public acceptance of her by Maan acknowledging his love for her! Again fabulous Nissar!

And girls be happy Nissar didn't make Maan go on his knees to apologise but he made him go down on his knees to propose, to put that ring on her finger again & this time in front of the whole world. A proper engagement they got themselves into with a social stamp. This going down on his knees by Maan I can gladly accept. 😃 And finally he will put the ring on him & Geet might put the Taveez on him!! Finally she found her soulmate that babaji has destined for her. One question Nissar can we get a Dargah episode as well on them afterall their proper journey of love started there? She realised her feelings & he too saw it in her eyes. Would love to witness that.

Overall a very nice episode Nissar & co, u made me happy today! With viewing of the episode several times I got a more clear perspective of the message put across to us by Nissar with all his symbolism!

And though it has got nothing to do with today's episode but I would request the CV's & Nissar not to change Maan's character in any way! I am being proactive here. I fell in love with the arrogant, aggressive, ruthless, no nonsense, rough & tough, unfeeling guy & though he is in love but pls keep him in his character. He shouldn't be mushy mushy all mellowed in love, even in love he has to retain his MSK qualities.

Ok now that my 'bakwaas' is over I will finally go & read all the beautiful takes of everyone. 😃

Edited by lghosh - 15 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

beagleboy

@beagleboy

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

res....if the goblins dont chew on my internet and I am still able to come online😆

Quote

MarshP

@MarshP

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#14

I'm not in the mood to bash today and I don't have a reason to either!!🥳 So, here is a lighthearted "analysis" for a lighthearted episode. 😊

The first half was very Filmy!! But the execution was good, unlike on Friday which was in the negatives.

Hide and Seek session: 😆

Geet is getting ready to leave Delhi and is at the station and everything reminds her of Maan. 😔 All positive memories about their relationship!! 👍🏼

She is leaning on a metal railing and about to leave when her dupatta gets stuck. Naturally, Geet thinks it's none other than Mr. Dupatta Lova. But no, it just stuck to the railing

But wait!! In comes Munda running calling out for Geet. (Don't kill me for saying this but checkout Maan's chest playing peek-a-boo with us.😳 Hayyyeee!! 😍😍😍Did you see that they were glistening?? 😳I'm so tempted to say OMG right know-but I won't.) 😆 Anyway...I loved the look of restlessness on Maan's face. GC, kudos to you!!

Geet sees Maan and is happy to see him there. But she is reminded of the now infamous line by Maan!! (Why oh why did you say that Maan? We spent 5 Dens trying to figure out what you meant!) 😡😆 She thinks if he wanted to stop her from leaving, then he could have done it at the conference room and decides to leave.

So Geet is standing 10 feet away from Maan and is wearing an apple green dress. But Munda can't spot her...talk about being slow and BLIND!! 🤣 Maybe GC's eye situation is affecting Maan's vision!! 🤣 I think that is a completely plausible explanation. Don't you? 😳

Maan is looking for Geet by the tracks and asking people if they saw a girl. Blooper alert-Maan says did you see a girl and gestures a height of about 3 feet!! 😳🤣 Anyway, meanwhile Geet is standing about 20 feet way from him hiding behind a metal railing!! But no, Munda does not spot her again!! 😆 This boy needs glasses big time...

And then Geet and Maan are standing right behind each other and still can't sense that the other is right behind them. I guess Maan's spidey sensor receptors were being intercepted by the noise and the smells of Delhi station. 😳😆 I don't know.🤣

Geet's bag gets stolen by a couple of kids (Child thieves!! Never gets old on Indian Television👎🏼) Geet is looking for the bag and asks for help from a group of Rajastani dudes. They were talking about something getting stolen. I wasn't really paying attention here; I was truly distracted by the costumes. 😳 Either way, I felt the whole scene was unnecessary. 🤔

The kids look through the bag and find the TAVEEZ!!!!!!!!!!!(The taveez is back baby!!🥳🥳🥳) And they throw it on the ground!! 😔 Maan picks up the TAVEEZ!!!! 😃 (GC's expressions were awesome) 👍🏼. He looks around and sees that the kids have a bag and goes through it and finds the hideous palak paneer dress he gifted Geet 🤢. Blooper Alert!! Maan has a FB of Geet's imagination!! 😳🤣 It was good to depict that Maan does not support the child thieves. 👍🏼

Then Maan runs towards the tracks and sees that Geet's train has already left. Maan is shattered!! 😔He has FBs of Geet! And, drum roll please''.Maan cried!!!!! 😭 😭GC's expressions were awesome. Maan starts walking away and sees white roses and is immediately reminded of Geet!! 😔

Maan is all Nakul 😆, aka depressed, and then he hears a girl's voice. It is none other than GEET!! (I was maha shocked!)😲😳 She is giving the kids a lecture about stealing and how it's bad!! Geet in mommy mode was very cute. 😊 Maan's face lights up like a Christmas tree when he sees her. 😃

Maan says "Geet" and his voice almost cracks! Geet looks up and they have a 15 second Mahi-less ghooring session. 👍🏼 Geet turns around and runs.👎🏼 Maan follows close behind.👍🏼 Geet runs into a kid and almost falls. But she doesn't. As usual, SuperMaan 😲 comes to the rescue. 🤣🤣And a cheap looking Christmas decoration garland falls on them. 😲🤣

Then the REAL episode starts!!!

Maan and Geet are staring at each other with the silver garland obstructing their view and Mahi impairing our hearing 😡🤣. Did you notice that Maan was holding Geet by her waist!!😳 Munda is very phast! 👍🏼 Geet is trying to get out of the garland but Maan is still staring at Geet. 😳

And then Dev-Meera scene...only thing I'm going to say is Perneet Chauhan is a good actress!! Others, not so much!! 🤣🤣🤣

Back to Maan and Geet. Maan tells Geet that she can never go away from him. I loved how confident he was when he said that to her. Geet asks why he came now...Maan says "Tumhare Bina Main Jeen Nahi Sakta"!!!! And the camera pans to Geet...And she is covered in the Christmas garland and looked like a silver chicken!! 🤣

Back to the dialogue...Maan apologizes to Geet and tells that it was his fault thinking that she was deceiving. That it was his fault as he thought she betrayed him... Maan says her past doesn't make any difference to him and all that matters is her future now and he wants to become a part of her future.

And then he said, "Geet, tum is ek angooti ke saath, kisi ki saari duniya piche chod ke aagayi thi". This line was brilliant 👏 and trying to explain it would destroy it. So I'm going to just enjoy it! Gurmeet was very good in this scene!!

During this conversation Maan is gently removing the garland from Geet. Hayye, Maan keeps practicing to take things off Geet!! Someone can't wait for C-night!! ☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️

All seems well until the Rajastani dude comes in with his "Bhai...Bhai.."and ruins it!!! 😡 Geet gets spooked and turns around to leave. But she can't because her dupatta is stuck the garland which is stuck to Maan's watch. Geet turns around and Maan gives Geet a look that says I told you can't leave me! 😃 This scene was good except for the Rajastani dudes who were OTT and simply annoying.😡

Precap: Maan on one knee proposing and people clapping. The public proposal is fine because that will keep Geet from running. But the clapping is OTT. But we don't know the whole scene. Eagerly waiting for tomorrow.

GC and the last dialogue were brilliant!!! DD was also no less. There were few minor dubbing and editing issues, but not colossal ones.

Overall: 8 /10

Edited by Marsha_Patel - 15 years ago

Quote

Poli.Geek

@Poli.Geek

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#15

Every Rose has a thorn, for today's Episode this is the Song

Look into the future where would it be
Space between the lives whatever will I see yah
How long will I wander before I really know
What I'm here to do and where I have to go

Guess I'm coming home
Yeah you know I'm coming home someday
You know I'm coming home
I'm coming home some way

There you are my shining start
Can you remember who you are
The role that you play from day to dayayayay
You know it's not know it's not the only way

Still I'm coming home
Yeah you know know I'm coming home someday
The futures brighter now it's not so far away
dodododododododododo
Guess I'm coming home I'm coming home some way

But still I'm coming home,
Yeah you know I'm coming home someday
The futures brighter now it's not so far away

It's right around the corner
Just around the corner, oh no
Just around the corner, oh no no no ho
Just around the corner, oh no no
Just around the corner, yeah

Song: Look into the future
Artist: Journey

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICbGFXmVh8E[/YOUTUBE]

Edited by Poli.Geek - 15 years ago

Quote

Poli.Geek

@Poli.Geek

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#16

My munda was good today, take that all you haters 🤣 🤣 🤣

@Rhea...Thank you for making my life simpler but putting your entire take in points and dividing the 😃

Loves-
1. Yes Ms. Taveez is back, she is so glad that she is back with Maan, after all she has been trying for the last few weeks to get to him, ever since Geet took her from the attic. 😡 Finally success.
2. MSK's dialogs- straight and precise, no beating around he bush, loved how he just looked into her eyes and told her exactly what he need to tell her. 😉
3. Clothing was okay, would have preferred the shirt without the white bands on the sleeves. But he looked good, his hair was styled high, just like it used to be in HP. Now they just need to trim his beard and I will me a happy happy person.😛
4. The Flash backs, I want to meet the person who choose them, not to congratulate them but to yell at them, since when do we have flashbacks of others thoughts. Yes, we are in magical Maneetland, but it just isn't possible. Unless the show CVs know something I don't 😕
5. Arre!! every time I think he will shed a few tears I am left disappointed, the love of your life is gone and all you have is one tear, two or three would have been better. But, I guess I have to be happy, atleast he cried. 👏
6. MSK's expressions were really good today, I in particular liked when Geet is walking away after he has bared his soul and the decoration is stuck to her dupatta and his watch, He looks at his watch with suck intensity and then at her, as it to say, I came, I fought, I conquered. Victory is mine. Very MSK.
7. Thank God, I was tired of seeing the Nanga brothers show, when I intend to watch Geet.
8. GC's acting on Friday was bakwas, but an actor is only as good as the script, the director, the audio guy and the camera man. Today they proved as you said, give the actors good Material and they will excel.

Likes-
1. Execution was good, the hide and seek game a little too long, he can sense her presence in the office, but he can't sense her right behind him 😕
2. The kids a big thumbs down, stealing, what!!! I am glad though that Maneet spoke against theft. Samaj Seva, good good 👍🏼
3. Yes..MSK publicly telling Geet he loves her, big deal. Very unlike Donkey who did everything in the secret. It will be a big things when Geet has to differentiate between the two brothers. 😛
4. Deveera scene..loved Meera's reaction. I don't expect much from Dev, but I do from Meera, I don't know why, but I am looking forward to seeing what she does next.
5. Really the cheapy tinsle was a like for you. Geet could have bumped into the lady selling flowers and it could have been real flower garlands, instead of Christmas deco.. 🤢 But I liked Maan removing it.. 😍
6. Not looking forward to MSK on his knees in public, but it is gonna happen, Polki not happy 😡

Dislikes-
I think I already mentioned my concerns. Crowds are inevitable in India, after all the population is Maha, so I guess although filmy it is reality. Also people always love a show, be it lovers reuniting, or fighting.

What the future hold no one knows, for know lets just enjoy the present.

Good take.
_________________________________________________________________________

@Darlunia...Yes, the episode was bilkul filmy and they are not going to stop there, they are gonna make my munda get on his knees 😡

Kids stealing, a big no!no! But ateast Maneet did a public service announcement against theft so that is good.

When she was talking about signs, she wasn't talking about signs from Babaji, she was talking about Maan. When she was trying to stay away from him, he kept on giving her signals that he wanted her close, and when she finally tells him the truth and wants to be with him, he sends her signals that he wants her far from him. That one stupid line on Friday has put crazy thoughts in her head.

Yes, once again, I love you so much it hurts, Maan's reaction was good, I always want more tears but I will settle for one. Him remembering her reminding his own words to him, was really good. And Geet's reactions was good too.

You can run, you can hide, I am gonna find you..ready or not here I come. Maan running behind Geet. Good, and finally being able to say what is in his heart, loved each and every dialog, except the last one about her leaving behind the ring and leaving behind someone's life. I think they messed it up. He should have said that by leaving the ring behind you inadvertently took my life with you. But I guess they had to make it more filmy since it wasn't filmy enough.

Deveera, hated Dev loved Meera. Loved how she reacted, loved how you could see all her trust on him evaporate with every word he spoke. I am looking forward to seeing what Meera has to offer. I hope not support to Donkey.

You too with symbolism with the cheap tinsle. I guess we all see what we want to, I am sure others will appreciate your perspective on Maan removing all hardships that might fall on Geet. I would have preferred real flowers, she could have bumped into the flower seller, who would have been magically carrying garlands.

Predictable yet joyous to watch, Maan and Geet were good, GC and Drashti excelled being Maan and Geet.

Looking forward to tomorrow. Nice analysis.
_________________________________________________________________________

@Cute...Never mind if you can't describe your feelings in words, you do an excellent job describing them through your VMs. Loved the one you posted with your take. Perfect song for the situation too.

In my opinion the chupa chupi ka khel was little too long and a little unbelievable, it would have been better if she were on the train, specially as soon as he walks in her dupatta is stuck and she is literally in front of him with her dupatta like a Green flag giving him the go ahead and he very conveniently doesn't see her. 😕

Yes! me happy too that munda cried, I would have liked more than one tear, but I will take what I can get, I have been asking for tears for so long and finally, my wish was granted.

The bacha log, I don't know I am not sure about that, stealing a big no, no. It would have had been better if she has left it behind or if someone else had stolen it and they had just found the bag. But again, it reflects poverty as you said, so I will let it go.

GC was perfect as Maan today, the eyes, oh! the eyes. Awesome expression of emotions, the look of relief that she hasn't left, the look of confusion as she starts to walk away, the look of determination as he runs after her, the look of love and sorrow as he apologies to her and tells her he wants to be with her. The look of disbelief as she once again starts to walk away from him and finally the look of victory when she stops because she is once again stuck to him by something. His signalling to her through his eys, run as you may but you can't separate from me.

The dialogs were really good. Short and precise.

The flashbacks, I know how you love flashbacks, but can someone tell the editor that you cannot have someone else's thoughts in your flashbacks. Other than that no complaints.

Deveera scene was good from the perspective that Meera's acted really well and her reactions to his unforgivable actions were perfect. You could see the disbelief and disgust in her face. Dev, it seems just wanted to dump his guilt onto someone else to make himself feel better, after all I don't really think he cares for anyone else but himself. He doesn't care for strangers, he doesn't care for his wife, no matter how horrible she is, else he wouldn't have slept with Geet and he doesn't care for his friend.

Maan on his knees me not happy but I have to give a few to gain a few.

Nice analysis.
_________________________________________________________________________

@Adits...Flashbacks were good, as you said something original, we also needed to see just how much Maan has seeped into her being, that would justify her later saying that she couldn't leave without the Taveez. 😃

Dude Dupatte ki toh baat hi mat karo, he runs into the station, she is right in front of him, her green dupatta, giving signals like a green flag and he doesn't see her? What? Anyways I thought it was funny how in the office he feels her presence but when she is right behind him on the platform he cant feel her. 😆

Yes, finally someone who says, Geet got Maan wrong, I hated the line, he could have stopped me in the conference room if he wanted, munda wasn't allowed to speak and he followed her home and she decided to avoid him and not hear what he had to say by jumping out the window. Anyhoo, munda is nothing but persistant, he is here and ready to bare (his soul I mean 😳)

Munda will do anything for kudie, which means supporting bad deeds, bribing children, Tsh! Tsh! Tsh!, MSK. But atleast he told them chori was bad. And yes Ms. Taveez is back where she belongs. She is so happy.

Maan in tears, Yes!! Finally. Polki is very happy. Again will someone tell the editors that you cannot see other's thoughts in your flashbacks.

Maan's eyes were so expressive today, relief, hurt, pain, sorry, regret, love, everything could have been understood by just looking into his eyes, but he decided to tell kudie what he felt. That too without riddles. 👏 Loved his apology and him telling her he wanted to spend the future with her. Short and precise, so MSK.

Deveera, liked the scene just because of Meera. I don't know the actresses' name but she was perfect in the scene, she should disbelief and disgust so well at what Dev was saying, her reaction was great. Dev once again expressionless, no guilt could be seen on his face and he blamed it on NT. 😡 It was almost he was just trying to burden his guilt onto someone else's shoulders. I don't know why but I am looking forward to seeing what Meera does next.

Maan getting down on his knees in public, me not happy, but I guess Munda has to do whatever he can to get Kudie back. Atleast he wasn't on his knees begging for forgiveness.

As always your take is always fun to read, love the emoticons.
_________________________________________________________________________

@Geet...Thanks for the poem. Don't even start with the dupatta, as soon as he walks into the station, you can clearly see that she is right in front of him, her dupatta like a green flag giving him the green signal and yet conveniently he doesn't see her 😕

Liked Geet's flash backs, it showed exactly how much Maan has seeped into her being, they showed his importance to her, which then justifies her not wanting to leave without the taveez.

I guess we have to agree to disagree, Geet did misunderstand him. Even if what he said was from his heart, he misunderstood the meaning behind the words. But my munda is there to clear up all the wrong faymi. 😳

Chupa Chupi very filmy and in the office he can sense her from far away but at the station he can't when she is right behind him 🤣 🤣 You are so positive, love it. Everything is symbolic. No wonder I call you the symbolism queen. Love it.

Ms. Taveez very very happy that she is back with whom she rightfully belongs. Congo Shongo..

The kids stealing the bag, Polki not happy, it would have been nice if someone else had stolen it and then thrown it when they found nothing and the kids were just going through it once they found it. I don't like seeing kids stealing, personal preference I guess. I am glad though Maneet did a public service announcement saying that stealing was bad.

Me not going to go into symbolism since no one can do it better than you, plus I have no talent for it, other than to make fun of it. So I don't think its fair for me to say anything.

But those eyes, expressed everything from disbelief over missing the train she was on, hurt and loss when he thinks she is gone, regret and sorrow for his behavior towards her, relief when he finds her, love and expectation when she looks at him, confusion when she runs from him, determination when he runs after her, love and regret when he apologizes to her, disbelief as she walks away once again from him and finally victory as if to tell her you can't escape that easily as he looks at his watch and her simultaneously.

I would have preferred if it were real flowers instead of the decoration, Geet could have bumped into the flower girl who would have been conveniently carrying garlands. It was a little unbelievable for me that the decoration fell out of a closed bad. But I will let it go as seeing removing the stuff off of Geet was too good. He has a talent for removing stuff, first the jewelery and not this. 😍

The dialogs from Maan perfect, just want I wanted, straight and precise. No beating around the bush for MSK. This is what I feel, and this is what I want.

Deveera, Dev blaming NT for everything, but I am glad that Meera reacted the way she did, I would have had been Maha upset if she had said it's okay we can fix it or something like that. I loved her expression of disbelief and disgust. I don't know why but I want to see what she does next. No need to be sorry, what he did was despicable and he should not have any redemption for it.

The whole confession thing being filmy, but it is true na, where there are people and someone is making a tamasha, crowds will gather, whether to see a fight or I guess in this case see someone profess his love. Can't be avoided, specially in a country with such a large population and where most people take the train. It would have been weird if the platform was empty.

Overall a great take, I promise I read the whole thing, from the color significance to the baccha log significance. Thank you for see the positive in everything, but your kudie misunderstood my munda.
________________________________________________________________________[

@Doodle...We love you, and we are proud to have a friend like you. That being said, lets get down to business.

Loved your take, can't really go into detail since you write in so much detail, I am sure blue is glad that you clarified the Dhoka line for us. All of us had so many interpretations of it. Most of them coming from our personal experiences, but that is what makes this den fun, us arguing for hours over a line or two.

Also agree with you about the children, I was disappointed that they showed them as thieves. I would have preferred it if they had shown someone else steal it and throw ti away after not finding much in the bag and then the baccha log would go through it just out of curiosity to see if they can find something. But I guess then they wouldn't have lead Maan to Geet. However I am glad that Maneet decided to condemn their actions.

I would have preferred to see real flowers fall on Maneet, but I guess what is done is done, I just found it a little unbelievable that the jalaria jumped out of a closed package, it would have made more sense if Geet had bumped into the lady selling flowers who would have conveniently had garlands in her basket.

Thanks for googling you brain and once again showing where the vachaans were reflected, a little too much for my brain to handle but that is why I am so glad that you stated them in you take.

Loved Maan's dialogs, short and precise, to the point, no you look wonderful, no you make my heart sing, no I love you, just to the point. I am sorry, I am sorry I didn't believe you, I am sorry I thought you lied and betrayed me, I want to live your life with you, your past does not matter only your future. I can't live without you.

I don't know what else to say, your take is always wonderful. Thanks.
___________________________________________________________________________

@Vandana...Aww, you brought back a song from Kishore D to talk about today's episode. You speak the language of my heart, I find a song for every episode, but it is always nice to see someone else who too loves music.

Geet recalling key moments with Maan while looking at things in the station, nice and sweet, but I think she was wrong when she felt that he wanted to push her away with his words. She misunderstood his words, I guess her wound is still fresh since she keeps on hiding from him. What about his wounds, never mind today was about him making amends for his actions, so I will let it go.

Oh! don't get me started on that one line from Geet, if he wanted to stop me, he could have in the conference room. Girl you didn't allow him to speak, he said 5 words and you were done. He followed you home to talk to you and you jumped out the window. I have talked about this enough so I am not even going to bore you with it.

Loved how you said all three looking for something that they lost, I was for a second thinking what is she talking about and then you said country folk looking for the jaleria 🤣 🤣 🤣

One thing I don't understand, in the office he can feel her presence yet in the station he can't feel her presence when she is right behind him 😲

Oh! Yeah!! Ms. Taveez is back and with exactly whom she belongs. The Taveez was never Geets to keep, it was meant for her humsafar, Geet no matter how much you try to hold on the the Taveez it will always find its way to Maan.

The baccha log, a little OTT, I have one complaint, I didn't like that they showed them as thieves. But it was fixed when both Maan and Geet voiced their opinions about stealing being bad.

Maan ki train station chod he chali gayi. He cried, yeah...I have been waiting for so long to see him shed real tears. Him seeing Geet after thinking he had lost her, priceless. There was so much joy in them. Geet running, I don't think she is ever gonna stop running, at this time away from Maan, later behind the kids. Iski zindagi me dorna likha hain.

The jaleria was a bit cheap looking for me, I wish it were real flowers that feel on Geet. It would make more sense for Geet to bump into the flower seller who would conveniently have garlands in her basket, than have the jaleria magically jump out of a closed package with just one bump.

Maan's confession was too good, total MSK style. You can't escape Geet, I won't let you. He tells her I told you before no matter how hard you try you can never leave me. Also the rest of the dialogs were short and precise, he tells her exactly what is in his heart without frills. No sweet talk (unlike his creepy brother), just I am sorry, I was wrong, I can't live without you, I want to be a part of your life. Oh, so sweet.

Filmy scene hai!! funny yet OTT.

Maan on his knees, Polki not happy, but I guess I win some, I loose some. Atleast he didn't get on his knees to apologize.

Nice take..
_________________________________________________________________________

Edited by Poli.Geek - 15 years ago

Quote

zarmina asad

@zarmyna

Navigator

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#17

y isnt any1 uploading it on youtube??

Quote

@-RD-

Stunner

+ 9

Posted: 15 years ago

#18

Reserved😉

Love, like a river, will cut a new path
whenever it meets an obstacle.

Jaane jaan dhoondta phir raha .......followed by ruk jaana ruksaana hum se do baatein kar ke chali jaana...followed by I am never gonna let u go😳.....sums up the epi doesnt it ....another song that came to my mind when Maan was saying all those luvly lines to her was Chura ke Dil mera goriya chali ....paagal hua deewana hua .....

I'm sorry for the times you cried,
and the loneliness you felt inside.
I'm sorry for being unfair

And showing to you that I didn't care
I'm sorry for the love you missed;
the one moment where I thought I'd lose you made me realize this.

I'm sorry I wasn't there to show,
the deepest love you'll ever know.
I'm sorry for the empty days,
and the stresses that you still yet pay.

I'm sorry for the way I left;
I've never felt so much regret.
I'm sorry for the heart I broke,
that shattered with the words I spoke.

I'm sorry for the empty arms;
you fell into when times were hard.
I'm sorry for the days that passed,
Our love now will surely last.
I'm sorry it took so long to vow,
to love you forever here and now.

Now I have said all that was in my heart for you

Hope u'll realize my feelings for you were always true

So I am here on my knees, asking for you to come back to me

And give me that final chance to prove my love for thee😉

I dont know but him being on his knees could mean that he is putting himself below her ...considering than she always thought of herself as being inferior to him bec of her past ...he is now placing her not as his equal but somebody superior to him and that she is now like the crown on his head.............also there was the official yet unofficial gathbandhan....so loads of meaningful symbolisms...as well some really good dialogues by Maan ...GC you rock and so does the person who wrote those dialogues

Edited by rdfan - 15 years ago