#*Devil's Den#* Lets Be FRIENDS! [Index at Bottom] - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

58.3k

Users

63

Likes

6.1k

Frequent Posters

SuhaniSonia thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
Reserved!! I won't be able to edit for a long time today so just going to put up points for now.
My 'mahiii' was back!! 😃
Such a sweet family bonding scene. 😳
I know the friendship scene was cute and it was needed for the Parineeta story to go further but I think it was out of place in the flow of the recent episodes. It was a little cheesy to say lets be friends and then chase each other in the following scene. Also Maan's character is changing a bit too much too quickly for my liking. In his thoughts he called her 'bechari'!! 😳 Its just my POV!! (Nothing you all will say will change my mind. 😆) I already know most of you will disagree!! Just don't bash me. 😆
That said, I love the end!! Dusham dusham fight to come!! Yay Maan!! 😍
Overall, still a fantastic episode. 9/10!!
Edited by SuhaniSonia - 15 years ago
lghosh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
Trying to recover from the phaaassst episode, will try to make some sense before penning down anything!! Pheww!!!
Ok I will try to keep it short today!! The episode to me looked like a storm just blew by with so many things happening all at once. By the time I tried to register the episode got over!! Yeah call me slow! 😃 I really wanted to ask the CV's why this rush, why the sudden urge to hurry up the story, I am having problems with the pace nowadays, the pace of story telling. So kindly please take a deep breath & slow down. HP over in 4 days!!
Ok with that over I will get to the episode. Geet's juvenile methods finally worked & Rasika came down from her high horse & finally assented to let go of the case! Well good for all of us! But what was it all about? She kept on giving threats of putting MSK behind bars & for what, because he cancelled a deal?? Doesn't deal fall through day in & day out? Do all the people land up in prison?
Anyway the following scene I liked because I saw Maan acting just like himself. I remembered Dadi's explanation to NT, the difference between 2 brothers. Where Dev is an escapist from any difficult situation Maan on the other hand face them boldfacedly & accept the challenges as they come. He did just that today, went straight ahead to meet the angry mob & cooled them down! Good character consistency there! I know the CV's will be raising their eyes in boredom when they will read about character consistency from me but what to do, its extremely important to me in any work of fiction.
So Maan already is performing all the duties of a doting husband! Another vow here signified, he wanted to make Geet happy & thus brought a part of her happiness to her because she can't go to achieve her share of glory!
The sibling scene was very touching, at least the younger generation feels what the older generation very conveniently has forsaken. I am surprised how come parents have simply given up on their kids so much so that they don't even think about her!! How can that be?? But loved the bonding the young generation shares & Maan's happy look to see Geet so glad & emotional. What I liked here was how he understood what Geet was trying to ask when she looked up at him & he gently said no one else is here. Their eyes r conversing now! 😍
Next segment, well, it will be difficult to digest & understand that why now she is offering & asking for his friendship when all of us feel this stage is long past over! To justify I will here think from Geet's point of view because looking at Maan he is definitely long past that stage! The way he paused & looked at her with that smirk said a lot! 😆 Must be wondering he got a nice naive slow girl who will take centuries to reach to his 'baba Adam ka zamane ka soch aur kartoot'! 😆 Ok jokes apart, from Geet's side I know where she was coming from. She is after all a village girl & her thinking will be related to basic feelings & emotions. She handled Rasika in her own inane way showing she is not like a city bred girl like Pari who had an unique way to find out about their love for each other. And in this instance I will say CV's u stuck to basic character consistency. She was grateful to Maan for all he did with Rajji & Tito & what more can she offer to him other than her friendship, a part of her!! So from this angle I think she was ok. She felt cribbing with him all the time makes her restless & so its high time she makes peace with him & thus this offering of an olive branch!
2ndly also I think the CV's r telling us the importance of true friendship here in any relationship. Am I right Nissar?? Even between the audience & the creatives a friendship can exist where one shows something & the audience is supposed to understand & pick it up intelligently! They r trying to convey friendship is something very strong & doesn't fade away just like that & in a friendship one is open & free to say or do or to confide & understand which not necessarily is in every relationship be it parents & kids, Husband & wife, between siblings & in any other relationship we can think of. So maybe they r basing Geet & Maan's relationship on friendship now so that tomorrow when the time comes Geet can freely tell Maan about her past without any inhibition & Maan will also accept her as she is without making any judgement. So this friendship today was the foundation stone of tomorrow! Hope I am right here Nissar!
But I will say the dialogs were a little cliche! And I loved Maan's attitude in this right from the beginning to end. He completely gave the right over to Geet to call the shots. He didn't want to push her into anything, he let her have the comfort to call him her friend & openly accepted her decision & suggestion. He is slowly backing off giving her that space & freedom & not overpower her by encroaching in her personal space that we were witnessing all these months. He is letting her to make the call to come to his life instead of pursuing her himself like he did earlier. And also he wanted her to be happy after the emotional turmoil she faced in the last 2 days. His care & love remains intact & he is now the changed mellowed MSK who is thinking about his actions & reactions, curbing his temper, controlling his taunts & remarks. And he is trying this consciously so that Geet becomes more comfortable with him. All said & done I don't want MSK to change even in love! I love & adore him for the way he is, arrogant, aggressive, ruthless, proud, stubborn & bold & even in love I want to see him with these qualities! Yeah crazy me I know!! 😆
Next segment was a little juvenile, bickering over nothing! And then Geet's comfort level has grown so much with Maan around. It was a nice touch there showing how she pulls him by the hand without a second thought to take him inside that forsaken house or ruins. She didn't feel odd to hold & bring him in like that. "Chhote sahar ka soch' was not there then! 😃 Both r growing in their relationship, that is what is portrayed here.
Again their small squabble not much of value went on! And this time Geet helped Maan for a change to come up, a symbolism Maan is all the time rising in love! All his life he led a solitary life taking care of himself but today he has someone to share his life with & in this he is achieviing a higher level peace, satisfaction & happiness.
The last segment totally filmy & a little over the top for me! I fail to understand why were the villagers against Geet? She didn't do anything to them, then why?? So these people were Brij's friend who were all willing to avenge Geet for what she did to Brij?? Again if this is so, wow, what a friend Brij must be to inspire this feel in his friends!! Amazing 'dostana' I would say! 😃
And Maan's frantic search for Geet & how he slowly gets worried from being mad was good to watch. And he knows every little aspect of Geet be it her nature, personality, mood, jewelry, dress ......everything!! He knew her anklet, her earring & obviously her dupatta.......after all its the only possession of Geet that loves to entangle itself on Maan! 😆
Ok so tomorrow will wait for some MSK type of action back in the ground of HP!! And Guru again looking very tired & exhausted all throughout! He needs sleep, rest & food, big time!
To me this episode was not out of the ordinary or anything but an ok episode with a new phase built in their relation which is making it all the more stronger!
Ok done, Doodle shoot away! Will go & read ur take now!! And I know it will be awesome like everyday! And I am really thankful to have u as a good friend guiding me with others day in & day out with ur explanations, hints & suggestions, here offering my hand in frienship!! Shake it pal!! 😃
Edited by lghosh - 15 years ago
sailaa thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
So, here is a question for the experts. Why is Channi's bro so pissed at Geet. Uska kya bigada Geet ne. Be-izzati to hui Geet ke family ki na??

EDITED:::

Sorry! didn't notice that I posted on page 2.
Edited by sailaa - 15 years ago
rivaanvira thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
*clink*
reserved...
*******************
Edited...
*******************
Color Coded
Blue - My comments
Italicized Magenta - Dialogues
Red - My complaints

What should I say today… was I glad the episode was trying to stay consistent with few scenes here or there… or should I say the episode was too fast since they want Friday to be the truth-revelation day…??? 🤢

I am glad that starting Monday they have shown progress in building blocks for the truth… i.e. Monday was good for laying the foundation… Tuesday for laying the 1st block… and today another one…!!! 👏

But at the same time I am disappointed with the quality… don't know if it's because my expectations are sky high… Brij-Maan's dramatic encounter and the dramatic truth… or CVs are compromising with the story due to external pressures…!!! 🤢

Anyways here are some good-bad words as per each scene…

Scene 1 – Tug of Expressions

Yesterday M nodded and G obliged… today G nodded and M obliged… That's the unsaid understanding we've all been seeing… and I guess that's the understanding expected out of a true relationship… Way to go CVs for showing such subtle, although impactful gestures…

Yesterday G was all out to save M (his reputation), today M was all out to save G (her life)… That's the support sought in a true relationship…

Scene 2 – Siblings Day

It was good to see M dutiful enough to get her siblings to meet… this goes to show how much he is willing to do to see a smile on her face…😭

Her bonding was emotional… but the effects of that bonding were worth watching on his face… He smiled when she smiled… He was disappointed when she was disappointed that no one else was there… Shocked to know her family has moved on… He was the mirror-image of her emotions…

Scene 3 – Friendship Day


Alright… here is where I have a complaint… where things have been so in-sync without saying them… where head nodding is understood… Did she really to have say it out loud that too explicitly… 'Can't we friends?' I mean they could've executed it differently… Maybe we are spoilt with non-clich dialogues…

The fact that they showed friendship as a base for any strong relationship was a good move… Friendship is always the pioneer of any flourishing relationship … It is unbiased of any emotions… unbound by any commitment… It moulds itself into any relationship… that of a parent-child, siblings, or lovers…

The best part of this scene – M neither accepts it first nor rejects it… He conveniently leaves it on her to decide… since she is the one who has always called the shots of this relation… :-P Office mein I am the boss… Bahar you are the boss… indirectly giving her the authority of their relationship…

Few things worth noticing here were G's expressions – her trust in him… Earlier she had always trusted him with her life since he was her savior… But from today onwards she'll be able to trust him with her secrets as well… M's expressions – satisfied that atleast she gave into something… and knows one thing for sure that she will slowly-n-steadily give in further too… the true businessman MSK… knows where he can make the most and the least…
👏

'Bechari' !!! Why on earth that…??? It symbolizes weakness… sympathy… yesterday he empathized today 'bechari'… CVs don't kill the characterization with such words...

Anyways moving on – As I said earlier… he is ready to go to any length to see a smile on her face… He even went out of his normal character to make her smile… so unlike MSK…

Scene 4 – Let's play games in Tabela… First 'Tracking' & then Hide-n-Seek

'Mein aapko yahan ghar basane ke liye nahi keh rahi hoon…' & 'Bhagwaan ne aapko 2 aankhen di hai na… to iska istamal kijiye…' I just love the way she mouths such dialogues... 😆 😃 😛

'…Doston se kuch chupaya nahi jata… unse share karte hai…' True… and that's exactly where he is leading through friendship… the reason for her rejection… the reason related to her past which we all including him are awaiting…

Love it when he goes wrong… comes back to normal MSK colors… and then finally giving into her help…

Scene 5 – I'll do anything for you…

That's the song by Meatloaf… 'I'll do anything for you… anything you want me to…' apt in this case… he is ready to do anything for her irrespective of her situation…


Few things that I didn't like here… When had he seen her payal earlier to recognize it now… Second step and he finds her earring… although she deliberately throws her earring elsewhere… magnetic effect I think…!!!

Back to scene – He finds the dupatta on the ground and picks it up mouthing 'Mein tumhe kuch nahi hone doonga…' Yep true he is the one who will protect her honor and save her too… Her knight in black shirt…!!!

Precap – *Clink* MSK holding the sword…


Overall the episode was alright… Glad to see the CVs are keeping the characters in place by maintain their consistencies… DD & GC as usual were in form… Today the dialogues didn't have the punches unlike yesterday…

Can't wait to see the next 2 episodes… with mixed emotions… I am excited… But disappointed that it won't be Brij-Maan interaction… no sword clinking between the two hotties… Now that Brij won't be there and none of the HP family was there… the climatic-truth also won't be that effective either… Oh well… I'd say something is better than nothing…

Adios Devils… 😈 😈 😈

Enjoy the takes and spams…!!! 😊
Edited by sanam912 - 15 years ago
adits7 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#15
finally
Thanx gou..hugzz
nt a detailed analysis frm my side..jus some pointers...
1)as most of us hd predicted...dt fasion disaster..... style ki dushman ....🤣Ms Rasika Rathod backed off.....maan raising dt hand 2 stop d chak de phatte..hoshairpur waasis...reminded me of SARKAR...d way SARKAR(Amitabh Bacchan) greets d crowd gathered in front of his bunglow..😆😆😆..
2)thou she knew dt d matter ws serious ...geet kept on wid cribbing n continue wid dos unending conversations n complaints 2 babaji...😕😆.
3)so sweet of maan 2 think fr geet so much.....😳...did he hv lump in his throat wen geet met her siblings...he gulped it dwn.....awww....😳😳
4)rajji.....yippeee..😃😃..n thou my expectations wer higher..m happy dey showed raajji meeting geet scene.....i wantd 2 c dis 1...👍🏼.
n y hd Dev called maan???2 ask him if geet ws his secretary......???...😕...wat ws Dev gonna reply or ask 1ce maan hd said yes???..😕...nyway guess v get 2 c Delhi frm Monday...😕😊..
5)car scene...little OTT.....bt can let it go......yes d smile looked thodu gurmeetish..bt chk fr sumthin mre on pt 7......
n no mahhhiii....gala phadoingg..😆😆😆..gud...i lkd d subtle 1...😃..
....maan said saare faisale tumne kiye hai....chalo ek faisala karne ka mauka toh mujhe diya......hsnt geet bein doin wat MSK wants...or at times he leaves no choice fr her bt 2 choose wat pleases him....😕😕.....
friendshp......yeh toh pyaar ki shuruwati step hai???......
6)wen geet hold maan's hand n took him 2 dt tabela......no OTT der..maan mus hv surely liked it.....no slow motion or mahii...gud.😃....
7)d tabela scene.......wen i saw dis scene..esp MSK.......only thing dt striked ws...Hrithikish..😆.
chk :
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGsk37leW0w[/YOUTUBE]
here :
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UYjbPu1m38&feature=related[/YOUTUBE]
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AYwXOWYrqs[/YOUTUBE]
der r mre frm dhoom2...bt cant find d videos..ll post dem...😕..gurmeet does imitate hrithik fr sure....
8)i found dt maan findin geet's belongin scene a bit funny...😆😆...running around same places agn n agn.😆😆..
editin...👎🏼...n wat wid dt shakky screen durin d brij frnds scene...wer dey call brij......camera wrk...👎🏼.👎🏼.
9) maan saving geet...can v expect d partial truth revealation by friday????guess yes...😕👍🏼.
lookin frwd fr d epis..😃.
dats it frm my side...😊.

Edited by adits7 - 15 years ago
Poli.Geek thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#16
Every Rose has a Thorn, Today's Episode has only One Song


From the mouth of the Goddess Debbie Harry to your your ears.


This is the perfect song for the entire episode.

Why?

1. Geet gets Rasika to agree, like she said yesterday if not one way (apology) than the other (angry village mob)

2. Maan gets Geet to change her mood; one way (by trying to console her) or another (by reuniting her with her siblings).

3. Maan gets Geet to move their relationship forward by letting her make the decision. (I think it was reverse psychology), one way (aggressive lover boy) but another (giving her the choice)

4. The Talvar Possy getting Geet after she had given them the slip the first time, one way (the failed attempt with Brij) or another (this time, without Brij)

5. Maan getting Geet after she hides; one way (not finding her) but another (finding her jewelery)


So what do you all think? Good Choice?



One way or another I'm gonna find ya
I'm gonna getcha getcha getcha getcha
One way or another I'm gonna win ya
I'm gonna getcha getcha getcha getcha
One way or another I'm gonna see ya
I'm gonna meetcha meetcha meetcha meetcha
One day, maybe next week
I'm gonna meetcha, I'm gonna meetcha, I'll meetcha
I will drive past your house
And if the lights are all down
I'll see who's around

One way or another I'm gonna find ya
I'm gonna getcha getcha getcha getcha
One way or another I'm gonna win ya
I'll getcha, I'll getcha
One way or another I'm gonna see ya
I'm gonna meetcha meetcha meetcha meetcha
One day, maybe next week
I'm gonna meetcha, I'll meetcha

And if the lights are all out
I'll follow your bus downtown
See who's hanging out

One way or another I'm gonna lose ya
I'm gonna give you the slip, a slip of the lip or another
I'm gonna lose ya, I'm gonna trick ya
One way or another I'm gonna lose ya
I'm gonna trick ya trick ya trick ya trick ya
One way or another I'm gonna lose ya
I'm gonna give you the slip

I'll walk down the mall
Stand over by the wall
Where I can see it all
Find out who ya call
Lead you to the supermarket checkout
Some specials and rat food, get lost in the crowd

One way or another I'm gonna getcha, I'll getcha, I'll getcha getcha
getcha getcha
(Where I can see it all, find out who ya call)
One way or another I'm gonna getcha, I'll getcha, I'll getcha getcha
getcha getcha
(Where I can see it all, find out who ya call)
One way or another I'm gonna getcha, I'll getcha, I'll getcha getcha
getcha getcha
(Where I can see it all, find out who ya call)
[repeat until fade]

Song: One way or another
Artist: Blondie

here is the Youtube link for the song, remember it is really old song, most of us weren't even born when it was release - 1978. The singer is Debbie Harry and the band is Blondie. They were and are very popular, they were regulars at the famous NYC club CBGBs.

Hope you all enjoy the music.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-P9FjArlxs&feature=fvst

Enjoy

Polki


Edited by Poli.Geek - 15 years ago
Autumnn thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
Dont know what to post about the episode..😆 but now whenever I heard Mahiiiiiiii track.. I remember chillaying aatyaams saying Mahhiii dialogue from den.. and I start laughing.... 😆😆😆😆
indiaforumID thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18
Hi all,🤗 I love watching Geet. Its the best serial among sooooo many I've seen.
Poli.Geek thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#19
Okay another episode where all you analyst has so much to say. I am glad because that allows Polki to put her 2 cents in, I take that back, you have so much to say and I have so much to read.



Eis den ki ragini- Vini

I thought you said you were going to try to keep it short and sweet, if this is your short and sweet, I am fearful of finding out what long is. Anyways as the jugde and jury I am prepared to take on your analysis.

See from the very beginning we knew that RR would never fit into Maneet world. And today we got a concrete reason why. Like you said, Rat says, "One thing I cannot handle is violence." Arree, our Geet and Maan are so special that no matter where they go violence follows them. In the first scene it seemed everyone was screaming internally, Rat to Geet and Maan, Maan to Geet and Geet to her babaji. Thank you for imagining HP people accidentally cutting off each others heads while running to RAT's residence. Very funny, thankfully I didn't have to trouble my mind since you already did most of the imagining.

You know you are right, I noticed it too, but didn't make a big deal about it, but you are right it was really sweet how Maan looked at Geet for approval before accepting RR's apologetic handshake. Only after she nodded a yes, did he accept RR's apology. I think they have gotten to a state where they really care what the other is thinking. Also they won't do anything that the other does not approve off, yesterday Maan shook his head negatively as he put Geet's finger down and Geet didn't argue, she knew he didn't approve and accepted. Today Maan didn't argue with Geet's decision to accept RR's apology even though he wasn't happy. A new aspect to their relationship.

I was laughing during the scene where Maan subdues the village people, he was like a holy man who raised his hand and all the followers became quite to hear him impart some gyan. Maan totally invoking the spirit Ram.

Aww the siblings meeting, and then getting separated again. So heart wrenching. Totally cry fest. I think the pain reflected on Maan's face was two fold, one seeing Geet so sad and second maybe sadness for himself since he doesn't have a great relationship with his brothers, with one he can't seem to connect and the other is missing in action.

I know you are mad at the Handas but I think that Geet's parents are only pretending to have moved on. I think one they feel really guilt about what they let happen to Geet and are too ashamed to face her, hence they didn't come today to see her. Secondly maybe they are still afraid for Geet's life, we know that Geet's dad knows where Geet is because he asked Pinky's dad to take care of Geet and maybe they are afraid that if they let their emotions show they may unknowingly give away Geet's whereabouts. I personally would like to give atleast Geet's parents the benefit of the doubt. The others I don't care about.

Yes, Maan too has become Juru ka Gulam, he hasn't even gotten married yet and has decided to let her make all the decisions. You are right the Khurana brothers have no say in front of their significant others.

I am not even going to talk about the FRIENDSHIP bewakufi, they could have done so much to portray them giving their relationship a name, yet they made it like a precious moments scene, all that was missing was a few butterflies and flowers.

I really thought the economy was bad and that people can't really afford to be standing in Tabela's waiting for someone. First of all the way the Talwar Posse was standing, it felt like dal mein kuch kala tha, when do you actually see men standing in dark corners together. Can we say GAYYYYY. They are just sexually frustrated, I just need to tell them, boys in this day and age people like you have hope you don't need to hide in darkness. Say it loud, say it proud, 'we are here, we are queer, get over it.'

The tabela scene was cute, Geet talking about her life, Maan falling in, he should have listened to her, and the hide and seek game.

The Talwar posse getting hold of Geet and Geet like Sita, leaving clues for her Ram- Maan.

Overall funny and imaginative analysis. Saved me a lot of imagination, thanks.




Taj of the den- Anj,

I completely agree with you regarding the use of the word Bechari for Geet, totally inappropriate especially since she has proven herself to be strong, she may have been a victim of circumstance but she has risen above it. She actually went and fought to get Maan out of trouble and as Maan even accepted it, she is in-charge so why call her 'Bechari'. However, I think you were being to kind with the gift for the writers. If you are going to gift them shoes to beat themselves on their heads with, you should save the good ones and buy a pair from the dollar store.

I also have to agree with you about the cliched way the whole friendship scene was enacted. It was too little kids story book setting. When we are little we read the books on manners and how to behave with other people, you know the anti-fighting ones. Today's scene seemed that it was a Public Service Announcement against fighting. Sad as it may sound I actually like the Jai-Veeru Song sequence in Sholay, as I write this I am imagining Maneet re-enacting the sequence with Geet driving. I guess my brain has too much free space.

Sweety you are not wrong, Maan defenitely wants more than FRANSHIP, as soon as she suggested even something remotely positive she was already plotting. As you say, we could see it on his face. Munda is not as bohla as he would like kudi to believe.

Overall well said, mostly liked the visual aids.




Sab hain tuj pe sweet-Geet,

Starting your analysis with a poem, fantabulous (fantastic and fabulous together) The poem relayed exactly what was going on. Well done.

Yes, you are right today was a really sweet episode, finally we see Maan putting his ego aside and putting Geet first but letting her define their relationship or give it a new name. He definitely wants more but I think at this point he realizes that aggression did not work in winning her over so might as well try her method. Of course MSH hasn't really put his ego aside completely, we saw this when he didn't admit that he was wrong while they were having the fight, he just distracted her by telling her that he would have to accept defeat because he was scared of her. But we have to let MSK be MSK even if it is just a glimmer. And yes the friendship will bring understanding to a relationship that already has great chemistry.

Now lets discuss the symbolism. Everything you pointed out to the point, I can't really comment or elaborate more on what you said.

However I also noticed another one more thing that was symbolic in the episode. While Maan admires Geet's bond with her siblings, he is quick to hang up the call from his own brother even though Dev says that there is something important he needs to talk to MSK about. I think this was the first glimpse into the future for us. Geet is more important to Maan than Dev. It seems that from today's episode that we can conclude that Maan and Dev's relationship was never strong. This will be important when the truth comes out about Dev being the man who destroyed Geet's innocence; I refuse to say life, because Geet is strong and hasn't given up on life and the small joys that life has to offer.

Now I don't know if I made any sense but I have the habit of just writing what is on my mind. Now you can make what ever you want of it.

Overall I can only reiterate the populous voice and say awesome analysis.




Sab ko dil ka dorah dene wali- Sarirah,

I don't know how you do it, but you manage to make every analysis funny. You are right the first scene was funny, the fashion police need to fine RR for her attire, but you know what made me want to call you (with your Talwar) during the episode was when Maan is like some holy man making the villagers shant by just raising his had, nasty RR had her grubby hands on MK. Apart from Geet the only other people who have a right to touch MSK are in the den. While watching the episode I was like where is Caco, I need her with her Talwar, in total Brij estyle to teach this besharam ladki some limits.

The reunion was really emotional, I know you question how could her parents not come, I think it is because they don't have the guts to face her. They did nothing to save her, yes her father gave her a head start to get away from Brij, but really where could she have gone without any money or mode of transportation. I think that once her dad arranged her living accommodations (on the sly with Pinky's dad) in Delhi he decided to get out of her life as it was truly her life in every sense since they had already come to terms with her death when Brij came back with the 'FAKE' news that she was dead. You know what I just realized, there is a lot of fake stuff in this girl's life- fake husband, fake in-laws, fake wedding, fake fiance, fake death, etc, etc. I am sure there is more, I just can't remember it.

Lets not even start on the OTT friendship scene. You are right, I too thought that there was going to be a serious conversation, poor girl has just seen her siblings, she is happy that she saw them, but is sad that she had to once again be separated from them. She is sad that her parents didn't come and when she says I am tired of fighting with you, you think finally a nice decent conversation after such an emotionally charged scene that preceded, but we were slapped with a big 'NO', we got lets be friends. I know you know what I think about the line 'lets be friends' so I am not going to repeat it again, but it was such a disappointment.

I love your description of junglie Maan, and once again I am laughing hard, picturing Maan doing 'I Like to Move it, Move it'

Yes, the Talwar Posse is back, minus the leader- BRIJ. I know you are really sad, but we never get what we want, sorry love.

Overall as always really nice and funny analysis and once again I made it serious while analysis your analysis. Maybe I need to take some lessons from you in funny.



Pareeneta theory ki acharya- Labanya

As always a great start to your analysis, thank you for once again telling the creators and all people associted with Geet, exactly what is on your mind, in fact what is on all the den sista's minds. You are our voice and thank you for doing it so well.

Clothes, we can't call what RR was wearing clothes, more a costume, I don't know what costume event she was attending, but she was at the wrong venue. I hope in the future the costume designer keeps in mind the environment scenes are taking place in and dresses the characters appropriately. It seems that they have gotten the wrong impression that being rich mean dressing sluty. Tish! Tish! Tish!

I think many of us too were under the impression that they were friends because they way they have been behaving with each other, even before they acknowledged that they had feelings for each other, they behaved like friends with each other, they fought and made up like friends do, they trusted each other and protected each other. I guess they had to give their relationship a name which they both were comfortable with and I believe in this moment all Maan is concerned about is Geet, so if she is comfortable with being friends, so be it. Like he said, she has been deciding from the very beginning what is between them so if friendship is what she wants so be it.

I reallu enjoyed reading your explanations of how the episode included so vachaans. I can't really analyse that part because I am totally ignorant and truth be told I am learning all about them through you. Thank you so much for taking me concern into consideration and actually explaining them before you showed how they were included in the episode. I am sure that many people will appreciate this.

Now the word Bechari, oh how I hated it in today's episode. Even after she proved how strong she was they included it. The dialog would have been perfectly fine without that word. Lets see if they take your advise and stop speaking of Geet as this helpless woman. Afterall the show is supposed to show her fight for her rights. Even if it is with Maan's help, she still has to fight.

I agree with your observation that CG is acting more like CG than Maan specially when it comes to his voice modulation. Yesterday when he was talking to Geet about how strong she is, he has his Ram voice not his Maan voice. Speaking of dunning, I cannot stand when they have a totally different voice speaking for the chracters, in today's episode when Geet puts out her hand and says 'Friends', it was a totally different voice. Arrgh, it is very annoying.

I kinda liked the tabela scene, it was light and sweet, that is until the Talwar posse came into the picture, but you take the good with the bad.

Overall as always great analysis, thank you once again for explaining the vachaans you were going to talk in your analysis.





Aha moment dene wali chica- Nibiha

Yup have to agree the episode was good, the only problem I had was how the friendship scene was executed. I see your point that it was necessary because Geet needs a friend and who better than Maan. Also it is interesting what you pointed out that Geet although has feelings for Maan hasn't really allowed him the enter her heart and that there was a need to have something that was more substantial than a boss/fake mangetar relationship, hence friendship. I too noticed the look on Maan's face as soon as she said lets be friends, he seemed to be plotting something, our munda is not as innocent as he tries to portray himself. Also as you said he never said okay I will be your friend, he now wants Geet to take all the decisions regarding their relationship, make her come to him. I think it was an important that he said "whatever that has happened between us you have decided so you decide what you want to do." He is letting her know, now it is totally up to you, you already know how I feel, now you decide how you feel and if you need to start with being friends, so be it.

I think that Dev's call was important is showing the difference in relationships that Geet and Maan share with their respective siblings. One one hand Geet's siblings basically defied Darji's commands to come and see Geet, on the other hand Maan hangs up on his brother even though Dev said he needed to talk to Maan about something important. It seemed that Maan didn't want to miss even a moment of Geet's reunion with her siblings, maybe he finds in them a bond that he never shared with his siblings. We don't know what his relationship is with Vicky because he is MIA, but with Dev his relationship seems strained. I think it was also a way for the CVs to show us who exactly is more important to Maan, Geet or Dev. This may come into focus in the future.

I hope you are right about the reasons Maan thought of Geet as bechari. Cause if that wasn't the case I am sending the Talvar sista's after him.

Overall really nice analysis.





Hume pyaar se monitor karne wali chori- Gouri

Hello, I know you didn't want to go over RR scene in detail, you are right that the two of them understand each other just through their actions, that there is no need for word and when it comes for them to be against the world, they will always stand united. Did you notice, holyman Maan making all the villagers shaant by just raising his arm, and they became silent as if they were waiting for him to impart some gyan. I was on the floor during that scene.

I would love to say something about the paagh phera rasam, but I am so ignorant so all I can say is thank you for reiterating it, I know a lot of the other analysts have mentioned it, but it is nice to see it explained in different ways by each one of you.

Yes, Maan munda is very chalu, he tried the aggressive way and failed, now he is trying the passive way. Letting Geet make all the active decisions regarding their relationship. So smart. He is basically saying "you know exactly how I fee, now you decide what you want to do with that knowledge."

Really liked how you reminded us how Maan has already decided to let Geet rule his life, had forgotten the disco, actually didn't forget it, but didn't put 2 and 2 together, you are right, he let her drag him off the dance floor there without protest and today he let her once again lead him into the Tabela. Now who is the bechara?

Love your take on the actors, perfectly put, CG needs rest and they need to focus more on him being Maan rather than CG in the show. Dhrasti was really good today, I wanted to cry when I saw her cry with her siblings.

Overall really nice analysis.





Faz ke saath saath tamasha banane wali- Ayeha

Yes, the chilati atmass, I thought I told you, Caco and Faz to use your talvars and return them to where the belong- six feet under. Hopefully the CVs will do what you all couldn't. The episode was going great and then MAHHHHHIIII! Arrrr.

RR scene, did you notice that besharam ladki, she had her hands on Maan. You know what needs to be done, talvars out once again. After Geet the only people who have the right to touch him are in the den. Okay, now if Maan wants to be with Brij or Adi, I will make an exception but for now, Ms. RR you crossed the limits.

The siblings seeing each other after such a long time was truly emotional, I think all the viewers are suckers for such sweet scenes.

Stop being greedy, let the 'bechara' boy get some rest.

Sweety you aren't being rude by saying the whole FRANSHIP scene was executed poorly, like you I too understand that it is important for them to be friends, but they could have made it less FAKE. There is already enough fake stuff in Geet's life, they could have stayed away from this fake scene.

The one liners were funny, like the one you pointed out, "hum yahaan apna ghar basaane nahi ayein hain". Good thing ladki that you made yourself clear, because you don't know how besharam the munda is, he is just waiting for you to say yes and he will basao ghar right there and then.

Talvar Posse in dark tabela, think about it, there is something fishy going on. Think about it when do a bunch of men stand in darkness. I think its time to give them some gyan, hey guys just come out and let the world know "Don't Tolerate Intolerance - Gay is the ONLY Acceptable Way" all their anger which stems from sexual frustration will evaporate. After-all they need to realized that it is the 21st century.

Overall, thanks for giving us a funny analysis.





Pyaar ki bhakti karne wali- Jyoti

Yes, we all are very aware of you reaching swarglook and we are all very happy for you. The tabela as the CVs gift to you and the gufa to all of us devils in the den. Me soo happy.

I don't think the CVs are litening to us regarding the editing, since the two got fake engaged every thing is moving at light speed, no rhyme or reasoning with the editing. You are right how did Maan manage to get Rajju and Tito to come and meet Geet, I wasn't thinking about it, but when you mentioned it, I started to have my brain work, Rajji and Tito both were in regular clothes, so he couldn't have gotten them from school, confusion, confusion. I am, still happy though, the siblings meeting each other after so long was truly emotional.

You are right about the two of them understanding each other and all they need is to look at each other, no words need to be said, very few couples have that and they truly looked awesome. Did you notice how Maan made all the crazy village people by just raising his hand, like a Holyman giving his followers ashirwad, and his followers actually became quite to hear him impart from Gyan, too funny.

None of the family coming will allow Geet to move forward, but I feel the need to defend her parents. I think that they feel guilty for letting what happened to Geet happen. I think that they feel that Geet's life is hers and hers only that they have no right since they did nothing to stop Brij from going after her. Also there maybe another reason for them not mentioning Geet, we know that Mohinder knows where Geet is since he initially made living arrangements for her with Pinky's dad. Her parents maybe afraid that if they let their feeling out, someone in the house may findout where Geet and her life maybe in danger once again. They may have not even known that Geet was in town. I hope I am right.

You are right about the friendship scene, I thought it was cliched and it could have been executed in a better manner, it doesn't matter that it was important to their relationship moving forward, but the CVs need to keep in mind that you have to make sure something done properly specially when it is important. I thought I saw a sly look on Maan's face when Geet suggested friendship, finally something positive, he was so tired of hearing her say no that he welcomed this change. However he never said okay, he let her decide what she wanted their relationship to be. I think that he tried the aggressive route and failed, so now he has decided to take the passive route and let her deal with her feelings without her needing to push him away.

The famous Tabela, I liked everything about it, nothing to complain about. Liked the playfulness between them, liked how they get angry at each other. Again why are they turning Maan into Ram. First on Tuesday when he was telling her how strong she was, he has Ram voice not Maan voice. And now Geet dropping her jewellery for Maan to find, just like Sita and Ram. I loved the episode so I am not going to complain more.

Yeahhh, the Talvar Posse is back, minus the leader, too bad, but we take what we get. I can't wait for thursday's episode.

Overall as always nice analysis.



Mahi ki acchaia sunane wali- Sonia

Thank you for having such a short take on the episode, my eyes are starting to hurt and my brain is hurting, however my poor dear, people are not disagreeing with you about your opinion about how the friendship scene was handles and how it was a little out of place, even though it is important to the story. What people are probably concernened about is your love for MAHIII! But I guess the chilati huin atmaass need someone to save them from the Talvars that are out to get them, it might as well be you. And lastly the bonding news was very emotional, so nicely executed.

Overall nice and sweet.



Kisi ko rulana na chahe- Lana

Dear if this is short, I don't want to find out what long is. Lets start, I too have been yelling since they got engaged that the CVs are taking the story ahead at lightning speed. What is the rush? I think they are trying to apease all the crazies, who keep on demanding Maneet confession. In less than three days, we have them in HP, RR problem solved, Geet meeting family members and now also being attacked. Too fast.

As for Maan going to jail for the cancellation of a business deal, it doesn't happen in real life. There are cases going on for almost 20 years regarding land disputes and none of the people have gone to jail, the lawyers have gotten rich, but the people are still living free, but I guess they needed Maneet to get to HP and used artistic licence regarding the whole case thing filed by RR.

Man you must have really good memory, because I don't think anyone other than you remembered Dadi's conversation with NT regarding the differences between the 2 brothers. Good one, thanks for reminding us, yes Maan confronts everything head strong. I just thought how he dealt with the villagers was funny, he looked like a Holyman raising his hand to give his followers to be shaant so that he can give them gyan, and guess what the villagers did get quite and listened to him. I was on the floor, I think I was the only one who found it funny.

Girl you are after my own heart, an olive branch, you brought in the United Nations. Okay I am political geek, hence the mention of the UN. But you are right, two waring countries, both tired, the little one has nothing to offer but a promise for good relations, hoping the larger country will accept. In our case the big country turned out to be very benevolent and told the little one that it could set the terms of their relationship. Although the establishment of friendship was important the way it was executed was cliched. But what is done is done, we can talk about it all we want, all I hope is that the CVs keep in mind that this show is unique and they shouldn't succumb to cheesiness when trying to relay something to the viewers.

The tabela scene I though was cute, it was nice to see Geet feel comfortable around Maan. And yes Maan finding Geet through her belongings again a little filmy but oh well. And yes the dupatta, it sure loves to get it's grubby hands on Maan. As Ms. Taveez would say, "only I am allowed to be so close to Maan, I know you all are rooting for Geet, but trust me I am allowing her to get close to him, I am tolerating her since bringing them together is my assignment. If it weren't I would keep Maan all to myself."

Looking forward to today, overall you brought up some really interesting points and once again you have a great memory, really nice analysis.



Rangoh ki Swami- Ami

Thank you for color coating and writing your analysis in sections. Makes it a lot easier to read.

You are right, yesterday he nodded she listened, today it was the other way around. Interesting MSK who never listened to anyone, not even his Dadi (although he loves her, but remember when he refused to come back home, even after she asked him countless time) will listen to Geet's silent gestures. Loved how he was so protective of her and commanded her to leave before opening the door.

Geet's reunion with Rajji and Titu so emotional, I don't think there was one soul that wasn't touched. Parting can be such sorrow, them telling her that the family has moved on and them regretfully leaving her, will now allow her to move forward. I guess finally she will be able to break ties with the painful memories of her family.

Friendship day, lets not even talk about it, such a dissapointment. Could have done it so much better, there was so much they had to work with, and they used the silly way. I was really looking forward to what Geet was going to say after she said, "mein apse ladke thak gayi hu" the preceding scene had been so emotional that when she said lets be friends, I was taken by surprise and not the good kind. Hopefully the CVs will keep in mind for the future that they don't have to make their characters act like teenagers to convey something.

I am too excited with the Tabela scene and the nok jok between the two, thank you for putting some of the funny and nice dialogs into your analysis. I also liked it that before he realized that she was in danger, he went back to being MSK and started giving dhamkiyas. Dude needs to control his anger sometimes, or atleast only yell when the situation calls for it. He will learn slowly, I am sure how to handle Geet.

Arre yaar, MSK Geet ke baare mein sub kuch janta hain, uski payal bhi pehchanta hain. Woh payal jo aaj taak Geet neh kabi pehni hi nahi thi. ESP.

Waiting for Thursday's episode. Nice analysis.





The one with emoticons in her edits- Adits

Dear missed the smilies, you know the cute ones not the ones from IF, but I know you were not home so I forgive you.

He reminded you of AB in Sarkar, he reminded me of some Holyman, who raises his hand to silence his followers so that they can get some gyan from him. It was too funny, Geet ke babaji ne Maan ko babaji bana diya. It's Geet, if she doesn't complain to her Babaji about Maan, the episode would be incomplete. Althought I would actually like to see 1 episode with out Babaji talk. I wonder what it would be like.

The siblings scene too good. One side Geet can't get enough of her siblings and on the other side Maan can't wait to hang up on his. I wonder of the CVs were trying to send us some kinda message through that scene, but I am sure we will find out.

Car scene was OTT specially since the car wasn't moving. Maan finally giving up being agressive and telling her now you decide, what you want us to be. Very samajdar, he did say, "agar seedhi ungli se ghee na nikle toh tedi ungli say sahi", dummy didn't know that what he was thinking was teedi was actually seedhi and now seedhi is teedi, yes yes very confusing, but he is finally getting it.

Maan will go anywhere when Geet holds his hand, off the dance floor into a stinking Tabela, I wonder where next.

Maan running in one place trying to find Geet is symbolic dear, he has been running like a hamster continuously behind Geet without getting any results. Finally Geet leaving some clues so that he can get off that wheel and get some results. Balle Balle.

Nice and precise. Me too looking forward to today's epi.



The End.
Edited by Poli.Geek - 15 years ago
vivacious_gurl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
ok am sorry if this still comes on page 2..... am starting my banter.......
anyone who wants to continue with friendship and trekking talk...please go back to old den..... not here...
@GF - u were talking bout orchids for u?? did u mention in any of ur posts that u like Orchids????

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Queen0fDarkness · 2 years ago

As mentioned in the notes in the other FF threads that I had created the other ID at a time when I wanted to be anonymous and avoid raising...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tellyme · 2 years ago

MG FF - Devil's Den #2; Updated Last Chapter Pg 71 May 18

LINK- THREAD 1 INDEX ************************** Chapter 31 - Below Chapter 32 Chapter 33 Chapter 34 Chapter 3 5 Chapter 36 Chapter 37 Chapter 38...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".