GHSP-Geet's story or Maan's story?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

-honeydew-

@-honeydew-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

👏👏👏👏👏 you are 19! awesome points made... yes it is very easy to talk of radical feminism.. but thats not what i am talking about...
what i have issues with is the way she is almost tormenting another human being, and presuming its for the better! she does have a larger issue at hand and for an 18 year old i admit she has seen alot..! neither is it easy to fight your growing feelings for someone you really love ... and you know the person loves you back...!! its hard ... nothings easy.. life aint easy either.. but we being humans.. its inherent in us that we try doing things that make problems easier to deal with... i am saying she is choosing a harder way out and being harsh on herself as well as another human who seems to come back to her no matter what!!

Originally posted by: geet.a

See..I am willing to be understanding about the show..

The CVs work in a society..which is patriarchal..
The inherent feminist strains ARE the ways women do fight in their lives

Geet stands up for her rights..but they come at personal sacrifices

She loves Maan.
Not to be sentimental..but even practical..

She loves Maan. And she cannot tell him the truth because she knows it will hurt him.
What will she say anyways? How will he react.

When there is the person you love on the other line..someone as unpredictable as Maan..you can't just confess...

It's within the context of the so called job that she's doing this.
He can conveniently revert back..but she cannot..

She might get a job..but none as safe as that with Maan

She has faced abuse before..

Now..this is different..

Plus he's emotionally blackmailing her.

She is 18..It's not easy.

Its now that..being 19 even I am understanding how oppression..even gentle oppression works..

It's not easy to be all radically feminist

I think Geet is usually a pretty well-rounded individual who is aware of what she is doing.

God..I have no idea if I got any of my points across..
😳

but really good post Niha!

Quote

smrite

@smrite

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

well the name of the show is geet so obviously it's geet's story and how her life started with innocent village girl and all injustice happened to her and she got guts to fight for her rights and all that and maan as her soulmate her saviour and now maan is geet's love major part in her life it's geet and maan's both story coz they both are main leads and i don't think maan did anything bad to geet in today's episode he is always that angry and i love it geet and maan are both connected to eachother so it's both's story and i love it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tinsel

@tinsel

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

Well said....honeydew...I agree,the CV's have made it look as if Geet is the weak one,just cuz she's a woman and have used it infront of Maan....as if all the women are the ones at fault...what about Maan...does that mean he can get away with anything and that doesn't matter at all it,cuz he's a Man...

Quote

fijianbabe

@fijianbabe

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: geet.a

See..I am willing to be understanding about the show..

The CVs work in a society..which is patriarchal..
The inherent feminist strains ARE the ways women do fight in their lives

Geet stands up for her rights..but they come at personal sacrifices

She loves Maan.
Not to be sentimental..but even practical..

She loves Maan. And she cannot tell him the truth because she knows it will hurt him.
What will she say anyways? How will he react.

When there is the person you love on the other line..someone as unpredictable as Maan..you can't just confess...

It's within the context of the so called job that she's doing this.
He can conveniently revert back..but she cannot..

She might get a job..but none as safe as that with Maan

She has faced abuse before..

Now..this is different..

Plus he's emotionally blackmailing her.

She is 18..It's not easy.

Its now that..being 19 even I am understanding how oppression..even gentle oppression works..

It's not easy to be all radically feminist

I think Geet is usually a pretty well-rounded individual who is aware of what she is doing.

God..I have no idea if I got any of my points across..
😳

but really good post Niha!

I agree with u. it wouldnt be easy telling maan. either way he would get hurt. but there will be more hurt if he finds out what really happened to geet. one of the many reasons is because of the way he treated her in the past.

Quote

sana

@Sananya09

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#15

Can't say anything.. you said it all! My thoughts exactly! 😃 So yeah.. i agree! But kya karein.. i think more people on this forum are maan fans than geets 😕

Quote

Marya

@Mazzy101

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#16

yeah i guess i kinda agree wth you, it is going in a kinda crazy direction wth all ths confesssing and nt confessing and its quite dissapointing!

Quote

311578

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#17

comment updated on pg 1 😊

Quote

meravigiliso

@meravigiliso

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#18

niha, what you said is partially true. yes sometimes they show from maan persepective. but can you imagine,a girl saying i am pregnant and cannot love you or marry you.'no'. i think no girl can confront her sad past to her mentor. she knows that maan loves her a lot their is no need to confess verbally .he had done many times with his gestures .but what to do she cannot accept that. can you imagine aplight if her man says ' i don't want to do same mistake by believing in innocent face ,bholi eyes like of yours',i think no girl can take that.but geet had taken that insult and stood strongly becoz she knew that this pain will subside with the time but the bitter truth he cannot take it.maan is really sensitive and was not able take denial feelings of geet .even though he said he doesn't want to come near geet but he was just pleading ,forcing her to confess.yesterday it was a confession only when she said i doesn't want bhoj on you and doesn't want toyou feel that.may be hoshyarpur scenes will make realise maan,why she was not accepting her feelings ,and definetly respect for her and love for her will reach tto its zenith. so i feel geet is very strong and took right decision by not confeesing. this is purely my opinion.

Quote

sana

@Sananya09

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: acjanfeb1
niha, what you said is partially true. yes sometimes they show from maan persepective. but can you imagine,a girl saying i am pregnant and cannot love you or marry you.'no'. i think no girl can confront her sad past to her mentor. she knows that maan loves her a lot their is no need to confess verbally .he had done many times with his gestures .but what to do she cannot accept that. can you imagine aplight if her man says ' i don't want to do same mistake by believing in innocent face ,bholi eyes like of yours',i think no girl can take that.but geet had taken that insult and stood strongly becoz she knew that this pain will subside with the time but the bitter truth he cannot take it.maan is really sensitive and was not able take denial feelings of geet .even though he said he doesn't want to come near geet but he was just pleading ,forcing her to confess.yesterday it was a confessiononlywhen she said i doesn't want bhoj on you and doesn't want toyou feel that.may be hoshyarpur scenes will make realise maan,why she was not accepting her feelings ,and definetly respect for her and love forher will reachtto its zenith. so i feel geet is very strong and took right decisionby not confeesing. this is purely my opinion.

Wow! I love your thoughts! Agree with them 100%