Making Khushi Mine II ~ (THREAD 26) - Page 83

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

118.2k

Users

583

Likes

3.6k

Frequent Posters

shree10 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: MoonlightAura

Hello again dear Author,

Well I did not expect that to be a deal breaker. The chapter was despairing to read, you got us exactly where you wanted us to be. Why go to end to a spectrum to get things right? She almost ended up paying a price for being innocent and unpretentiousness, the very things because of which he fell for her. Their life is indeed filled with bad timings and untimely confession all rolled in one single concoction. Do I feel sorry for her? not exactly.. Since she has sorted out her mind way back that she had a crush on him, she should have maintained the same attitude no matter how tired or frustrated she was feeling. She wanted to give him some words of comfort then revealing her crush would have been suffice. I was disappointed with her reply of 'Nothing can be changed now', it almost sounds like she wishes otherwise, that she made some sort of compromise out there.
I was always in a tug of war between who is the better contender for Khushi. I am glad that this update clearly defined Arnav as a way better man between the two. The fact that Rishabh was aware of her crush but was not man enough to imagine a life with a limping girl. It clearly etched out that in his eyes she was lacking something and indirectly not his equal. He kept her hopes up too with his flirtatious behaviour but kept her at a distance at the same time. Its indirectly points to his duplicity of nature, at the same time expecting her to fall in line when he feels that he is up for it, not caring that his indifference might have hurt her. Arnav is many things but he is very in your face person. When he hated her, he hated her with passion and made no bones to hide his dislike for her from her or others. He is not hesitant to let others know if he is displeased with them, he does not pretend to be something which he is not. Arnav was a way better man and individual any day, thank you for getting us over our 'injustice against Rishabh' line of thought.
Khushi was stepping on too many stones in here, she was bound to fall hard in the end. You know the feeling that when you try too hard to praise everyone, you may just come across as sounding phoney. Khushi gave Arnav something precious with her words of love. But today she took away their essence by sharing those with other man. Arnav is mature enough to understand that she may harness feelings for other man/men when he was not in picture, after their first post marriage argument he had clearly asked her if she felt the same still. She had lied then to save her marriage. Though her intentions are sincere, she is indirectly contradicting herself in front of his eyes. Not long back I applauded her when she developed a backbone to stand for what she believes in, to fight against her very intimidating husband too. Then why today, just to please this friend did she decide to bend backwards? Why could she not defend her marriage of choice and husband in front of this stranger?
Arnav with strong setbacks in life, still strives to move forward. Though it seemed cowardly of him to run away in face of her confession, it indirectly point to the fact that love for him has far deeper meaning and connotation. The termed should not be taken lightly or thrown around carelessly. Somehow today of all days, his anger was perfectly justified. Even if you happen to take away his past, any man would have reacted the same way. A moment was inevitable when Arnav would witness half confrontation between Khushi and Rishabh was a foregone conclusion. I was not happy with the way it played out.
I have seen other reader comment, especially cosmina express doubts, if the victim is indeed Khushi. Arnav is highly frustrated as of now, did he mistakenly take other woman as Khushi. Was it some other woman wearing black saree? This is a way balance story with mistakes at both end of the parties. There are feelings at both ends but mostly what stands out is 'Impulsiveness Vs Caution'. I somehow do not want to see Arnav nursing Khushi back to health. Their equation will drastically change if so were to happen. Its not about Arnav's redemption only, Khushi needs to redeem some too. If she gave him a reason to hope, she equally gave him a reason to doubt too. Her presence made him re examine skeletons in his closet too. In midst of all this what comes out strong is his sincerity to try for their sake. Why should HE always be a knight on white charger to rescue? If she can fight for her dignity with her husband, why would she not fight back with a man trying to encroach into her marriage? A strong woman needs to keep her wits about her too, why rely on her man for that too. Arnav's rightly feels like a charity case, knowing her and knowing the affection for others that she goes around bestowing freely.
If the victim was indeed Khushi, we have a man trying to make amends to his heart broken wife. I somehow do not want Rishabh trying to make Arnav understand Khushi sincerity towards him. I do not wish to see other well meaning people intervene. Khushi is learning along way, it would be nice to see her stop trying to please everyone and pretend things are hunky dory when they are not. Arnav needs just a jolt to come away from the edge of blinding anger, to realise he cares for her. Will seeing a Khushi alike woman take a fall get him out of his stupor? After everything else, she has become his addiction, his drug and he will always come crawling back to her. I would say I might not crave 'Knight to Rescue', but a 'Comrades in Arms' who have each other backs while navigating through mine field of life..
What is interesting is the way you make us sympathise with one character this time and other for the next time. Its a talent that is for sure, for we end up discussing, debating to our heart's delight 😆
Hopefully you put us out of this melancholic we seem to have fallen in since last update.
Please update very soon.



wow what a comment and analysis! simply loved it!
Edited by shree10 - 11 years ago
Arshix144 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Thank you A, absolutely LOVED your note! I am relieved to read your thoughts on everything!

And I absolutely cannot believe that people are actually questioning Khushi throughout everything that happened. I don't know If I should blame the mentality here or what. Sure she is not perfect but man out of everyone in this story she has tried the hardest to keep everything together. She has time and again been the least selfish and I sincerely hope she becomes a little more selfish here! She has to look after herself and her broken heart too other than continuously trying to please her husband. I hope that His parting words about the marriage being over is indeed the last blow. That was the worst thing he could do because Khushi clearly mentioned about the past, it is not like she was/is having an affair with Rishabh. He always quite conveviently forgot his misgivings, how he treated Khushi from the begining till the end, rejecting her, insulting her, manipulating her for his selfish reasons completely disregarding her happiness and wishes oh and the list goes on.

While Arnav's trust issues have been incredibly high and unreasonable as well because I suppose that is how his character has been all along, I would say kudos and salutes to Khushi for continuously putting up with it. I most certainly wouldn't have! It is just so sad to see her love not only not reciprocated but thrown back in her face as well because rationality and logic leave Arnav whenever he is even faced with the tiniest of situations for doubt. *sighs again I can't commend you enough for the realistic portrayal even if it is painful for us to read at times. I like the fact that you stick to what you know best despite getting the kind of feedback you get. While I understand why Arnav's character was and has been the way he has been, I don't get the readers who support him blindly no matter how horrible he has been and let him get away with even murder if they have to. I guess it has to do with barun/arnav loyalty and then there is the "blame the woman syndrome" in all situations.

I personally go by characters depending on how they are in every story, for instance in MKM1 I liked the Arnav who gradually changed. He had issues but he never hurt Khushi delibrately, was considerate to the T specially and loved her passionately after their marriage. The way you portray your khushi's automatically make me adore her and feel this strong sense of protectiveness for her. She most certainly has been the most selfless and mature one out of the lot in this story. And so the way her accident happened right after her heartbreak had me just a tad depressed. ( Heck, I am still not quite over it.)

When it comes to Rishabh I most certainly don't dislike him or blame him for anything. Sure the last thing he did is questionable, but he was angry and compared to Arnav he hasn't been nearly as unreasonable at all! While people conveniently forget Arnav's initial treatment of Khushi and let him get away with everything. I haven't forgotten anything. Rishabh's hesitation to marry Khushi because of her limp is quite a common and REAL hestiation. I think because he is not Arnav people are not so forgiving and I am baffled.

I hope this accident shocks Arnav into accepting his true feelings and reality, he might need to be taught a few things about his wife too. He might have to reflect on how she has been throughout his stay and how he has been with her since he came back from the States and then decide on how to redeem himself if at all possible.
Edited by Arshix144 - 11 years ago
shree10 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: tanu3579

thx fr the note anon...

bt like farha... i wud also stick to the pt.. tht no matter wht sacrifice or adjustment khushi was doing... this was very very wrong.

especially as moonlightaura put is..

whn she says "nothing can be done abt it now" it does sound like she wants to change the situation in her life.. wrt to who her husband shud b.

i wonder hw was arnav so controlled even after tht..

i can see logic in every other thg.. bt this.. i dont think i wud ever b able to see any logic in it.
no matter hw frustrated n angered she was... if she knew tht arnav is more imp.. then this was never ever.. ever to come out of her. not to rishabh, nt to arnav..
actually this line "nothing can be done abt it now" shud never come to even her thots...

bt then again... main to jyada gussa bhi ni ho paa ri uspe... since hse suffered the worst betrayal, n then her worst fear of losing arnav seems to come true in all this...
she is too soft n gd fr her own gd.. :(



Totally agree Tanu. And sorry Anon, For me Khushi still doesnt get a clean chit.
Doesnt matter if she is bride of 3 months! Men are possessive and arnav is epitome of that!

I still wish you are not going on Khushi seriously injured , Arnav nursing her and then finding out how important she is for him or he loves her this way.. No.. I would call this inorganic progression. Kind of cliched.
I would have loved the battle of wits/ words to win the loved one over!

Had you alway thought of Khushi's accident as such?

DirtyDancing thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: MoonlightAura

<font color="#009900" size="2">Hello again dear Author,</font>

<font color="#009900" size="2"> WellI did not expect that to be a deal breaker.The chapter was despairing to read, you got us exactly where you wanted us to be. Why go to end to a spectrum to get things right? She almost ended up paying a price for being innocent and unpretentiousness, the very things because of which he fell for her. Their life is indeed filled with bad timings and untimely confession all rolled in one single concoction. Do I feel sorry for her? not exactly.. Since she has sorted out her mind way back that she had a crush on him, she should have maintained the same attitude no matter how tired or frustrated she was feeling. She wanted to give him some words of comfort then revealing her crush would have been suffice. I was disappointed with her reply of 'Nothing can be changed now', it almost sounds like she wishes otherwise, thatshe madesome sortof compromise out there. </font>

</strong>

<font size="2"><font color="#009900"> I was always in a tug of war between who is the better contender for Khushi. I am glad that this update clearly defined Arnav as a way better man between the two. The fact that Rishabh was aware of her crush but was not man enough to imagine a life with a limping girl. It clearly etched out that in his eyes she was lacking something and indirectly not his equal. He kept her hopes up too with his flirtatious behaviourbut kept her at a distance at the same time. Itsindirectly points to his duplicity of nature, at the same time expecting her to fall in line when hefeels that he is up for it, not caringthat his indifference might have hurt her. Arnav is many things but he is very in your face person. When he hated her, he hated her with passion and made no bones to hide his dislike for her from her or others. He is not hesitant to let others know if he is displeased with them, he does not pretend to be something which he is not. Arnav was a way better man and individual any day, thank you for getting us over our 'injustice against Rishabh' line of thought. </font></font>


<font color="#009900" size="2"> Khushi was stepping on too many stonesin here, she was bound to fall hard in the end. You know the feeling that when you try too hard to praiseeveryone, you may just come across as sounding phoney. Khushi gave Arnav something precious with her words of love. But today she took away theiressence by sharing those with other man. Arnav is mature enough to understand that she may harness feelings for other man/men when he was not in picture, after their firstpost marriage argument hehad clearly asked her ifshe felt the same still. She had lied then to save hermarriage. Though herintentions aresincere, she is indirectlycontradicting herselfin front of his eyes. Not long back I applauded her when she developed a backboneto standfor what she believesin, to fight against hervery intimidating husband too. Then why today, just to please thisfriend did she decide to bend backwards? Why could she not defend her marriageof choice and husband in front of this stranger?</font>


<font color="#009900" size="2"> Arnav with strong setbacks in life, still strives to move forward. Though it seemed cowardly of him to run away in face of her confession, it indirectly point to the fact that love for him has far deeper meaning and connotation. The termed should not be taken lightly or thrown around carelessly. Somehow today of all days, his anger was perfectly justified. Even if you happen to take away his past, any man would have reacted the same way. A moment was inevitable when Arnav would witness half confrontation between Khushi and Rishabh was a foregone conclusion.I was not happy with the way it played out. </font>


<font color="#009900" size="2"> I have seen other reader comment, especially cosmina express doubts, if the victim is indeed Khushi. Arnav is highly frustrated as of now, did he mistakenly take other woman as Khushi. Was it some other woman wearing black saree? This is a way balance story with mistakes at both end of the parties. There are feelings at both ends but mostly what stands out is 'Impulsiveness Vs Caution'. I somehow do not want to see Arnav nursing Khushi back to health. Their equation will drastically change if so were to happen. Its not about Arnav's redemption only, Khushi needs to redeem some too. If she gave him a reason to hope, she equally gave him a reason to doubt too. Her presence made him re examine skeletons in his closet too. In midst of all this what comes out strongis hissincerity to try for their sake. Why shouldHE always be a knight on white charger to rescue? If she canfight for her dignity with her husband, why would she not fight back with a man trying to encroach into her marriage?A strong woman needs to keep her wits about her too, why rely on her man for that too. Arnav's rightly feels like a charity case, knowing her and knowing the affection for others that she goes around bestowing freely. </font>


<font color="#009900" size="2"> If the victim was indeed Khushi, we have a man trying to make amends to his heart broken wife. I somehow do not want Rishabh trying to make Arnav understand Khushi sincerity towards him. I do not wish to see other well meaning people intervene. Khushi is learning along way, it would be nice to see her stoptrying to please everyone and pretend things are hunky dory when they are not. Arnav needs just a jolt to come away from the edge of blinding anger, to realise he cares for her. Will seeing a Khushi alike woman take a fall get him out of his stupor? After everything else, she has become his addiction, his drug and he will always come crawling back to her. I would say I might not crave 'Knight to Rescue', but a 'Comrades in Arms' who have each other backs while navigating through mine field of life..</font>



<font size="2"><font color="#009900"> What is interesting is the way you make us sympathise with one character this time and other for the next time. Its a talent that is for sure, for we end up discussing, debating to our heart's delight 😆 </font></font>


<font color="#009900" size="2"> Hopefully you put us out of this melancholic we seem to have fallen in since last update.</font>

<font color="#009900" size="2">Please update very soon.</font>


<strong><font color="#009900" size="2"> </font>


loved your comment...totally true.
I go with it.
tanu3579 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shree10



Totally agree Tanu. And sorry Anon, For me Khushi still doesnt get a clean chit.
Doesnt matter if she is bride of 3 months! Men are possessive and arnav is epitome of that!

I still wish you are not going on Khushi seriously injured , Arnav nursing her and then finding out how important she is for him or he loves her this way.. No.. I would call this inorganic progression. Kind of cliched.
I would have loved the battle of wits/ words to win the loved one over!

Had you alway thought of Khushi's accident as such?


i think in the end... we r all human... n hv our own flaws...

khushi's being tht she is too too trusting, n too kind hearted to b direct n to the pt to anyone... even shyam fr tht matter... n rishabh was her frnd, whom she trusted soo much.
how cud she ever imagine he wud hurt her this ways.

n as of future... i m sure anon wud mk it worth it :) .. even if its arnav nursing khushi.. i m sure it wud b gd..
though if i go by the note.. i feel arnav is going to go away, even if its fr a while... even if he is physically present, he is definitely going to b emotionally distant to khushi...
which i think anyone in his place wud hv been.

i mean thr needs to b some sort of seperation fr the khushi POV song to happen.
shree10 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Mini, for a story like MKM-2, it is very difficult to be in one camp I mean pro-Khushi, pro-Arnav. I dont like RIshabh bas. I am a die-hard juvenile(in mind not by age 😆) Arshi shipper!

Originally posted by: Arshix144

Thank you A, absolutely LOVED your note! I am relieved to read your thoughts on everything!


And I absolutely cannot believe that people are actually questioning Khushi throughout everything that happened. I don't know If I should blame the mentality here or what. Sure she is not perfect but man out of everyone in this story she has tried the hardest to keep everything together. She has time and again been the least selfish and I sincerely hope she becomes a little more selfish here! She has to look after herself and her broken heart too other than continuously trying to please her husband. I hope that His parting words about the marriage being over is indeed the last blow. That was the worst thing he could do because Khushi clearly mentioned about the past, it is not like she was/is having an affair with Rishabh. He always quite conveviently forgot his misgivings, how he treated Khushi from the begining till the end, rejecting her, insulting her, manipulating her for his selfish reasons completely disregarding her happiness and wishes oh and the list goes on.

==> For me there is no doubt that Khushi is the least selfish out here but that is no excuse to be stupid right? I completely agree that she should become a bit selfish- which also means that she needs to prioritize and concentrate first on what is most important for her! SHe just cant go around trying to please everybody (be it Arnav or Rishabh) putting herself down in the process!
And it is not enough to try harder if you are not getting intended results. It's like you continue to put the hard work like a wood-cutter who goes on cutting trees without sharpening the axe!

While Arnav's trust issues have been incredibly high and unreasonable as well because I suppose that is how his character has been all along, I would say kudos and salutes to Khushi for continuously putting up with it. I most certainly wouldn't have! It is just so sad to see her love not only reciprocated but thrown back in her face as well because rationality and logic leave Arnav whenever he is even faced with the tiniest of situations for doubt. *sighs again I can't commend you enough for the realistic portrayal even if it is painful for us to read at times. I like the fact that you stick to what you know best despite getting the kind of feedback you get. While I understand why Arnav's character was and has been the way he has been, I don't get the readers who support him blindly no matter how horrible he has been and let him get away with even murder if they have to. I guess it has to do with barun loyalty and then there is the blame the woman syndrome in all situations.
==> Arnav does not get a clean cheat not atleast from me. He cannot take excuse of his horrible past for everything! So no..
But I agree I have juvenile bias towards shipping Arshi! I would very well support Khushi if she decides to stay away from Arnav for a while or give him cold shoulder for a while. OR even leave him if she decides. Totally support her. Personally I could never tolerate a person like Arnav as my husband! He needs counselling period.Not only for his anger management issues but also the mistrust and his overall doubt in human relationships. But you know only counselling also doesn't help. Scars of past are somtimes so deep-rooted that people like him need strong emotional family support for a prolonged period to restore their faith which in this case only Khushi can provide. But then as Arshi shipper I can only hope that she does that. As a woman I would even understand if she decides to leave Arnav at this stage!


I personally go by characters depending on how they are in every story, for instance in MKM1 I liked the Arnav who gradually changed. He had issues but he never hurt Khushi delibrately, was considerate to the T specially after their marriage. The way you portray your khushi's automatically make me adore her and feel this strong sense of protectiveness for her. She most certainly has been the most selfless and mature one out of the lot in this story. And so the way her accident happened after her heartbreak had me just a tad depressed.

When it comes to Rishabh I most certainly don't dislike him or blame him for anything. Sure the last thing he did is questionable, but he was angry and compared to Arnav he hasn't been nearly as unreasonable at all! While people conveniently forget Arnav's initial treatement of Khushi and let him get away with everything. I haven't forgotten anything. Rishabh's hesitation to marry Khushi because of her limp is quite a common and REAL hestiation. I think because he is not Arnav people are not so forgiving and I am baffled.

I hope this accident shocks Arnav into accepting his true feelings and reality, he might need to be taught a few things about his wife too. He might have to reflect on how she has been throughout his stay and how he has been with her since he came back from the States and then decide on how to redeem himself if at all possible.
=> I would have personally liked if
Arnav accepted his true feelings and reality without this accident! I would have preferred different shcok treatment for Arnav!



Mini Loved you POV too . OMG discussions on MKM -2 are becoming too interesting.
Edited by shree10 - 11 years ago
shruti46 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
agar rishabh n bhi dekha hoga toh arnav ko push karte hue then her accident..
what he will do then..??
his notion will become more strong that arnav is not good for khushi
will he still pursue khushi?
tanu3579 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shruti46

agar rishabh n bhi dekha hoga toh arnav ko push karte hue then her accident..

what he will do then..??
his notion will become more strong that arnav is not good for khushi
will he still pursue khushi?


fir bol ri hun shru... abki baar agar is rishabh ne arnav khushi ki life me interfere kara naa.. to laptop screen me se bahar nikal ke iski khoob maar laga ke wapas daal denge...

n kasam se daantne ka bada exp hai humko... maar se jyada to wo hamare cheekhne se hi mar jaega 😉
1chilly thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Thanks for clearing up a few things here.
Waiting for next week.
tanu3579 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: 1chilly

Thanks for clearing up a few things here.

Waiting for next week.


haw... dont wait fr next week anon pls... aaj abhi ho sake to isi waqt de do update pls...

Related Topics

Fan Fictions thumbnail

Posted by: themasked · 3 months ago

Hi,I recently started watching Kasauti Zindagi Kay 2 and fell in love with it and got introduced to so many characters.I started playing around...

Expand ▼
Fan Fictions thumbnail

Posted by: So-So · 7 months ago

One of my entries for Love-O-Rama Pyaar Ka Trope Fest Storyline: Enemies to Lovers Setting: Crime Character/Pairing: Arnav Khushi from IPPKND...

Expand ▼
Fan Fictions thumbnail

Posted by: Koeli · 5 years ago

Hey guys, This is the place where you can request for comment migration. Please know that FFEs are going to migrate your comments. Rules - You...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".