My dear Vidya,
I would have said that this is a touching and credible mood piece, except that I do not see what it means or where, if anywhere, it is going. If this is just the one chapter, and there will be no more, I do feel a little blank and uncertain. You always write from the heart, and that is why you do emotional scenes so well. But this reads like a patchwork: one funny scene with Shree, one tearful reminiscence by Aisha, one empathetic spell of silence with Arjun, and then what?
If this was the opening chapter of a regular FF, that would be one thing, but if this is
it, I am not sure what to think of it. Even a very short story has to go somewhere, the narrative and the emotional loop have to be completed. This one goes nowhere, and I feel shortchanged. I am sorry if I sound too critical, or if I have not got what you intended to convey, but my reviews would be pointless if I was not candid, would they not?
Shyamala Aunty
Hello Arjunians...Today morning, i am in a philosophical mood...and the result is this OS...yes its Arisha but more essentially Aisha And Arjun...
So here it goes..."Woh lamhe woh baatein..koi na jaane.."
Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago