No logic!!! - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Virmanishal

@Virmanishal

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

ok I dont get one thing..

"Please dont say any thing to Jeevika/Manvi/Viren/Virat,..its writers fault..."

But hello !!!

a character in itself = writer + actor..

When the person doesn't mean actor part of character,obv the question is for writers..

When a character does something great, then its the character who's praised,No one says She/he dint do anything,praise the writer.Why do things get reversed when criticised..

A CHARACTER IS A TEAM EFFORT.. Pointing at a character's 'track' or doings means script automatically..acting part is out of question.

As for the topic, i guess the team just wanted to introduce some behna element in wedding and impending separation for the other couple, so they introduced it for the sake of it ,and yet again,J's character suffers.

Edited by Virmanishal - 12 years ago

Quote

madhu0702

@madhu0702

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: Dhoxi
jeevika is leaving inorder to give her sister a happy life and punish herself. Dont blame her. she is crying because it's her character and being in ehmmbh forum you should be in support neither than going on opposite by telling no logic...

Originally posted by: Dhoxi
and if so why dont no-1 remember when manvi was told not to attend virika marriage?

Back then, Manvi staying away from Virika wedding had LOGIC. She made a promise to beeji. And also from that track not only us, but all the characters in the show got a message LOUD and CLEAR. And that is, both the sisters will never ever marry their respective partners without the presence of the other behena.

And this message was given by JEEVIKA VADHERA herself. So how the hell does she think now her leaving away will solve all the problems for Manvi and especially Manvi's wedding will happen without her? 😡

On a side note, nobody is comparing who is better Jeevika ya Manvi. All are tired with the way Jeevika is portrayed as a character. Unti now, she has been portrayed as timid, shy, calm girl never as a dumbo. And some of you still say it is in her character ?!😲 Now I am clueless !

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

js1234

@js1234

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

There hasnt been logic in the show for a while now to be honest. Some one has raised a point correctly - that when we are pleased with the story line - we praise actors not writers - but when story is not logical we tend to blame writers not actors. I suppose they are intervened but not sure how much clout does actors have over story line - surely they can raise their views as to what makes sense??

I seriously cannot take anything away from the acting they are all very very good. they have butchered one character or the other - time and again - at the moment not sure what the end game is here. But M acting like a 10 year old (please do not tell me she is just excited about wedding!!) especially after her maturity during J's wedding, chachu's case and also during cancer and her love confession. Virat playing video games- not thinking about his future wife and family and how is he going to support them. All Viren does is romance his wife - straight after abortion and bone marrow transplant - come on yaar!!!

They have shown depth of all them as to how they can react and act. So why not now! This is not bashing anyone at all just my feelings regarding the show. I suppose it is fictional and I should not really expect too much intellect from indian soaps!

Quote

swasti tiwari

@sanjana_cool

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

its cv's fault and jeevika is not respnsible...!!!!!!

Quote

Virmanishal

@Virmanishal

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

^hey there js1234 :), if you meant by my post, i just need to clarify i dint mean 'actors' anywhere in my post.. Criticism and praising both were with respect to 'characters' as in writer part of character, not the actor part.. They have nothing to do with the story :)

agreed on the rest,more or less..

Edited by Virmanishal - 12 years ago

Quote

js1234

@js1234

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Virmanishal
^hey there j1234 :), if you meant by my post, i just need to clarify i dint mean 'actors' anywhere in my post.. Criticism and praising both were with respect to 'characters' as in writer part of character, not the actor part.. They have nothing to do with the story :)

Not at all i actually my own post to be honest. you raised a fair point. I am also trying (may be not very well) to say the same - that as actors they are all very good and even as characters they have shown what each one of them can do! but as well know that its not being explored or even exploited. I would love to know writers views on these - as there must be soemthing that drives this plots in this day and age.

Quote

1 2

No logic!!! - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics