why was Shiv silent all along? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

4.9k

Users

19

Likes

224

Frequent Posters

486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#41
I never knew this show was based on Krishna Cottage😛Either way that was a movie where everything was clear from the beginning.The lines between the good and the bad were clear.This show is supposed to be a thriller with a suspense.Therefore every character is under scanner.
As to why Shiv didn't save XYZ people,then is he supposed to save them?He is not obliged to save them.Bhoot hai,superhero nahi.Sharanya is his only motivation.

Everything is expected from Shiv only.He is not supposed to scare Sharanya,he is supposed to protect so and so.Social worker samajh rakha hai kya??And if any murder or untoward event occurs then pat the blame goes on him
chinnuyadu14 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#42
👏👏

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

I never knew this show was based on Krishna Cottage😛Either way that was a movie where everything was clear from the beginning.The lines between the good and the bad were clear.This show is supposed to be a thriller with a suspense.Therefore every character is under scanner.

As to why Shiv didn't save XYZ people,then is he supposed to save them?He is not obliged to save them.Bhoot hai,superhero nahi.Sharanya is his only motivation.

Everything is expected from Shiv only.He is not supposed to scare Sharanya,he is supposed to protect so and so.Social worker samajh rakha hai kya??And if any murder or untoward event occurs then pat the blame goes on him

👏👏
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#43
Coming to the topic,why was Shiv silent all along?The answer is coz the CVs want him to be.
During the molestation scene on the Haldi day,had Shiv appeared miraculously to save Sharanya from Vyom then everything would have been clear about who is right and who is not.That would have vilified one of the leads beyond redemption.They want to keep the audience confused and maybe reveal at a later stage that Vyom was faking it all and he is the culprit.

chinnuyadu14 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: afreenaamna

You guys just need to watch Krishna Cottage to get all your answer's
He want Shanny to find it out on her own! Till then he won't let her die & his possessiveness won't let any other man get physical with her.
Shiv can't hurt Rajan as he is mata rani biggest bhakt but he can use his powers on the victims to save them but he didn't do that. Why? Krishna cottage dekh lo.

Then it would be so easy...if it was inspired from Krishna cottage...no need to watch further.😃
One question...y should shiv hurt Rajan?!!! If he was really after his killers there won't be a story then! A ghost is not omnipotent...
Rajan being the villian is viewers assumption...shiv is a character in the story...n being a bhakt of Durga doesn't mean ghost can't hurt u!! I don't think normal (relatively normal to Hindi serial) logic does apply here


romaila thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

I never knew this show was based on Krishna Cottage😛Either way that was a movie where everything was clear from the beginning.The lines between the good and the bad were clear.This show is supposed to be a thriller with a suspense.Therefore every character is under scanner.

As to why Shiv didn't save XYZ people,then is he supposed to save them?He is not obliged to save them.Bhoot hai,superhero nahi.Sharanya is his only motivation.

Everything is expected from Shiv only.He is not supposed to scare Sharanya,he is supposed to protect so and so.Social worker samajh rakha hai kya??And if any murder or untoward event occurs then pat the blame goes on him


But in the Krishna Cottage movie, the evil ghost killed those dared reading the book the ghost had left for her lover 😆 But yahan toh Shiv is leaving clues for the dhakkan humans Shiv has powers so protecting the world should be his supreme duty.

romaila thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

Coming to the topic,why was Shiv silent all along?The answer is coz the CVs want him to be.

During the molestation scene on the Haldi day,had Shiv appeared miraculously to save Sharanya from Vyom then everything would have been clear about who is right and who is not.That would have vilified one of the leads beyond redemption.They want to keep the audience confused and maybe reveal at a later stage that Vyom was faking it all and he is the culprit.


Point! 👍🏼

afreenaamna thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

I never knew this show was based on Krishna Cottage😛Either way that was a movie where everything was clear from the beginning.The lines between the good and the bad were clear.This show is supposed to be a thriller with a suspense.Therefore every character is under scanner.

As to why Shiv didn't save XYZ people,then is he supposed to save them?He is not obliged to save them.Bhoot hai,superhero nahi.Sharanya is his only motivation.

Everything is expected from Shiv only.He is not supposed to scare Sharanya,he is supposed to protect so and so.Social worker samajh rakha hai kya??And if any murder or untoward event occurs then pat the blame goes on him


No it was never clear. Esha kopikar character took a human form & was living in between them! Everything was blamed on aman verma spirit. Krishna cottage was a suspense thriller horror movie.
Social work others are doing for shiv despite of not having any powers & having a life to lose. Not other way around. They are all dying coz they are trying unveil his death mystery.
He is not suppose to scare sharanya? a girl who woke up from coma after 2 years is haunted by him. So let's not even go there. Shiv is possessive about sharanya's body & that's what it is.
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: romaila


But in the Krishna Cottage movie, the evil ghost killed those dared reading the book the ghost had left for her lover 😆 But yahan toh Shiv is leaving clues for the dhakkan humans Shiv has powers so protecting the world should be his supreme duty.

Haan Ji.KC waali ghost didn't want anyone to find out about her secret except her lover.Also she was more powerful as she could appear before the humans and also trick them.
But apna Shiv is a dhakkan bhoot who is leaving clues for dhakkan humans.🤪

Oh yes!! Shiv has powers so he should be saving the world.Phir toh Shiv should create his own army of ghosts and save the planet from all calamities.Duniya ka kalyaan hojayega.😆Sharanya ke peeche pagal hone se better hai ki kuch samaaj seva karde.Government ki help karde in maintaining law and order.Ab toh yahin karne keliye janaab bhoot bane thay.

Sau baat ki ek baat.Everyone is expecting Shiv to be a superhero but no one expects the humans to grow some brains.Who told Dr Amit to call Sharanya to an isolated place at night when there was a chance of potential danger to their lives?
Who told Papa Bisht to fix his daughter's marriage without digging info on the guy's family?And he had to remember Mata Rani's idol just a day before the wedding and had to go all alone to retrieve it.If he had done this a few days ago or taken Sharanya to their old home to refresh her memories then yeh naubat naa aati.
Who told Odhni to directly confront Rajan and thus make him aware that they were onto him?
Humans themselves behave like idiots and invite trouble for themselves.But when the time comes sab blame karne lag jaao Bhoot ko.Ghor Kalyug😛
Praju_D thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

Haan Ji.KC waali ghost didn't want anyone to find out about her secret except her lover.Also she was more powerful as she could appear before the humans and also trick them.

But apna Shiv is a dhakkan bhoot who is leaving clues for dhakkan humans.🤪

Oh yes!! Shiv has powers so he should be saving the world.Phir toh Shiv should create his own army of ghosts and save the planet from all calamities.Duniya ka kalyaan hojayega.😆Sharanya ke peeche pagal hone se better hai ki kuch samaaj seva karde.Government ki help karde in maintaining law and order.Ab toh yahin karne keliye janaab bhoot bane thay.

Sau baat ki ek baat.Everyone is expecting Shiv to be a superhero but no one expects the humans to grow some brains.Who told Dr Amit to call Sharanya to an isolated place at night when there was a chance of potential danger to their lives?
Who told Papa Bisht to fix his daughter's marriage without digging info on the guy's family?And he had to remember Mata Rani's idol just a day before the wedding and had to go all alone to retrieve it.If he had done this a few days ago or taken Sharanya to their old home to refresh her memories then yeh naubat naa aati.
Who told Odhni to directly confront Rajan and thus make him aware that they were onto him?
Humans themselves behave like idiots and invite trouble for themselves.But when the time comes sab blame karne lag jaao Bhoot ko.Ghor Kalyug😛


Shiv must be thinking kaha in idiot logo ke beech mein bhoot ban gaya mein.. All are giving tough competition to each other in proving their idiotpanti.. 😆
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: afreenaamna


No it was never clear. Esha kopikar character took a human form & was living in between them! Everything was blamed on aman verma spirit. Krishna cottage was a suspense thriller horror movie.
Social work others are doing for shiv despite of not having any powers & having a life to lose. Not other way around. They are all dying coz they are trying unveil his death mystery.
He is not suppose to scare sharanya? a girl who woke up from coma after 2 years is haunted by him. So let's not even go there. Shiv is possessive about sharanya's body & that's what it is.

If I am not wrong then Esha Koppikar herself appeared before Anita's character to kill her.😛And that was a movie.They had only two hours so everything was revealed early.
@bold,Who has done anything for Shiv till now??🤣Apart from blaming him and cursing him.Freddie was a detective.It was his job to investigate.He had volunteered for it out of his own freewill.Shiv never told him to go and investigate.

@Pink,Okay so Sharanya has woken up from coma and he shouldn't scare her.What should he do then??Baithe baithe tamasha dekhe?😛He was the only one who was doing something to remind Sharanya of her past and bring her memories back while the rest of human beings around her were doing nothing.It's natural that she would get scared of his actions coz he is invisible and she can't hear him.

@Red,🤣🤣🤣Uff itni comedy toh Kapil ke show main bhi nahi hai🤣
Edited by Athene - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".