Revenge, Abuse and their Justification!!!!

11714daughter thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Hi Guys,

Do two wrongs make a right? Is Abuse of any kind justified, if the reason behind the abuse is valid or legitimate? Is there any excuse that would justify abuse? Everyone wants revenge for something or the other when they were wronged, but how many of us actually act on it, but even more important, but when does the reason behind the reason stop being a justification for that revenge? Is it all right for one to use a third party to carry out their revenge, or to lump everyone in one category and consider everyone your enemy, simply because of what one person did to you? Let us explore these issues in these last few episodes that were aired November 8 through November 11, 2013, that we have seen of Ek Boond Ishq:

Your my way in

We finally find out that Yug was never what he seems, he was trying to get into Nandu and her mum's good books, and now that he has achieved this he wants to get into the Shekawat's house for some reason. Most likely he has been wronged by someone, who could be Rudra or Adi and so wants to get revenge.

We are still hoping that he won't be Mr bad guy and actually only be out for revenge, but we will know as the story progresses.

However one has to wonder whether he is the one that told the jeweller about the jewellery and had Tara put into such a fix or whether it was barely the fact that the bangles had been recognized?

The cards are falling down

The cards that Nirmala is building a house with scatter. Rudra takes this opportunity to ignite problems. He tells Nirmala unless she sorts out MJ, Adi might lose his place on the throne, as he is fast seeing MJ take it. Nirmala becomes concerned and Rudra leaves warning her to take action before it's too late. Of course, Nirmala being not as smart as she seems to love showing herself to be decides to take action. She over hears MJ saying that he is going to Indore and like a small child runs to Bhaisaab to tell him what she knows, not realising that poor Rudra is sweating at the thought of MJ going to Indore and finding out that Rudra and Jairaj's dad is still alive. However, when Nirmala points out that if the police were to be informed MJ would be caught and put back in jail as he is not allowed to travel out of state. Of course Mr. Smarty pants gets Nirmala to inform the police of what MJ has done, thus covering his backside just in case anyone were to investigate.


The final trump card

I would rather be your enemy

And show you my love,

Than be you lover,

And show you pain.

I would rather you see the world,

Than be by my side.

My own refuse to stand by me,

Have turned me away,

So how can I be your aide?

Hate me all you want,

I won't complain,

Instead I will be behind you,

The way your shadow follows you,

I will protect you,

And be destroyed,

Thinking only of you.

Having tried everything to get Tara away from him, and now realising that she is the same girl that he is fast falling in love with, MJ decides to take action. Having received a call that the family bangles have been sold he decides to use it to his advantage and take Tara on a date. Tara on the other hand is scared as she knows what he is like, and despite Meethi's consolations, is apprehensive about the date. MJ takes her and manages to pretend to be worried about her. However he chucks her off the cliff and leaves her there to make her way back. Once she is back he accuses her of all manner of things, and out of them the one thing that would really hit home with her and make her leave, "For money you would even sleep with a man!" And as expected, Tara finally breaks and realises that she has to get out of this abusivee relationship.

Domestic Abuse Worldwide

Brilliant Saba in terms of letting women know that abuse is not to be tolerated. Saba has managed to show us abuse not in one way but in many different ways.

Husband and wife: Mj is abusing Tara and is making her feel weaker and weaker in the relationship however not wanting to hurt her FIL she is accepting this abuse. But whilst accepting it she is further falling into the trap until her friend advices her that a person that accepts abuse is more liable then the one causing it.

Mother and son: Most people would say that abuse cannot ever be possible by a woman, but they are wrong, women can emotionally, and situationally cause abuse. And that has been exactly what Nimmo darling has done to MJ throughout the years, to secure her son Adi's future, and knowing that MJ wants her to treat him like a son, she abuses the relationship by emotionally blackmailing him and by making him feel crap about his own self.

Father and Son: This has been seen recently, although currently sketchy and something that we might have read wrong, but it seems that Rudra was abused mentally and possibly physically for being different to others. He was rejected by his father, or so it seems and was made to feel inferior and to see his brother become more important than him because of the defect he has been alleged to have.

Now in all the above situations, Tara has not changed much as she is able to understand what is happening and has taken the right decision. MJ has had the love from his Baba if not from his mother, but he has always been rejected by Tauji and Nirmala.

That leaves us with Rudra, what could possibly have happened in his life to make him the way he was? He has become broken and rejected and from that he has risen back up an evil monster. Obviously if his dad has in any way or form rejected and/or abused him for being different, then he will be partly to be blamed for the way Rudra has turned out. But does that excuse Rudra's actions; is it fair for him to be the way he is? We don't think it is. One wrong does not make another wrong right. Every person has a moral compass within them and an inner voice that tells them the difference between wrong and right, and when a person supresses the right voice and follows the wrong one guiding him down the wrong path, then the person morally takes the decision to become bad. Nothing can ever excuse killing and abuse; if he were to have hurt his dad only, one would say fair enough, he hurt the person that tried to hurt him, but why is he taking revenge on many others?

My friend my foe

I was in your debt,

Until my world came tumbling down.

Betrayal is only achieved,

When you give your trust away

I held your sadness in my hands,

I showed you light,

Only to find,

You were my darkness.

I wanted to walk side by side,

I wanted to take away your pain,

Only to be left broken.

I took your hand in mine,

And without realising I was killing myself,

While breathing life into you.

As our dear friend, ddFan2012 predicted, Tara decides to run to her friend for help. Although really sad to watch her in so much pain, there was black humor as to how she runs to the very person that has been abusing her, for help.

MJ seems quite reluctant to help her, but then realizing that he has helped her all along, what would be better justice for him than to now help her runaway from himself?

If noted closely, one sees that he is quite bitter and it seems just a teeny weeny bit jealous of the friend, who really is him. Quite an ironic twist of fate we would say.

They both leave together but soon have the police on their back. MJ even gets hurt in the process in an accident, trying to get away from the police, however poor Tara assumes that her "dost" is going through all this trouble for her, when in reality he is trying to keep police out of his way. Unfortunately for him, everything crashes down when the police finally catch up and Tara is shown his picture.

At this point it is interesting to note that she is about to tell them where he is but something stops her from doing so. We believe that it is this something that will later help her to understand him better and to finally put some of the pieces together. Please note that in that instant where they are staring at each other, her with the feeling of being betrayed, and shattered innocence, and trust, and him with regret in his eyes, one can see their spark of chemistry and what binds them together.

She confronts MJ, and thank God, for once a woman finally smacked her husband. He rightly deserved it and the ringing of the slap was like a balm to our hearts. While one can understand his reasoning, the method he chose to achieve his goal was wrong. And that is still wrong. There is never any justification for abusing someone.

It should be interesting to see where it goes from here.

Will they go home and once again give Tauji the shock of his life, or will they be stuck wherever they are hiding from the police whilst MJ tries to explain to her why he did what he did?

Will they be stuck wherever they are with MJ refusing to tell her anything and pushing her away which would in turn make her realise something is up or will Saba end up surprising us once again with something different?

Thank you for reading us, and please leave us with your thoughts and comments on our view. We really appreciate all of your comments and suggestions, insights and thoughts.

Ciao, guys we hope to catch up with you soon!!!!!

AA (Rashdah & Pepper)

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.9k

Users

13

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

ddsoaps thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Once again a brilliant analysis summary. Loved loved the superb abuse take in every kind of relationship. Brillianlty shown in EBI! With you on the slap! He did slap with his abuse this was a teeny weeny physical one. MJ did dig his own 20-foot grave...so he better be prepared.

nd yeah your poems as always are apt, and just wonderful Its also hard to predict what Sabaji delivers day in day out...So wont say much...but ofcourse they do go home eventually. I am worried will we get to see Maria now? And yes Viraf is the co-writer of the show!


bright_star89 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
AWESOME Analysis , as always..👏 u summed it up so beautifully...
Its True taht the slap was deserving,, because what he did to Tara ,can have no justification...
I woudn't like her to forgive him so easily... till then I wanna see hoe Mj now deals with her...

your poems are amazing.. love reading them!😛 keep the posts coming😊

Viraf co-writes the show?? how many more talent does he have... i am falling in love with him harder and harder... this man is a Gem!

LeenaRG thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Fabulous post & agree two wrongs donot make a right & there can never be any justification for any sort of abuse, physical or mental. I hated what MJ did to Tara on so many occasions & I know i will hate what she now does to him😆 But Tara's shock, dispair & desire for revenge is very natural. In reality, i would have preferred if Tara thought this out rationally & came to the right conclusion but since this is fiction, some amount of drama & drag is necessary😆
As far as Yug is concerned, I think he will be related in some way to the elusive Radha who he thinks has been wronged by the Shekhavats maybe.
lilly thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Rashdah & Pepper thanks again for your brilliant analysis courtsey your pen every time you come up with a sixer or beyond that , I am now looking forward to reading your poetic take on the episodes with your penmenship you have again fully justified giving your take on each and every character, I am now becoming more and more addicted to the show all due to the brilliant script which has been given full justice by all the star cast
ShagufElina thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Ur poems r so nice and superb...
Good yaar
---ayesha--- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Superb post !! 👏 👏

Glad that u have covered not only the abuse given by MJ to tara but also abusive relationship between MJ and the evil mom & also Rudrapratap and his dad,,,

I think RP case his most heart touching is most realistic out of all three He is evil bcoz of all the abuse he had to bear from his own father because he was born different,,Unlike other TV shows there is an explanation on why he is the way he is,,,why he holds grudges against his own family. Saba has done a commendable job is presenting the main villian as someone who is bad because his soul has been shattered to peaces by the unequal treatment from his own father,,not just cause he wants money or power..

In MJ and Tara;s case I m glad that tara slapped him hard,,although i don' like these kinds of scenes,in this case he completely deserved it,,even his intentions were rt ,,he has crossed the line..What he has done to tara can be only called as emotional and physical violence,,,glad that she stood upto him,,

N finally in MJ n nimmo's case I just hope MJ grows a spine n tells her mom that he doesn't owe his life to nimmo just bcoz he was adopted,,I m sure that it was nt MJ's choice that he was adopted to this family,,,poor MJ 😭
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
What an awesome analysis. Your writeup is scintillating and I loved the apt poems for each situation.

The slap surely was well deserved and I am glad she slapped him before he could say something . When I heard him say Tara I was like oh no is he going to spill the beans on why he behaved the way he did .Despite the fact he has abused her will still her heart melt when she hears the reasoning. Its true his intentions were to have her go away from him so she can be lead a good life unfortunately he should have told her so. But whether she would have let go of everything if he actually spelt it out ?

The revenge mode has set in so its going to be fun to see how now she holds his feet to the fire. She too like MJ will just use the scare tactic to keep the other's heart pounding with fear. Thats what he deserves a bite of his own medicine.


AraBearxo thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Is the question about abuse or what's right or what's wrong? Well, if it is about abuse. We all abuse eac other. Physically, mentally, emotionally. Yes. It's a big bad world with bad bad people.

Now quoting myself from another thread.

" My point exactly. She has no abuse abuse to play against. Not even mental or psychological. Seriously, I don't see Tara emotional abused or psychologically. Abuse is what happened to Jhanvi from SB who was afraid to even breathe. Tara was out of the house flirting with a random stranger. Literally.

Okay, I took a test considering myself to be Tara. I couldn't even pass it. Seriously, do these people even know what abuse is that they just go abuse abuse abuse. It isn't just a word that you use on tv or some show. Tara isn't the one in an abusive relationship. If she was in an abusive one, I wonder what Arnav was when he started flinging Khushi the minute her met her. Or when he threw her down from one floor to another. No every time he moral degraded her.

http://m.helpguide.org/articles/abuse/domestic-violence -->a point or two that matches. But the number of checks is hardly two or three. And it said the more the checks the more you're abused.."

MJay was abused by TJ and his mom, you can see the effect it has on his psychology. That is harsh. TJ was abused, but not even a feminist would agree that Tara was abused. Mistreated, yes! Not abused. There's a difference. Abuse is a harsh word. It's harsh, cold and not something to play but when you decide to play with words. Just no. Physical abuse is harsh, psychological abuse destroys you and so does emotional abused. Please don't insult the word claiming that Tara ia abused. Look it up. Please.

P. S. : If what mentioned above was serious 'abuse' then Tara SLAPPING MJay would be a crime. Psht, she could even be sued by him. Yes. Or have something in court up. Or our parents threatening us and not permitting us would be abuse too. The court of law and justice has tried its best to protect us. So much so now every little act can be considered degratory. It's sad.
paljay thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
@ TM
I like to read your post, they are beautiful as well as unbiased, you look at every angle that is what makes it a great post.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".