So a promising show loses to saas-bahu drama.....

amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hi everyone,

I am a silent member of this forum although I have followed the show almost regularly.
Yesterday, I got to know Manmarziya is coming to an end n I was shocked...First Jodha Akbar n now this...
The thing that shocked me the most is this show was only four or five months old n it's coming to an end for just TRPs!!
Should they not have given some extension?

I started watching the show bcoz of Aham Sharma...but was really really impressed by the freshness of the serial...
Story of an author!! I took interest immediately...Samaira's character was a brilliant contrast to the quintessential bahus of TV who go on giving test after test to prove themselves as the ideal bahu...Kashmira was brilliant in her portrayal n I was really impressed with her acting n beauty. But I guess, the grey, vulnerable heroine is not acceptable in our country which believes only simple, middle class girls can do all the great things n city girls are always uncultured.

Then Radhika...though Monica has still a long way to go, I found her to be promising in the first episode.
All actresses go through immense transformation in the industry n I believed the same would happen to her as well.
I was impressed when the CVs gave Radhika the scope to act n behave in a way different from the typical 'middle-class goody goody heroine'. When the show's ending was declared I saw a lot of people saying a lot of things against Monica as if she herself is the director, writer n actor of the show...but that is really really unfair bcoz she's a newcomer. If veterans couldn't make a difference then how do we expect a newcomer to change things?

Shravan is simply brilliant as Neil...I have seen people here commenting on his 'girlish looks' but girlish or boyish, I loved his acting. Period. His innocent yet firm portrayal of the best friend of a vulnerable girl like Samaira was brilliant.

Finally Arjun. Well I started watching the show bcoz of him...n I think Aham has never looked better.
The spikes, the glares, the polo T-shirts...I loved him. And wat a voice.
There were moments when I felt his acting is slightly one-dimensional with the same intense looks all the time but nonetheless, I loved him as Arjun n still love him... 😳

The problem started when the CBs messed up with the storyline suddenly n from the author's story, it became the typical angry boss n talkative assistant love story...While I prefer Aham with Kashmira more, onscreen I prefer Ardhika more than Samarj.
So basically I am an Ahamira n Ardhika fan... 😆 And yes, Neil n Sam's friendship is just awesome.
Initially I was disappointed with the shifting of the story n not focussing on the author's story, but I started enjoying the serial from Lonavala track...Since then I secretly became an Ardhika shipper n saw potential in their pairing which I hadn't seen before.

One thing that impressed me most was the music. The songs of this serial are brilliant n so like those of movies.
Be it 'Aansuo bhi galti' or 'Khwaihishon mein likhi'...the songs are just so much progressive for a TV serial.


Now all that is coming to an end. It is true that the CVs had messed up the characterisations but they could have resurrected the characters by making changes in the script. Why were they not given the chance?
Personally I loved the Nandini track, Shilpa being my favourite. The only mistake they made is they made the revenge story very weak...The whole reason for Arjun to take revenge is quite shallow...They could have shown some other story...nonetheless, I liked Ardhika marriage. They could have utilized this marriage n shown something interesting but the CVs wasted it. Even then, the show had potential...despite the ruining of characters n storyline, they could have ressurrected it with better storyline...but unfortunately, they didn't get the chance.


I guess our Indian audience is still obssessed with saas-bahu mindset. Unless the female lead is giving one exam after another in her sasural n saving the day for everyone, the serial is a flop. Either it has to be a saas-bahu saga or absolute mindless youth comedy, where the lead characters have no other work than falling in love posh college settings...
Anything in between is a flop...

I guess...unless the mentality of the Indian audience changes we will never have any improvement in the quality of our shows...
Edited by amritat - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

2k

Users

9

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

MayurArti_rocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
You expressed it beautifully. After so many years i felt attached with one serial and one couple Ardhika.
Loved amidst of all this drama Radhika is still not a typical bahu who does not have any say. Loved them , still so much could have been shown.

But alas now i dont have any hope from SP. will miss this amazing and electrifying couple.
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: LoveKriyansh

You expressed it beautifully. After so many years i felt attached with one serial and one couple Ardhika.
Loved amidst of all this drama Radhika is still not a typical bahu who does not have any say. Loved them , still so much could have been shown.

But alas now i dont have any hope from SP. will miss this amazing and electrifying couple.



Thanks dear.
Although things are messed up, they could have mended it.
GoldenPanda. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Your last paragraph said it all. The modern bunch of us have to suffer because the majority of the people are still into the whole saas bahu thing with the submissive and weak female lead.
CarpediemRose thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Easter Egg Contest Winner (2023) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
U were absolutely right we r going to miss a show that has portrayed unique aspects regarding youth. I am soo sad I will miss ardhikha so much love them a lot especially ahem he was the main reason for my interest towards mmz he is an excellent actor.
Angad_Diwani thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
The thing I dont get is that this show is no. 7 rite now
And its still getting the axe.
😕

That makes no sense.


Storyline or no storyline. Why would u axe a top tenner show?
Plus, there are ads shown in the dym breaKs so we got plenty of sponsors.

Yet.

Somebody is still not satisfied.

What gives???
Edited by Angad_Diwani - 10 years ago
Greys_Anatomy thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
I guess...unless the mentality of the Indian audience changes we will never have any improvement in the quality of our shows...True indians love saas bahu shit and of course ekta aunty shows 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

MMZ is such a great show i agree it has flaws but there can be room for improvement but cvs are hell bent in shutting the show down ...neither they are promoting it nor excepting our request to change the time slot 😡😡😡😡😡😡

I agree with you Arjun revenge agenda was very poor they writers could have done more 😡😡😡😡...And Ardhika or SamArj ..Aham looks stunning woth both the girls 😳

Wish that any how MMZ does get a secend chance 😕😕😕😕😕


shivamala thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
You are 110% right. Attitude must be changed and change must be accepted by the audience. I only hope they don't bring another Ekta show in this channel.
Dangelz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Beautiful post Amrita! :)

I believe we have met in MB forum earlier, and its great to see your post here :)

I completely agree with all the points you have mentioned about this show, the actors and characters! All in all, you have summed up my feelings about this show.

Manmarziyan was a show that I was looking forward to watching, ever since I heard about Aham's comeback news. 😆 Once the show started, the concept overall appealed to me as it was fresh...and over time, I began appreciating all the 4 lead characters/actors. Even though I started watching the show for Aham, Kashmira is the one who became my favourite in this show. 😳

As the title of the show suggests, I was looking forward to watching some great friendships, love, and relationships forming and bonding in the show. The characters were well-written and shaped, and they all had their own personal charm.

I feel such a brilliant cast, specifically Kashmira, Monica, Aham and Shravan have been wasted due to the TRP demands. One of the best things about this show is that all 4 leads shared chemistry with one another. Whether it was a sizzling SamArj scene, an intense ArDhika scene, an emotional NeSam scene, a cute RaNeil scene or even a sweet Sam-Radz scene. All the actors looked great with one another in one frame. This is what I will miss the most!


PS. - I am glad I found a rare fan like myself who is a Ahamira and ArDhika fan at the same time. 😆 I thought I was the only crazy person out here who loved both.
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: GoldenPanda.

Your last paragraph said it all. The modern bunch of us have to suffer because the majority of the people are still into the whole saas bahu thing with the submissive and weak female lead.



I agree...I dont know wat is wrong with these people...At least they could have given one extension.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".