Samaira and Piyali: An Analysis!

clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hey Doston!

After today's episode, I had to do a post-mortem of the relationship that SaYali share- Samaira and Piyali. Sorry, I took the liberty of coining a portmanteau for them. 😛

Coming to Samaira and Piyali, I just wanna say that Piyali does not deserve a daughter like Sam. Frankly, when I started watching the show, I was confused as to whether Piyali really was Sam's mom, 'cause a real mother would never utter the kind of vitriol that Piyali hurled at Sam.
It actually hurt me to see Piyali spit 'I hate you" and "You should have died instead" at Sam. It was truly heart-wrenching to see a mother berate and reject her daughter like this. If you analyse the situation, I think Piyali loved and continues to love Jai more than Sam. It happens. For reasons only Piyali can fathom, Jai was clearly on top of her priority list and Sam was next..

This is not to say she didn't love Sam, just that she loved her less than Jai. So, the accident happened and all of Piyali's rage and grief found Sam as a convenient target. After all, she needed something/someone to blame for Jai's death.
A normal parent, IMO, could have been angry, even estranged for a while, but the extent to which Piyali took it makes her unworthy of being called a 'mother'. She tortured her daughter emotionally for years, while Samaira begged and pleaded for forgiveness. Nothing can be more wretched than that. Sam's pain really spoke to me and made me heart break. 🥺

Even today, the mother and daughter reconciled over Jai. It seems like Jai is a cloud that will hand over them forever. It looks like PIyali was obsessed with her son and this obsession is what swallowed her relationship with Sam whole. Even now, I doubt the cracks have fully disappeared. Though the superficial wounds have been addressed, have the internal injuries really healed? 😲
I do not think Sam and Piyali are capable of having a relationship other than a functional, working one. There is too much history and bad blood between them to justify a normal, loving parent-child relationship. However, things don't turn out the way we think they should.

Sam clearly is someone who yearns for her mother and is willing to forgive her mistakes. Do you think they can have a full relationship again?

What say guys?
Edited by clarity - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

643

Users

3

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Does no one care about Sam and Piyali? 😆
ashne thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
I'm sure one more video presentation, and internal wounds also will heal 😆

Btw, Nice analysis. Yes, it was too easy the way they made up. Only in movies and shows do sudden realizations happen. In the real world u have to work to get to that path and forgiveness is not easy for any one to do suddenly. She has build up her hate for so many yrs, it would be difficult for her to let go. That could be her one connection left with Jai - her hatred for Sam.

It would have been more appropriate if Piyali could have opened a window somewhere in her mind and then tell Sam to give her some time to process this. As a result both of them work towards reconciliation.
Edited by ashne - 10 years ago
clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ashne

I'm sure one more video presentation, and internal wounds also will heal 😆

Btw, Nice analysis. Yes, it was too easy the way they made up. Only in movies and shows do sudden realizations happen. In the real world u have to work to get to that path and forgiveness is not easy for any one to do suddenly. It would have been more appropriate if Piyali could have opened a window somewhere in her mind and then tell Sam to give her some time to process this. As a result both of them work towards reconciliation.



@bold- I agree. Would have been more realistic. Maybe that's where the CVs are heading, who knows? I hope they don't show us that everything is hunky dory between Sam and Piyali so soon. I think they will take it forward. I hope so.

Also, thank you. 😃


ElMystique thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Well not talking of their dynamics or what has happened over years and logics behind the restrained relationship .It is Sam's biggest challenge or I must say a battle she was fighting all the while to earn her mother's affection back and get over her guilt .
inner turmoil is the worst enemy .It would be great if she took time to make peace with her guilt and stand up for a fact that she wasn't wrong and secondly convince her mother .I wish this happened over a gradual course of time.As per the serial it was the biggest challenge of Sam's life.She could have found the best possible way eventually making mistakes in the due course of time and finding the best possible and plausible solution ..
talking of deserving well you have to accept your parents no matter what and make peace with them at the end of the day .So it was important for Sam to reconcile .Sam is the soul of this show 😳😳
clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: frappie

Well not talking of their dynamics or what has happened over years and logics behind the restrained relationship .It is Sam's biggest challenge or I must say a battle she was fighting all the while to earn her mother's affection back and get over her guilt .

inner turmoil is the worst enemy .It would be great if she took time to make peace with her guilt and stand up for a fact that she wasn't wrong and secondly convince her mother .I wish this happened over a gradual course of time.As per the serial it was the biggest challenge of Sam's life.She could have found the best possible way eventually making mistakes in the due course of time and finding the best possible and plausible solution ..
talking of deserving well you have to accept your parents no matter what and make peace with them at the end of the day .So it was important for Sam to reconcile .Sam is the soul of this show 😳😳



@bold- I agree. I hope the CVs take it forward and show us how SaYali find it difficult to bond with each other despite wanting to. So many years of that glacial atmosphere is bound to leave behind some deep cracks.

They can't always be talking about Jai, for sure. Piyali needs to learn to relate to her daughter as Sam, the person and not Jai's sister. The CVs can still make the reconciliation gradual by showing us how tough it is to rebuild a relationship.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".